For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.
This is the final post of the article I've titled "The New Intoxication". In this post I will wrap up the conclusion I began in the last post in this series.
Therefore as the Church, the prophetic voice of God in the world, we must be careful to view such a discussion in light of the transcendent doctrines provided in God’s revealed Word and not by the light of cultural expectations. The Scriptural principle that speaks most boldly to this topic—namely the moderation of the aesthetic and functional enjoyment of substances motivated by recreational pursuits—demands that we consider the use of “non-essentials” such as alcohol, tobacco and the like, with a level of logical consistency, taking care not to condemn their use wholesale while indiscriminately commending the use of other substances when the motivations for their uses may overlap. On the other hand, the use of prescription and other drugs perceived “essential” should likewise be considered, especially since in many cases they are no less intoxicating than the substances used recreationally and in fact, it is their intoxicating properties which lead to their prescription in order to affect mood-alteration, behavioral change, or ease physical pain. While being guided by Scriptural principles we must always remain informed by the current medical wisdom and the needs of a person’s well being. Simultaneously all of us, especially Christians, must resist the temptation to impress our own strictly cultural expectations upon the consciences of others in different and perhaps even opposing cultures, especially where those other cultural expectations only disagree with our own, and are not incongruent with the expectations of Scripture.
Though this is the final official post for this article, I for one am sure my engagement of the study of this topic is far from over. Ever learning, and hopefully, always coming to the truth.
In this post I will begin to conclude the article I've titled "The New Intoxication".
I for one do not think there is enough Scriptural evidence to warrant a command of the universal abstinence of any substance in particular. The issue is far too nuanced for that. It isn't like sex before marriage or polygamy where we can make moral pronouncements that apply to humanity as a whole, transcending time and cultures. This principle should govern our thoughts at least on the topic of the consumption of substances motivated by recreational use, such as it should for the use of psycho-active drugs prescribed by neurologists, psychiatrists and other qualified medical specialists. The issue here will be one of legality and the general consensus of current medical wisdom. Because of its high-profile character, the degree of intoxication it causes with minimal use, and its recent enjoyment of some medical application, I'm considering in the use of marijuana for pain relief, glaucoma, or whatever other use medical professionals deem appropriate. Bearing in mind this substance in particular, I don't think we can sustain philosophical consistency while we reject (all legal aspects of the discussion aside) any and all medical uses of THC. Likewise, in cultures where cannibinoids are legal, we should be careful not to condemn their use absolutely but instead, the Church should maintain that drunkenness is the sin, not consumption. So in the end why are chemicals such as THC and alcohol not functionally interchangeable with prescription anti-depressants? Though the Church should take care not to speak hypocritically or inconsistently on the matter, I do believe there are good reasons to say that the two chemical substances (as they represent similar medicinal and recreational substances) should not be treated the same regarding their use. Several reasons: the different ends of the spectrum of synthesis that they occupy—anti-depressants typically on the highly synthetic end and alcohol typically on the more natural end. Anti-depressants have very little if any aesthetic value while alcohol has a great deal of aesthetic value. Alcohol for instance is a more commercial product promoted as functionally and aesthetically recreational, so its use tends to be recreational. Prescription anti-depressants and other such pharmaceuticals, though they too now are advertised, cannot be bought at the local grocery store and do not have aesthetic value through flavor or aroma, they do not compliment a meal; they do not have an aesthetic value of that sort, thus their use tends to be more clinical on the popular level. Culturally speaking then, alcohol and prescription drugs are not interchangeable at the point of their use. However, the distinctions I’ve just made do not transcend all cultures, but the principles in the Bible do.
In the next post in this series I will wrap up my conclusion to this article.
In the last post in this series I concluded my plea for consistent thought regarding the topic at hand and in this post I intend to make a brief assesment of the Church's consideration of the topic of the consumption of intoxicating substances.
One of the greatest problems surrounding the AmericanChurch’s consideration of the topic of intoxication seems to be one of classification and legalization. The legal restrictions of a substance’s use capitalize on, or necessarily create and reinforce its cultural taboo. While at the same time, these restrictions also generate rebellion. Alternatively, the legal permissiveness and the accepted medicinal efficacy of a substance tends to legitimize its use, even in the face of information that might prove it to be of more physical, emotional and thus societal harm than good. So when a substance is illegal then it is difficult for us to see any medicinal value it may have and when a substance is regarded by the popular culture as medically necessary then it is difficult for many of us to accept its possible negative repercussions. In yet other cases a substance may become illegal in a society solely because it has first become culturally disapproved. This very article and the promotion of similar philosophies in other venues, some would argue, lends to the legitimization of the use of substances which in their view should remain forbidden in all cases—consider for example the perception of tobacco use in America. As the Church considers the topic of intoxication, we must also remember the largeness of our world and know that simply because a substance in one country is illegal or culturally disapproved, or both, doesn't mean that its use is universally immoral. Even so, we also must concede that it is immoral to break laws to use a substance which may, even wrongly so, be scheduled as illicit—it isn't likely that being asked to refrain from any substance would be equal to asking one to sin. Also, just because a culture condones the moderate use of a substance does not mean that it is rightly permitted or that its use is universally moral.
In the next post in this series I will begin a two part conclusion to this article, "The New Intoxication".
