For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.
Showing posts with label Anthropology: Communication. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anthropology: Communication. Show all posts
This is the final post of the article I've titled "The New Intoxication". In this post I will wrap up the conclusion I began in the last post in this series.
Therefore as the Church, the prophetic voice of God in the world, we must be careful to view such a discussion in light of the transcendent doctrines provided in God’s revealed Word and not by the light of cultural expectations. The Scriptural principle that speaks most boldly to this topic—namely the moderation of the aesthetic and functional enjoyment of substances motivated by recreational pursuits—demands that we consider the use of “non-essentials” such as alcohol, tobacco and the like, with a level of logical consistency, taking care not to condemn their use wholesale while indiscriminately commending the use of other substances when the motivations for their uses may overlap. On the other hand, the use of prescription and other drugs perceived “essential” should likewise be considered, especially since in many cases they are no less intoxicating than the substances used recreationally and in fact, it is their intoxicating properties which lead to their prescription in order to affect mood-alteration, behavioral change, or ease physical pain. While being guided by Scriptural principles we must always remain informed by the current medical wisdom and the needs of a person’s well being. Simultaneously all of us, especially Christians, must resist the temptation to impress our own strictly cultural expectations upon the consciences of others in different and perhaps even opposing cultures, especially where those other cultural expectations only disagree with our own, and are not incongruent with the expectations of Scripture.
Though this is the final official post for this article, I for one am sure my engagement of the study of this topic is far from over. Ever learning, and hopefully, always coming to the truth.
In the last post in this series which makes up the article I've called, "The New Intoxication", I began to make a plea for consistent thought when it comes to the way we, the Church in particular, address the consumption of intoxicating substances, regardless of motive. In this post I will conclude that plea.
Though it may seem so, I'm really not trying to make the case for the use of any of the substances I’ve mentioned. I am merely trying to make the case for a biblically consistent philosophy regarding these matters when it comes to the prophetic voice of the Church. It is of paramount importance that we, especially when we must be involved in the condemnation of even the moderate use of a substance, attempt to remain as consistent as possible when we counteract cultural practices. Essentially, and from God's perspective, hypocrisy is no less a sin than addiction. So the Church's' voice is tainted in the eyes of our culture when we maintain blatant inconsistencies. Not to suggest that our doctrine and practice are to be tailored to cultural expectations, but there is no need in adding offence to the message of the Cross, especially when even Christians disagree over an issue such as this. This question has thus been begged: is it inconsistent to insist that the medically motivated use of prescription drugs, for albeit controversially diagnosed illnesses, is permissible while even the moderate consumption of alcohol or tobacco, for recreational reasons is in all cases forbidden? Perhaps that category of professed believers who claims both of the above items does not exist—a category in which persons are "T-totalers" when it comes to certain substances but fully agreeable when it comes to the medical use of others. For instance, when the same group denounces the use of alcohol for any reason yet supports the use of prescribed pharmaceuticals for depression or hyper-activity, I think the possibility for inconsistency blossoms. Conversely when a group, for theological reasons, condemns the use of any psychoactive drug yet sees no reason to condemn the use of alcohol or tobacco for recreational reasons, inconsistency in that case may tend to lead to hypocrisy. So I say yes, it is inconsistent to insist on abstaining from the use of alcohol while at the same time, obliging the use of prescription drugs for depression and hyperactivity.
Bearing all that in mind, I believe it is the wisdom of God that tells the Church that adding offense to the most offensive event of human history, the life and passion of Christ the God-Man and to the good news He brings the world is unnecessary, not to mention wrong. But I must admit the guilt of adding such offense to the gospel, if not surrounding this topic, then certainly involving some other topic where I've used my personal preferences like we are supposed to use God's Law.
In the next post in this series I will make an assesment of this topic based on the discussion I've presented so far.