In the last post in this series which makes up the article I've called, "The New Intoxication", I began to make a plea for consistent thought when it comes to the way we, the Church in particular, address the consumption of intoxicating substances, regardless of motive. In this post I will conclude that plea.
Though it may seem so, I'm really not trying to make the case for the use of any of the substances I’ve mentioned. I am merely trying to make the case for a biblically consistent philosophy regarding these matters when it comes to the prophetic voice of the Church. It is of paramount importance that we, especially when we must be involved in the condemnation of even the moderate use of a substance, attempt to remain as consistent as possible when we counteract cultural practices. Essentially, and from God's perspective, hypocrisy is no less a sin than addiction. So the Church's' voice is tainted in the eyes of our culture when we maintain blatant inconsistencies. Not to suggest that our doctrine and practice are to be tailored to cultural expectations, but there is no need in adding offence to the message of the Cross, especially when even Christians disagree over an issue such as this. This question has thus been begged: is it inconsistent to insist that the medically motivated use of prescription drugs, for albeit controversially diagnosed illnesses, is permissible while even the moderate consumption of alcohol or tobacco, for recreational reasons is in all cases forbidden? Perhaps that category of professed believers who claims both of the above items does not exist—a category in which persons are "T-totalers" when it comes to certain substances but fully agreeable when it comes to the medical use of others. For instance, when the same group denounces the use of alcohol for any reason yet supports the use of prescribed pharmaceuticals for depression or hyper-activity, I think the possibility for inconsistency blossoms. Conversely when a group, for theological reasons, condemns the use of any psychoactive drug yet sees no reason to condemn the use of alcohol or tobacco for recreational reasons, inconsistency in that case may tend to lead to hypocrisy. So I say yes, it is inconsistent to insist on abstaining from the use of alcohol while at the same time, obliging the use of prescription drugs for depression and hyperactivity.
Bearing all that in mind, I believe it is the wisdom of God that tells the Church that adding offense to the most offensive event of human history, the life and passion of Christ the God-Man and to the good news He brings the world is unnecessary, not to mention wrong. But I must admit the guilt of adding such offense to the gospel, if not surrounding this topic, then certainly involving some other topic where I've used my personal preferences like we are supposed to use God's Law.
In the next post in this series I will make an assesment of this topic based on the discussion I've presented so far.
In the last post in this series I took a look at the motivation to use intoxicating substances with which this article primarily deals—medical reasons. At this point I'd like to begin to observe the inconsistency with which most of us approach this topic and make a plea, for the Church anyway, from the special revelation of God, for us to consider this topic very carefully; and for the rest of the world, by the revelation of God's wisdom that all can enjoy through what we know to be true in nature, to make the very same careful considerations.
In addition to the motives behind use, it is also the purpose of this article to compare and contrast the "nonessential" ingestion of drugs to what is increasingly alleged as their "essential" use for the purpose of what is professed to be an improved quality of life. So in light of the Scriptural teaching of the moderate use of alcohol (and by extension, other “non-essential” substances), how is the Church to view the use of medically “essential” substances such as mao inhibitors or even medicinal marijuana? And as related inquiries: why don’t we tolerate the use of alcohol as an antidepressant the same way much of the Church tolerates the use of Prozac or Paxil? Is it unacceptable to use those drugs in moderately recreational ways as alcohol is used? Why also, where legal of course, is it objectionable to moderately use marijuana to modify mood or behavior, or to ease the bitterness of those who are suffering physically and emotionally, or to anesthetize the dying? As we consider these questions we must also admit that it is different to suggest or condone the use of a substance such as marijuana as a mood altering medication than it is to suggest its use in a situation where a person is dying of cancer and the pain is lessened in some small way by its use. Mood-alteration lends itself to the highly subjective “art” of trying to improve one’s quality of life, while the use of pain killers and other such drugs during death is a less speculative way to ease one’s suffering at a hopeless stage, and is widely accepted in nearly all cultures which probably lends credibility to its wisdom via “creational” or general revelation. Additionally, in the case of marijuana in particular, the method of use must also be considered. There is a substantial difference in the inhalation of its smoke and taking a pill containing THC isolated from the plant. In the case of alcohol, coffee and tobacco, as I mentioned earlier, they have an aesthetic value that synthetic anti-depressants and other mood-altering drugs such as Ritalin do not have. So it also is with substances such as marijuana, cocaine, opium, heroin, and the like. Though they have a functionally recreational value (right or wrong) they do not have in my estimation—which I believe to be grounded in Scripture—any aesthetic recreational worth. Also, due to the degree and quality of intoxication that is produced by their minimal use (which in a sense causes the tendency for their abuse) those substances are almost impossible to use moderately. And I am not speaking of moderation in the sense of occasional use, but moderation in the sense of limited intoxication at even one use. As Americans I believe we tend to think of and accept medicines as being more likely synthetic and substances that are intended for aesthetically recreational use are less likely synthetic. What is more is that substances such as cocaine, heroin, morphine and opium are further down the spectrum of synthesis thus making their use more culturally accepted in medical applications than in recreational applications; whereas less synthesized substances such as alcohol and tobacco, due in some measure to their intrinsic properties, are more likely regarded by the culture as recreational—both in the functional and aesthetic sense. This would, in addition to the limited application of their function, tend to delegitimize the use of synthetic medications as aesthetically recreational, both from a cultural and biblical perspective. Some cultures that are less consumer-driven or which do not have the same taboos in place may not see a functional distinction between the use of alcohol and say, Prozac. If the fact that Prozac and Paxil and other prescription drugs are synthetic does play into the cultural consideration, then we should all ask if humanity wasn’t better off fighting melancholy and anxiety with an occasional glass of wine or mug of beer. But to exhaust that inquiry would of course require the entire scope of another article.