In the last post in this series I took a look at the motivation to use intoxicating substances with which this article primarily deals—medical reasons. At this point I'd like to begin to observe the inconsistency with which most of us approach this topic and make a plea, for the Church anyway, from the special revelation of God, for us to consider this topic very carefully; and for the rest of the world, by the revelation of God's wisdom that all can enjoy through what we know to be true in nature, to make the very same careful considerations.
In addition to the motives behind use, it is also the purpose of this article to compare and contrast the "nonessential" ingestion of drugs to what is increasingly alleged as their "essential" use for the purpose of what is professed to be an improved quality of life. So in light of the Scriptural teaching of the moderate use of alcohol (and by extension, other “non-essential” substances), how is the Church to view the use of medically “essential” substances such as mao inhibitors or even medicinal marijuana? And as related inquiries: why don’t we tolerate the use of alcohol as an antidepressant the same way much of the Church tolerates the use of Prozac or Paxil? Is it unacceptable to use those drugs in moderately recreational ways as alcohol is used? Why also, where legal of course, is it objectionable to moderately use marijuana to modify mood or behavior, or to ease the bitterness of those who are suffering physically and emotionally, or to anesthetize the dying? As we consider these questions we must also admit that it is different to suggest or condone the use of a substance such as marijuana as a mood altering medication than it is to suggest its use in a situation where a person is dying of cancer and the pain is lessened in some small way by its use. Mood-alteration lends itself to the highly subjective “art” of trying to improve one’s quality of life, while the use of pain killers and other such drugs during death is a less speculative way to ease one’s suffering at a hopeless stage, and is widely accepted in nearly all cultures which probably lends credibility to its wisdom via “creational” or general revelation. Additionally, in the case of marijuana in particular, the method of use must also be considered. There is a substantial difference in the inhalation of its smoke and taking a pill containing THC isolated from the plant. In the case of alcohol, coffee and tobacco, as I mentioned earlier, they have an aesthetic value that synthetic anti-depressants and other mood-altering drugs such as Ritalin do not have. So it also is with substances such as marijuana, cocaine, opium, heroin, and the like. Though they have a functionally recreational value (right or wrong) they do not have in my estimation—which I believe to be grounded in Scripture—any aesthetic recreational worth. Also, due to the degree and quality of intoxication that is produced by their minimal use (which in a sense causes the tendency for their abuse) those substances are almost impossible to use moderately. And I am not speaking of moderation in the sense of occasional use, but moderation in the sense of limited intoxication at even one use. As Americans I believe we tend to think of and accept medicines as being more likely synthetic and substances that are intended for aesthetically recreational use are less likely synthetic. What is more is that substances such as cocaine, heroin, morphine and opium are further down the spectrum of synthesis thus making their use more culturally accepted in medical applications than in recreational applications; whereas less synthesized substances such as alcohol and tobacco, due in some measure to their intrinsic properties, are more likely regarded by the culture as recreational—both in the functional and aesthetic sense. This would, in addition to the limited application of their function, tend to delegitimize the use of synthetic medications as aesthetically recreational, both from a cultural and biblical perspective. Some cultures that are less consumer-driven or which do not have the same taboos in place may not see a functional distinction between the use of alcohol and say, Prozac. If the fact that Prozac and Paxil and other prescription drugs are synthetic does play into the cultural consideration, then we should all ask if humanity wasn’t better off fighting melancholy and anxiety with an occasional glass of wine or mug of beer. But to exhaust that inquiry would of course require the entire scope of another article.
The next post will conclude the plea for consistency.
Like a worm on a hook
Like a knight from some old fashioned book
I have saved all my ribbons for thee
If I have been unkind
I hope that you can just let it go by
If I have been untrue
I hope you know it was never to you
Like a baby, stillborn
Like a beast with his horn
I have torn everyone who reached out for me
But I swear by this song
And by all that I have done wrong
I will make it all up to thee
I saw a beggar leaning on his wooden crutch
He said to me, "You must not ask for so much"
And a pretty woman leaning in her darkened door
She cried to me, "Hey, why not ask for more?"
Like a bird on the wire
Like a drunk in a midnight choir
I have tried in my way to be free."