The next post will conclude the plea for consistency.
In the previous post in this series I discussed the issue of being motivated by aesthetic and functional recreation. In this post I will address what is likely my most controversial treatment of motivations to the use of intoxicating substances, namely the motive of medicine. I will close this portion of the article "The New Intoxication" with a few concluding thoughts on motives. Motivation by Medicine: a growing number of Americas at least, find themselves in this category. This is the motive that this article primarily intends to look into. The use of psychoactive drugs as the medically prescribed treatments for a variety of ailments has grown in popularity in countries where their people can afford such treatment, but at least in the United States it has generally been supplemented in the last 40 years by some form of psychiatric treatment, the evaluation of that treatment on the whole will be left for the consideration of another article. In any case I think it can be said that more and more people have personally been prescribed or know someone who has been prescribed a controlled substance in order to effect some sort of desired change in mood, state of mind or behavior.
I think it can be said without controversy that, individuals who consume intoxicating substances, from caffeine to morphine, do so for a variety of reasons. In fact, there are legitimate reasons for consuming a variety of substances. But it can also be said that one person’s use is usually backed by a combination of motivations for which they consume prescription drugs and other chemicals, illicit or not—depending on the cultural setting: one may take a “prescription” drug for medical or for recreational reasons; similarly another person may take an illicit or culturally disapproved substance for either recreational or medical reasons.
In the next post in this series, I will begin to discuss the inconsistency with which both the Church and the unbelieving world address the topic of the consumption of intoxicating substances.
I believe this is probably the most popular reason for useing intoxicating substances, at least in Western societies. This post has to do with the motive of recreation.
Motivation by Recreation: this category can be broken down into two classes, functional and aesthetic. The driving purpose behind this person’s desire to consume certain substances may be functional—for reasons of celebration or even purely for one's own physical pleasure, providing a means to "feel good" or drunkenness. Still others find that certain substances provide an aesthetic pleasure as a food product harmonizing with and complimenting a meal. While the aesthetic classification is probably limited to beers, wines, certain liquors, cigars and the like, the functional category could even extend to, and most likely is, one’s motivation to use drugs that are found on the United States list of Schedule I controlled substances, of which chemicals it is the general medical and psychiatric opinion that their potential for abuse is very high.
In the next post in this series I plan to discuss the use of intoxicating substances motivated by medical reasons.
The last post in this series considered the desire to use intoxicating substances as motivated by ritualistic practices. In this post I will discuss the motivation by sustenance.
Motivation by Sustenance: in other parts of the world, not so much now but very broadly in the past, persons had been motivated to consume alcoholic beverages because the drinking water was so widely contaminated that it was much simpler to consume products preserved by fermentation than to try to decontaminate a water source. It might be reasonable to say that this form of motive has lead in some cases to the motivation by culture, but is not reasonable extended in principle to other chemicals such as tobacco, caffeine or opiates.
The next post in this series will consider motivation by recreation.
In the last post in this series I opened up the discussion of possible motivations for the use of intoxicating substances. As I continue now with the discussion of the motivation by ritual, I'd like to point out that this list I've generated is by no means exhaustive. As I believe I already said, there are probably as many motives for an action as there are persons acting.
Motivation by Ritual: this type of motivation is closely linked to the motivation by culture and in some ways would be a sub-category of it. Often referred to as the ethnogenic use of drugs, many people in the past and today are enticed to drug use through their implementation in religious ceremonies. Many such substances involved in these types of rituals are illegal in the US (Opium, marijuana, Peyote, DMT, and Psilocybin Mushrooms) and others are culturally discouraged (Salvia and others). Historically, and for obvious reasons, these substances had been extracted by interested persons from plant material. This motivation is also closely related to the motivation based on physical sensation because in such ritual use it is believed that the chemical alteration of the state of mind and the feelings induced on the body have an element of supernatural or otherworldly cause. Those using certain substances in a religious manner may try to explain the experience this way: that some supernatural being or force uses the drug as a means to communicate through its effects. This motive is not exclusive to cultures in third world countries or secluded villages in New Guinea or Central America. Knowledge of such practices, likely combined with other motives, has generated sub-cultures even in the US in the last 60 years or so. In both the Beatnik and Hippie movements (which have experienced a sort of revival in the last 20 years) one would find individuals who use drugs (illicit or otherwise) to induce an altered state of mind, coupling it perhaps with some other sort of shamanistic or even Eastern religious practice such as transcendental meditation.
In the next post in this series I plan to discuss the motivation by sustenance.
In the last post in this series I endeavored to describe the core topic that this article purposes to discuss., and in the next several posts I will outline a few of the motives that may be behind the use of intoxicating substances. This post will be the first, wherein I attempt to uncover the motivation by culture.
The first issue to address in the line of questioning set before us at the end of the last post is the motivation behind taking any drug. Note here that the purview of this article however is not to condone or condemn the consumption of the substances mentioned, but it is to, in large part; examine the variety of motivations that lead to that consumption. Realistically speaking there are probably as many motivations for an action as there are individuals acting, but for the purpose of this article I will attempt to boil them down into several major categories.
Motivation by Culture: particularly in other parts of the world: Italy, France, Germany, Spain and even parts of Asia, individuals will find themselves having a glass of wine or a beer at dinner simply because of traditional or environmental reasons. They have no preconceived notion that it would be wrong to have a drink at dinner, and their parents did the same thing...it simply isn't taboo.
In the next post I will take up another motive: ritual.
In the previous post I introduced a discussion of the topic of the consumption of substances, moderation and the like.
Now on to the essential matter of this article, the "new" intoxication—are we being intoxicated by prescription drugs? Sometime around the middle of the 19th century the overuse of drugs, for various reasons, became endemic in parts of Europe and America. We must survey this periodic occurrence through time where cultures have driven their societies to destruction because of gluttonous behavior. Some historians would argue that this was one causes of the fall of the Roman Empire. In any case, since the dawn of modern history opiates, their derivatives and other sorts of intoxicants have been harvested and used for various reasons: as a physical, mental and emotional anesthetic (including a way to escape reality), sedation, religious ceremonies and general recreation. Now, largely due to the amount of money poured into the research and development of drugs as a result of the exponential increase of consumer demand and scientific technological advancements, mental alteration has become an industry of medicine. Rightly or wrongly, no one can doubt the far-reaching promulgation of and desire for prescription drugs that function as chemical agents for behavioral change, mood alteration, and the curbing or elimination of depression, especially in the affluence of Northern Europe, Canada and America. This popular desire brings into question the real difference between ingesting alcohol or even illicit drugs and ingesting prescription mood-altering drugs for what may in some cases be the same purpose. Are there different reasons for taking either classification of drugs, do their effects accommodate the motives behind their particular use, and are their effects substantially different? I will attempt to answer in some way, a couple of these questions, but the others are asked simply to generate thoughtful discussion of this topic among God’s people.
In the next post I plan to continue the discussion by introducing the topic of the motivations of consumption.
In the next several posts I plan to discuss the sensitive topic of consumption. This post will serve as the introduction to the discussion. In subsequent posts I plan to present the core topic, motivations for the use of different substances, a plea for consistency, my assesment, and concluding remarks.
The term "intoxication" in its biblical category is generally thought of as the altered mental state acquired by ingesting chemicals made, in part, to do just that. Alcohol (beer, wine and strong drink), being the most commonly mentioned in Scripture, will also be the term I use by default, to include any intoxicating substance. Even so, we must observe that there have for millennia been people who have ingested other substances in addition to alcohol with the intent of altering their mental state. In the comparison I'm about to make as the article is meted out, I don't want to imply that the degree or quality of intoxication by these different substances is the same (in some cases it isn't even similar) but I have felt that their common effects and the common motives behind taking them deem it necessary to make at least that much of a comparison. I do also want to point out my lack of knowledge regarding the specific uses of some prescription drugs or for that matter, the chemical make-up of any drug, so my comparisons between the specific chemical effects of alcohol and anti-depressants may not be scientifically engaged but the principles I'm trying to promote beg forgiveness for any pharmaceutical misunderstanding.
Arguably the Scriptural warnings against the abuse of alcohol can be extended to any substance that intoxicates. Warnings of drunkenness can be applied to drunkenness brought on by any substance capable of causing it. So for instance when Paul says in Eph. 5:18,"...do not be drunk on wine, for it is debauchery, be filled with the Holy Spirit", in principle we are able to exchange wine for any substance that acts similarly on our bodies. That admonition and other warnings are often, and as they should be, framed in the principle of moderation. If substances are ingested in moderation, even if a mild degree of intoxication is obtained, then their use in and of themselves is not explicitly prohibited.
In the wisdom literature of the Old Testament the use of alcohol is at times prescribed and at other times prohibited, but not universally in either case. In passages such as Ps. 104:15 and Prov. 3:10, alcohol is prescribed for our physical bodies wherein it is viewed as a generally good substance which makes the heart glad. And in Prov. 31:6 it is prescribed as a physical and mental anesthetic—a pain-killer and a mood-lifter of sorts. As a more eschatological benefit, just as milk and honey were the tactile substances that enticed the Jews to their physical land, in 2 Kings 18 our sense of taste is used to entice our desires toward the Ultimate Land (the New Heavens and New Earth) therein described as a Land where the olives groves flourish and there are stores of grain and wine—it is expressed as a treasure symbolic of the benefits of future Kingdom life. On the other hand many passages provide warnings of the dangers of alcohol, as though it is such a good thing that it is easily abused, just like food with which it is sometimes coupled in warnings against gluttony. Prov. 20:1, 21:17, and 23:20 all point out the pitfalls of overuse.
So we should be sober-minded as we consider what the Scriptures have to say about the use of alcohol and by extension, other similarly intoxicating substances. We should also be careful not to unnecessarily condemn or promote its use or those who use it in moderation, lest we speak more strongly about it than Scripture or become hypocrites as we ignore our own overindulgent behaviors.
In the next post I plan to describe the core topic at hand.
Like a worm on a hook
Like a knight from some old fashioned book
I have saved all my ribbons for thee
If I have been unkind
I hope that you can just let it go by
If I have been untrue
I hope you know it was never to you
Like a baby, stillborn
Like a beast with his horn
I have torn everyone who reached out for me
But I swear by this song
And by all that I have done wrong
I will make it all up to thee
I saw a beggar leaning on his wooden crutch
He said to me, "You must not ask for so much"
And a pretty woman leaning in her darkened door
She cried to me, "Hey, why not ask for more?"