These are the words of one of my favorite musicians, Leonard Cohen, from his song “Bird on a Wire”. As I listened to this song for the first time in a long while the stanza, “But I swear by this song and by all that I have done wrong; I will make it all up to thee”, really hit me in a different way than it ever had before. Perhaps because, since I have been considering theology more closely now than when I had first begun to examine Cohen’s lyrics, I thought of the way God promised Moses that He would lead the people out of Egypt. Moses asked who he should tell the people sent him as their deliver and God answered, “Tell them, I AM sent you.”; for there is no other name greater than Yahweh. And before that, God swore to Abraham about which the author of Hebrews makes this comment “13For when God made a promise to Abraham, since he had no one greater by whom to swear, he swore by himself, 14saying, "Surely I will bless you and multiply you." 15And thus Abraham, having patiently waited, obtained the promise. 16For people swear by something greater than themselves, and in all their disputes an oath is final for confirmation. 17So when God desired to show more convincingly to the heirs of the promise the unchangeable character of his purpose, he guaranteed it with an oath, 18so that by two unchangeable things, in which it is impossible for God to lie, we who have fled for refuge might have strong encouragement to hold fast to the hope set before us.” Likewise in the stanza I set apart, Cohen swears by two certain things: the existence of the words of the very song in which the oath is made and by the certainty of things wrongly done; if one thing we do in this life is certain it is doing things wrong. So an oath by the things we have done wrong contains two aspects to observe: the promise is in the certainty of the words of the swearing itself (sort of: “I promise by this promise that I will…”) and the great irony of making a promise on broken promises. In essence Cohen promises to make up for all that he has done wrong by swearing on the historical certainty of all that he has done wrong. And the promise rests on the honor of the song, by the truth of the song itself, he will make up for all he has done wrong. Circular and self-attesting as it may be, the words are gripping and their beauty may lie in their honest arrogance.
On a recent White Horse Inn episode they once again discussed the modern Evangelical tendency to prefer telling an unbeliever/skeptic about one's personal testimony and experience over "gospel doctrine". This is a continuation of sorts of an article I posted on October 25th 2008. In a series of interviews at a recent convention of Christian communicators, the persons interviewed all said that, when they witnessed to the unbeliever/skeptic, they believed they personal testimony of transformation was better proof, more effective, and easier to relate to than "gospel doctrine". Many of them said that both were equally important, but even that is not true—one's own sanctification narrative isn't as important as what God did one day in history to reconcile the world unto Himself—and that personal story definitely isn't part of the good news of Jesus Christ.
As I listened to their discussion, I saw a possible parallel. In the last 100-150 years or so, the face of visual art (especially that of painting) has changed dramatically. We have seen an abundance of new sorts of philosophies which work themselves out in not-so-traditional methodologies. For instance, the paintings of Jackson Pollock (Abstract Expressionism) or Pablo Picasso (Cubism); I believe we can condense the difference between "Modern" painting and Classic painting to two categories: Modern—guileless/candid methodology with a sophisticated/complex philosophy, and Classic—technically complex methodology with a sophisticated/complex philosophy. Granted, not all forms of painting or artist's philosophies fit into these two categories, however, the distilled distinction between Modern and Classical approaches can be simple described in this manner.
So how does this parallel the gospel presentation to unbelievers you ask? Let's look at the similar two categories in that realm: Personal Narrative—grounded only in the utter subjectivity of personal experience, and the Meta-Narrative of Redemption—grounded in the objective, historical truth of Incarnate Deity satisfying the wrath of God against sinners, which is an observable fact. Again, before I say what I'm about to say I want to admit the generalization of these categories makes for a very narrow understanding of both, artist and the world of human creation and the witness of Christ and the Kingdom of God and its various practices. Many observers of the fine art world, and artists alike, criticize much of what has been produced under the category of "Modern" art as being too simplistic and motivated by a lack of technical understanding and raw talent, thus supplying the sort of art that drifts further and further away from realism.