Like a bird on the wire
Like a drunk in a midnight choir
I have tried in my way to be free."
These are the words of one of my favorite musicians, Leonard Cohen, from his song “Bird on a Wire”. As I listened to this song for the first time in a long while the stanza, “But I swear by this song and by all that I have done wrong; I will make it all up to thee”, really hit me in a different way than it ever had before. Perhaps because, since I have been considering theology more closely now than when I had first begun to examine Cohen’s lyrics, I thought of the way God promised Moses that He would lead the people out of Egypt. Moses asked who he should tell the people sent him as their deliver and God answered, “Tell them, I AM sent you.”; for there is no other name greater than Yahweh. And before that, God swore to Abraham about which the author of Hebrews makes this comment “13For when God made a promise to Abraham, since he had no one greater by whom to swear, he swore by himself, 14saying, "Surely I will bless you and multiply you." 15And thus Abraham, having patiently waited, obtained the promise. 16For people swear by something greater than themselves, and in all their disputes an oath is final for confirmation. 17So when God desired to show more convincingly to the heirs of the promise the unchangeable character of his purpose, he guaranteed it with an oath, 18so that by two unchangeable things, in which it is impossible for God to lie, we who have fled for refuge might have strong encouragement to hold fast to the hope set before us.” Likewise in the stanza I set apart, Cohen swears by two certain things: the existence of the words of the very song in which the oath is made and by the certainty of things wrongly done; if one thing we do in this life is certain it is doing things wrong. So an oath by the things we have done wrong contains two aspects to observe: the promise is in the certainty of the words of the swearing itself (sort of: “I promise by this promise that I will…”) and the great irony of making a promise on broken promises. In essence Cohen promises to make up for all that he has done wrong by swearing on the historical certainty of all that he has done wrong. And the promise rests on the honor of the song, by the truth of the song itself, he will make up for all he has done wrong. Circular and self-attesting as it may be, the words are gripping and their beauty may lie in their honest arrogance.
In light of my current study on progressive sanctification I'd like to draw this particular series of articles to a close, appropriately so I think, by addressing the idea of the assurance of pardon. Lest you think that I believe I've exhausted any study of the topic, I reserve the right to contemplate what the Bible says about sanctification and assurance in some later series with a slightly different focus.
Assurance is a tricky thing, especially when a local church takes the Law and the depravity of man very seriously. Many such churches also don't, in my opinion, take the administration of the Lord's Supper seriously enough, so coupled together the "smoldering wick and bruised reed" may be harshly treated. Some churches don't see The Lord's Supper as a means God has ordained to distribute sanctifying grace by showing us once again the drama of election, effectual calling, regeneration, faith, justification, adoption, sanctification, preservation and glorification, played out before our eyes as it is framed in the New Covenant Passover meal where the Lamb's life of righteousness and passion on the behalf of all who believe is displayed. If that church also finds it difficult to see Christ in all of Scripture, and doesn't see the practicality of the benediction—reminding its people at or near the end of the service that God has forgiven all the sins of all those who believe and His wrath is never upon them—then the believer doesn't go away assured, in fact their faith may even be desperately challenged that whole week because they know the can't live up to God's Law, they heard that on Sunday. What they didn't hear was that Christ lived up to it for them.
I suppose this is the place to mention that balance and serious inquiry into the pertinent biblical texts is required when approaching this topic because there are passages that indicate, as the WCF puts it, that God's "Fatherly displeasure" will be on His children who disobey. Not that His wrath is directed towards them, because Christ swallowed the entire contents of that cup on the cross, but like an earthly father He is not forced to disown His children when He chooses, for their own good mind you, to discipline them. So to wrap up my thoughts on the topic for now I'd say this. The warnings found in the New Testament in particular are very real, and so is the accomplishment of Christ's blood. I've formulated a syllogism to illustrate: Believers do persevere to the end by faith, through the struggle against their sin. Unbelievers face eternal separation from God in Hell. If, by faith, you do not struggle against your sin to the end, you face eternal separation from God in Hell.
Having said that though, go you child of God and hear this, "The Lord bless you and keep you; the Lord make His face shine upon you and be gracious to you; the Lord lift up His countenance upon you and give you peace." (Num. 6:24-26)
"If we are turned around to get back down to earth by grace, then it would seem that true sanctification would show itself in taking care of our neighbor and God’s creation, not exploiting and destroying either for our own ends, religious or otherwise. It would mean concern for the neighbor and society, caring for the other for the time being. Here one should talk about the place of morality and virtue and such things. Although we do not accept them as the means by which we are sanctified, they are the means by which and through which we care for the world and for the other. This is what the Reformers meant when they insisted that good works were to be done, but one was not to depend on them for salvation."
Here Forde rightly categorizes virtue and morality to such things as “concern for the neighbor and society” and “taking care of our neighbor and God’s creation”. The prescription to do these things is explicitly Law and neither Forde nor Reformed theology suggests we lean on our doing of them as the merit or assurance of our pardon. Only the repetition of the gospel can give us assurance in the midst of our struggle against sin, and only the repetition of the gospel can cause the type of life change that acts on such commands as to love one’s neighbor as oneself and to love God above all else.