Much like the criticism leveled at the non-traditional painters and other artists of the 20th century, one could speculate that the lack of presentation of "gospel doctrine" when American Evangelicals bare "witness to Christ", is in part due to a lack of factual knowledge of that doctrine—a lack of technical apologetic skill. Of course, this may not be true in every case. Much of this slackness, as some may call it, could also be in part due to the post-modern idea of relativism, where individual subjectivity is validated as an individual reality, even if it opposes another so called reality.
"This is the heart of the matter." Most of us have heard that said during conversation; when someone wants to make a particularly salient point, one that they believe encapsulates the very focus of the idea they are presenting, they may employ this adage, "now this is the crux of the matter". The word "crux" is Latin and translates into English as the word "cross". It is interesting that the Latin word for cross is used in a saying which is attempting to set apart a certain portion of one's conversation as being the most important part. It is no mistake that this has happened. Aside from the obvious involvement of the Cause of Causes, men who knew the importance of the cross to the body of Christian doctrine and fundamentals have used it in the past to highlight what they are saying by, in essence, claiming, "this is as important and central to what I am attempting to say as the cross is to Christianity". (1 Cor. 15:13-17) Resurrection necessitates physical death, the death of the cross in particular in our discussion.
The use of the term cross in the saying is for good reason—for it is true to say that the cross is the heart of the matter of Christianity, and without its truth and efficacy there is no resurrection, no redemption, no life after death, and no meaning to our present existence; no inalienable rights, and no real cause for what might be referred to as goodness, regardless of cultural moras.
Believe it or not, I have posted this article two years to the day after my first blog article. This comes as nearly my 250th post, and after nearly 1900 visitors. Thank you for visiting!
I'll say again that I would like to draw upon the interests of my readers to help me to decide the topics on which I should post for much of the next year. So, if you have a particular topic you would like addressed, please feel free to comment on this article listing your suggestion.
Note that the categories I divide the topics into are:
Creation - Anything related to that which has been created by God.
Art - Anything related to that which has been created by man.
Theology - Anything related to the study of God.
Anthropology - Anything related to the study of man.
And it seems to me that any conceivable topic will fit into at least one of these categories.
I've been thinking recently about the differences in words and images, and especially how those differences should affect the form of our gathered worship. I guess the first question one should ask is, are there any differences between word and image or does the hard and fast distinction made between the two only serve to confuse the matter? The last several recordings of the White Horse Inn have made me ask that question.
For instance, we can observe the obvious difference between one of the words of this post and say, the image created by John Howe, which I have on the right column under the category called "pics i like". One might go so far as to say that one is a "word" and the other is an "image". But what about when a word is made to look like an image, such as the way "Google" illustrates the title of their web page on holidays and other nationally recognized days? At what point does the word "Google" stop being a word and become an image? My point is this, it is a false dichotomy; I don't believe we should look at the two categories as being mutually exclusive. In fact, I believe it is correct to say that every written word IS an image. Just consider the way written languages developed. Cuneiform, the written version of the language of ancient Mesopotamia, is generally regarded as the first, and what was it but a collection of pictorial representations of sounds, ideas, people, places, things, and their actions? And later "Italic" languages, from which English and many other languages were derived, are the same way—our alphabets are pictorial representations of minor sounds in our spoken languages which can be combined to form words in which we have invested meanings so we can communicate our thoughts to one another.
So how does this address the forms with which we choose to worship God as a gathered people? There may be a word verses image element that divides groups in what has sadly been named the "Worship Wars". Though most individuals, even those thoughtfully involved in that debate, would not categorize their philosophy of their form of worship as either word based or image based, and it is very likely that most are a combination of the two (assuming the distinction I'm attempting to vilify) most of our practices can be judged against that spectrum—a spectrum that ranges from the simplest form of lettering to the most sophisticated form of video. Though I lean toward the "word" based form of worship—centered around the reading and preaching of God's Word—I believe those of us who do so, need to realize our own dependence on images: the Word of God itself is a collection of images that expresses His revelation (though the focus in our gathered worship is not on the presentation of their visual character) and the visual representation of the gospel—the elements of the Lord's Supper.
In an attenpt to attract warm bodies, many pastors or "worship committees" have neglected the God ordained means of preaching in favor of dramas (ones other than the Lord's Supper) and dialogs, and have traded any litergal elements for light shows and laser beams; they have traded exposition for the extravagant. Don't get me wrong, I am for a variety of styles in musical presentation as long as they are tempered with excellence and framed in solid theology, but the above criticism doesn't just fall on labrynth walking, incense wafting, candle lighting emergent types (who have traded their father's form of seeker-sensitivity for their own sort), but also on much of mainstream Evangelicalism. Robert Norris, of Westminster Seminary California put it something like this, "...the Word creates its own audience."
I make the greatest effort possible NOT to address issues that are exclusively political and subject to cultural preference, rather than the didactic commands of scripture, on this blog. But I would like to point out an article where scripture was brought directly to bear on just such an issue. You can read the article here.
Lately, I've been considering the differences and similarities between the ways that political debate and dialogue and theological debate and dialogue (within the genuinely Christian camp) are handled. Though I do make it a point not to discuss my party affiliation or specifically "political" topics which must be considered preferential in regards to the didactic teachings of scripture, from time to time I do feel compelled to address (in the category of sociology) certain issues facing the American political landscape.
I have become increasing discouraged and disgusted by the methods and tenor of the dialogue between the parties, which in general, is a contrast to theological debates. Though I have seen a great deal of vitriol shared in the debate over Calvinism and eschatology, for the most part, these exchanges are at least considered to be between multiple schools of thought employing different means to the same end...the glory of God. The similarity I have seen recently is the casual approach to truth with which each ticket has interpreted the opposing position. Like many non-Calvinists I've read, they seem completely uninterested in the truthful exchange of ideas through the vehicle of an honest criticism of what an opponent has said. Instead, we the public, are battered by fallacious argumentation like, "red herrings", "weak analogies", "slippery slope", "straw men", and "ad hominem". Perhaps this is the result because, unlike theological debates, the study and practice of politics doesn't have a set of "solas" by which to govern their squabbling.
I do believe that there is a place for testimony. But, evidenced by the continuing errors we make, contemporary American Evangelicalism is post-modern in that (however unintentional) we often replace the objective truths of the gospel, necessary to believe and be saved, with the utter subjectivity of personal testimony. I do believe that personal testimony has its place in the edification of believers, but because of the subjectivity of having ones quality of life improved, or being given the power to obey God's Law to a greater degree, those things really should have a minimal place in an evangelistic situation. The personal testimony that is useful in those cases is if we can point to a time when we once did not believe and repent, and contrast that with the times when we do, thus testifying to the power of God by highlighting His ability to recreate persons who see their sin in contrast to His holiness and believe the gospel. I think a lot of the times we want to substitute transformation for salvation, and this is symptomatic of our mistake of confusing sanctification with justification; confusing Law and Gospel. What eternal good is it if an unregenerate person is inspired in some way by the testimony of my personal transformation, to "change his life" by going to rehab so he can replace bad habits with good ones if he has not first had his heart changed from a heart of stone into a heart of flesh? I'm certain that most Christians would say that it is of no good, and that is the point I'm trying to make--the business of the Kingdom is that of calling persons to see their sinfulness in light of the holiness of God (as reflected in His Law) and to repent of those sins and believe that Christ, in history, lived the perfect life and died the perfect death on a Roman cross, and was raised to glorious life in the place of lowly sinners. Personal transformation (sanctification) will be a result of that continued repentance and belief.
I guess its because most Christians are not forced to think about it formally day to day, but the question of beauty is neglected in our "world-view". If anyone knows of a published systematic theology that includes a treatment on beauty, please let me know. I am aware of several theologians who have written on the subject, Edwards, Sproul, and Kuyper (regarding the theology of art), who I have quoted below.