In conclusion I’d like to reiterate Forde’s thesis that, “Sanctification, if it is to be spoken as something other than justification is perhaps best defined as the art of getting used to the unconditional justification wrought by the grace of God for Jesus’ sake.” Perhaps it is stated in typical Lutheran hyperbole, but in this thesis Forde indicates that a distinction should not be made between justification and sanctification, except to say that sanctification is the “art of getting used to” being justified by grace alone. Reformed theology certainly disagrees with the idea that the two shouldn’t be distinguished. Justification is historically spoken of as the momentary event when God declares one righteous before His holiness on account of Christ’s merit. And sanctification, though it has its moment of eventfulness (John 17:19; Acts 20:32, 26:18; 1 Cor. 1:2, 6:11; 2 Tim. 2:21; Heb. 2:11, 10:10; Jude 1:1), has been referred to additionally (and in distinction to justification) as a process toward glory—and as support, scriptures that say we are “being conformed to the image of Christ” (Rom. 12:1-3), and “being made” like the Son of God (Phil. 3:8-11), or “being made perfect or holy” (Gal. 3:3; Heb. 10:14). Forde agrees with the Reformed position in that whatever progress in sanctification, whatever obedience is rendered in the believer’s life is due to the pouring out of the unconditional grace of God. So it is right not only to express justification as being by grace alone through faith in Christ alone but also to speak of sanctification as being by grace alone through faith in Christ alone.
Also, whatever spontaneous care-taking we see in our lives, or humility we express regarding our sanctification is still a measurement against the Law and should not be used as an agent of assurance. Only that historical fact of Christ’s life for our life and death for our death can assure us of our adoption and give us hope of a future freedom from even the desire to sin. Though our good works, to which believers were in fact predestined, are evidence to others of some difference about us, and though they may serve to a certain degree as a confirmation of faith along with continued repentance and belief, even they are tainted and marred by Adam’s indelible mark. As it was once penned in a Puritan prayer…”I need to repent of my repentance, I need my tears to be washed”. I believe we would do well to be reminded of the depth of our sin so the gospel of Christ grows increasingly sweeter thus we are assured because of its certainty.
"The second aspect of the transition of the Christian from old to death to life, is that all our ordinary views of progress and growth are turned upside down. It is not that we are somehow moving toward the goal, but rather that the goal is moving closer and closer to us. This corresponds to the eschatological nature of the New Testament message. It is the coming of the kingdom upon us, not our coming closer to or building up the kingdom. That is why it is a growth in grace, not a growth in our own virtue or morality. The progress, if one can call it that, is that we are being shaped more and more by the totality of the grace coming to us. The progress is due to the steady invasion of the new. That means that we are being taken more and more off our own hands, more and more away from self, and getting used to the idea of being saved by the grace of God alone. Our sanctification consists merely in being shaped by, or getting used to, justification."
In my opinion there is very little if any to disagree with in the above statement, assuming the way Forde frames the progress of sanctification, as the Kingdom coming ever closer to the justified man, means that it carries the broad idea of our going from justification to glorification through sanctification. He mentions at the first, the progress from the old man—the death of the old man—to new man, so there is a progression of sorts. But the matter that needs to be worked out is whether the new man is capable of sin or if he, by virtue of his new position in Christ, is not, and perhaps it is only the old man warring against him. If by having our ideas of progress and growth turned upside down, Forde does NOT mean the new man does NOT sin then I agree with his description. The concept of “compatibilism” also comes to mind, thus I’ve included these posts in that category on the blog. On monergism.com, B.B. Warfield is quoted as defining the term this way, “Compatibilism (also known as soft determinism), is the belief that God’s predetermination and meticulous providence is “compatible” with voluntary choice.” The term is generally thought of in regards to regeneration but it really covers the entire realm of human choice, which also includes our choices as believers, to obey and experience that moment of sanctification or disobey and not. Our choices to obey God’s Law and leading are mysteriously and sometimes strangely compatible with the foreordination of God that we either do or do not conform to that Law. We make real choices according to our present and most aggressive affection or desire—in fact we must operate that way, for the only factors constraining our “creaturely” free choices are our affections or desires and God’s perfect knowledge of our future choices. It is here I would like to draw the distinction between the indicative or positional and experiential natures of the believer’s sanctification. On the one hand the New Testament says that we are or already have been sanctified or set apart (John 17:19; Acts 20:32, 26:18; 1 Cor. 1:2, 6:11; 2 Tim. 2:21; Heb. 2:11, 10:10; Jude 1:1). When we were regenerated we were set apart to God. On the other hand, sanctification seems to be the progress through the interim period between justification and glorification, as the New Testament says, but not in as many places, we are being sanctified (1 Thess. 4:3; Heb. 10:14). So it is imperative that we obey God’s Law and be sanctified. At the risk of sounding politically incorrect, consider the following event as an analogy because most of us can relate to the emotion of it. During a bank robbery a woman is held hostage and the thief calls for the male security guard cowering in the corner to go to the safe, but in his angst he can’t move. Finally one of the other customers calls out to him and says, “…be a man!” The fact that the guard was petrified in the corner did not change his gender, during the entire episode he was a man. His gender hadn’t suddenly changed as his fear overtook him. But the other customer was encouraging him to fulfill in action, the position he already occupied.
Reformed theology would agree that the progress of sanctification is not the growth of our own virtue, but what does “being shaped more and more by the totality of the grace coming to us” mean except that our actions change? To be sure, the shaping would include at the very least an increase of repentance and belief over the entire period of “sanctification” in a believer’s life, but I am coming to the conclusion that it can’t be that alone. Even in Forde’s description of what being shaped by grace means he puts up life change as a sign of the growth; change which can only really be measured against the Law of God unless one sets up another tablet of prescribed actions in its place. But we would agree that any change made in that direction is not of our own conjuring but of the Kingdom coming upon us in the person of the Holy Spirit, and I would add, by whom we have been sanctified, and by whom we are being sanctified, or growing by grace, into our new position. Like someone who has been hired as a product developer who has never performed in that capacity before, even though he is called the Vice President of Product Development he must grow into the position as his actions change to reflect his title.
Below is the continued discussion of Forde's article on the Lutheran view of sanctification.
"So it is impossible to put God's unconditional act of justifying sinners for Jesus' sake alone together with our ideas of progress based on conditions. It doesn't work either logically or in the life of faith."
At least in the reformed camp, sanctification is not a work of man for God, but a work of God for man. Not even the regenerate man who in Christ is, before his glorification, made posse peccatore—who has the possibility to not sin in a given moment—can render to God without grace, the good works for which he has been foreordained. So perhaps it is against another non Reformed theory of sanctification that Forde is arguing, because Reformed theology agrees, “progress [in sanctification] based on conditions” is as improbable as God’s very plan for one’s life coming about by conditions. I believe the correct way to look at the relationship between the transpiring of God’s plan for our lives and our willingness to be guided into that plan by His wisdom is the same as the relationship between prayer and God’s actions, and the relationship between our obedience and the progress of our sanctification. Our “willingness”, prayers, and obedience are means to the ends ordained by God: His plans and our salvation, and He has ordained the means as well.
"So it is always as a totality that unconditional grace attacks sin. That is why total sanctification and justification are in essence the same thing."
This is where, I guess, my confessionalism shines and my love for historical theology and the weight I think they both should carry for subsequent believers is manifest. I don’t think that there is in any way that we can say that justification and sanctification are “essentially the same thing”. The Protestant Reformers were very careful to distinguish the two: justification as an event in time where the believer is declared righteous before God on the grounds of Christ’s work, and through faith—which is also the gift of God—and sanctification being the process or series of events between justification and glorification. The purpose of Martin Luther pointing this out in the 16th century was to challenge the Roman Catholic high-sacramentalism and the working out of the doctrine of salvation (specifically justification) to reform from a process wherein the covenant child was baptized, having original sin washed away producing the state of tabula rasa (blank slate), maintaining that state revived in continued cleansing of venial sins through the sacrament of the Eucharist, and finally the believer paying for his remaining sins in Purgatory, to an event which the description thereof was encapsulated in the five “solas”. So for a Lutheran to imply through a confusing statement that justification is perhaps a process is unfortunate. Certainly Forde would consider himself Protestant, even at his description of the differences of justification and sanctification, but denying any difference between justification and sanctification at their essence seems to me to be unhelpful. Even if his motive is altruistic, assuming it is to protect individuals from measuring their progress in grace up against to Law, or using the Law to try to find assurance of their justification by emphasizing the fact that we have been set apart and made holy, acquiring all the righteousness we need to stand before God our Father. But to jettison the idea of any actual warning to the Christian to make sure your calling and election is sure, and to render the New Testament imperatives impotent is not going to protect individuals from legalism, nor does it do justice to the text. Pastor Reggie Kimbro has said that when one finds himself to be a legalist he doesn’t need to remedy the situation by becoming a little more antinomian, likewise when one finds himself a bit too antinomian the prescription is not to become a little bit more legalistic to balance one’s self. So what is the answer, how do we protect ourselves from falling off the right side of the horse into the error of legalism or falling off the left side into the error of antinomianism? That will be a question to be answered toward the end of the discussion.
"Conditional thinking is wedded to the schemes of law and progress characteristics of this age. Sin is understood primarily as misdeed or transgression of such a scheme...The logic would then be that with the help of grace one progressively gains more and more righteousness and thus sins less and less. One strives toward perfection until, theoretically, one would need less and less grace or perhaps finally no more grace at all."
"Whose fault is it if the scheme doesn't work?...Either I have not properly responded to or cooperated with the free divine grace, or most frightening of all, the God of election who presides over such grace has decided, in my case, not to give it."
Again we hear in the above statements the visceral groaning of pastoral concern…to which I most certainly can relate. However, the total relegation of one’s progress in sanctification or growth in Christ to the “scheme of law and progress characteristic only of this age” is far too simple a distinction. Protestants of all shapes and sizes are jealous to separate Law & Gospel in some degree. The idea behind the Reformed view of sanctification through the mortification of sin is not one of conditionality: if I mortify sin, then God gives me more righteousness, but one of imputation as with justification: Christ lived in perfect obedience to the Law, meriting my righteous standing before God and died to pay the debt I merit with sins I commit even after I’ve been justified. So I am at war within myself to do real good, good that is a result of a holy standing before a holy God, not to retroactively merit what God has already done for me in justification but because God has predestined those whom He has justified, to actually do good works.
The term “conditional thinking” can be defined contextually as the idea that, if believers obey God’s Law, then they will be sanctified, thus considered holy. Forde goes on to define sin according to those who promote such a scheme, as the transgression of that if/then system. In my own mind, I agree that if one is lead to believe that they are left to perform in this scenario without the gracious provision of God, then he has been misled. But, like God’s use of means in the regeneration of individuals (Rom. 10) and the means of atonement
Assuming the correctness of the particular view of sanctification which Forde is fighting (which I don’t believe Reformed theology does), that the regenerated person “gains more and more righteousness” thus striving toward a theoretical perfection, I believe Forde is right to surmises that that individual might need less and less grace because of his performance. But this exposes Forde’s presupposition, at least at this point, that free divine grace isn’t the driving factor of the mortification of sin and calls to mind Paul’s words in Romans 6 that we should not sin more and more so that grace may abound more and more, God forbid. The fact is that grace abounds really in the life of a believer whether (in the eyes of man or his own eyes) he is conformed or lacked to be conformed to the Law of God. Grace abounds over a sinner saved by it regardless of the degree of fruit he produces. The most outwardly and inwardly obedient child of God has no more righteousness before Him that the technically worst sinner among the Kingdom. If he is a true convert of Christ, fruit will be produced by the same grace it took to regenerate him, yet the same grace shades him from the wrath of God when he commits sin and the righteousness of Christ that was once imputed to him neither waxes nor wanes but, like light in the universe, is constant—never changing but ever presenting us as sons and daughters, spotless as Christ. Furthermore, certain that Forde would agree that we are not made more and more righteous before God even if we do sin less and less by being more and more conformed to the image of Christ. Our righteousness is really gained at our justification (1 Cor. 6:11), otherwise how could God call us just, and what more righteousness needs to be involved except that of Christ’s which He merited for us in His life? Not withstanding, when we do sin it really does grieve the Spirit in us, thus the picture of war in our members, but there is no war in the unbeliever, just submission and slavery to sin.
Below I continue to post quotes and comments on Forde's article.
"Talk about sanctification can be dangerous in that it misleads and seduces the old being into thinking it is still in control. We may grudgingly admit we cannot justify ourselves, but then we attempt to make up for that by getting serious about sanctification."
Forde’s essential conclusion here is that talk about sanctification as progressive in nature can be “dangerous” and I can sympathize with this concern when such talk of our theology of sanctification either leads to a practical application that doesn’t include God’s gracious gift of that progress, or if it stems from a theology that denies the same type of graciousness from God which is subsequent to the grace of justification. The Westminster Divines, among others, concluded that the justified life necessarily involves some degree of the mortification of sin. Dying to the desires of the flesh, recognizing and repenting of (seeing it in light of God’s holiness) personal sin, confessing it and believing that Christ died with it on His shoulders, and having it once for all cast away is the sanctified life. But it is this matter of progression that is somewhat nebulous, even in the definition given in ages past. So I must admit that many a bruised reed and smoldering wick has been broken and snuffed out by well-meaning pastors (those intending to fight heartily against “Easy-believism” as they have taught on the progressive nature of sanctification. At times I’ve wondered if the gospel was simple left behind as though it was simply the boarding pass to get on the jet of sanctification. And in that way I sympathize with Forde’s (and what I think is peculiarly the present Lutheran concern for souls who have been prepared for legalism in the midst of the practical application of the doctrine of progressive sanctification. However, I must part ways when it is suggested that simply because the doctrine has been abused, it must therefore be erroneous. Consider Luther himself as he answered the Roman Catholic objection to sola fide, that if it were true, then a flood-gate of iniquity will be opened. To that protestation he said, “…so be it.”
Quotes and comments to be continued...
"It [sanctification] is what happens when we are grasped by the fact that God alone justifies."
"It is what happens when the old being comes up against the end of its self-justifying and self-gratifying, however pious. It is life lived in anticipation of the resurrection."
Certainly no protestant would disagree that a very large portion of what it means to be sanctified is, being “grasped by the fact that God alone justifies”, and living life in light of the resurrection. It is the realization of this fact (essentially belief in the gospel) that sets us and our belief apart from the world in the first place—the mental ascent to the dire need for salvation and finding it only through Christ’s life, death, and resurrection is part of what it means to have been justified by God but, and perhaps this is the main issue Forde is attempting to counteract in his argument, after being justified by grace through faith we are not then left to be sanctified by any other means. It is by the same grace and through the same faith that we are sanctified until the end of our lives; until that time when we “see Him as He is” and are glorified and rid of all possibility of sin.
"Now, living morally is indeed an important, wise and good thing. There is no need to knock it. But it should not be equated with sanctification, being made holy. The moral life is the business of the old being in this world. The Reformers called it "civil righteousness." Sanctification is the result of the dying of the old and the rising of the new. The moral life is the result of the old being's struggle to climb to the heights of the law. Sanctification has to do with the decent of the new being into humanity, becoming a neighbor, freely, spontaneously, giving of the self in self-forgetful and uncalculating ways."
My only real objection here, and it turns out to be a major one, is that I must, because I believe the Scriptures to do so as well, include “becoming a neighbor, freely, spontaneously, giving of the self in self-forgetful and uncalculating ways" as part of living the moral life. Jesus says that the greatest commandment or the summation of the Law is to love God with all your soul and mind to and love your neighbor as yourself (Matt. 22:34-40). So I must ask Forde how “becoming a neighbor” is not part of the moral life—“the old being’s struggle to climb”.