"And all these because the beautiful is not the product of our own fantasy, nor of our subjective perception, but has an objective existence, being itself the expression of a Divine perfection." Abraham Kuyper from, "Lectures on Calvinism"
It seems important to me, not only because I am confronted with ideas of aesthetics on a daily basis due to my vocation, but also (and perhaps more importantly) because Americans are constantly , through all sorts of mediums, being told what is beautiful by untrustworthy sources. Ultimately, that which is true is that which is beautiful. So, beauty directly corresponds to truth; the degree to which something is true is the degree to which it is also beautiful. And now for a bit of sarcasm...
"Don't teach me about truth and beauty, just label my music" Derek Web from his song, "New Law".
Below is an outline for the two major, Christian hermeneutical systems existing after the beginning of the Age of Enlightenment. Being that this excerpt begins the "Systematic Theology" portion of an essay I am composing, I have included a preamble to set up context for the outlines. Note that the Dispensational outline is, as best as I can tell, representative of the sort of Dispensationalism subscribed to by Ryrie, and other "Post-Dallas" dispensationalists. The outline representing Covenant Theology is, like the dispensational one, not exhaustive, but descriptive. So, covenant theologians and dispensationalists alike, will probably look at these outlines and have something to add or subtract, due to the fact that neither of these systems of theology and hermeneutical approaches is monolithic. I am asking for help from both sides to try and make these outlines profitable for as many persons as possible.
Hermeneutical Structures
It seems most appropriate to begin the section on systematic theology with a description of the different hermeneutical structures under which Dispensationalism and Covenant Theology operate. I understand that these two lists are not exhaustive, neither are they likely to represent everyone in the respective camps. There are two basic assumptions shared by the two major hermeneutical schools of thought, Deism and sola scriptura, these are starting points that shape all forms of what can be considered a Christian interpretation of reality. The assumption of Deism and that God has clearly spoken in time, leads to Christian theism after being confronted by the truths revealed in God’s Word. As a consequence of God having spoken, it is revealed to His creatures that they are accountable to the knowledge of His existence by the testimony of nature alone, thus persons never having been exposed to the special revelation of Himself found in the canon of holy scriptures, are still culpable for their unbelief and under the just penalty of His wrath on them because of Adam’s sin.
I.Theism—any Christian epistemological system must begin with the assumption that a Creator-god exists.
a.Immanence—the Creator-god has spoken; He has revealed a “Word” that His creatures have the capacity of receiving through their physical senses.
i.Primo Regnum—as a function of God having spoken, the Christian Theist must also assume that His special Word is revealed in the canonized scriptures alone. Not that the scriptures are the only authority in the life of the believer, but that their right interpretations are the primary and final authority. Not that every physically audible word of God, or vision or dream sent by God has been included in this collection of “Words”, but all of those Words necessary for the life and godliness of believer is therein revealed.
II.Literalism—the primary guiding principle in Dispensational Theology is the view that states that, unless otherwise expressly told differently within the immediate context of a passage, the grammatical/historical understanding of a prophesy/promise given, is its only possible fulfillment; the object of promise and the object of fulfillment are always the same. If an Old Testament prophesy is ever “expanded” in the New Testament that expansion can never negate, trump or “explain away” the grammatical/historical understanding of those prophesies.
a.Israel/Church Distinction—Spiritual Israel and the Church are now and always viewed as two separate peoples of God.
i.The promises God made to Abraham (and subsequently to ethnic Israel) are only ever meant to be fulfilled by ethnic, believing Israel in some future age and can never be applied to believers saved in the "Church Age".
ii.Millennial Israel and their future activity are the fulfillment of the Old Testament prophesies.
1.Semiti-centric Eschatology—God’s primary purpose in redemptive history is the salvation of His chosen people, Israel. And these people are the ethnic Jewish people He has sustained throughout the history of the world.
a.A contrast between the Kingdom of God/Kingdom of Heaven.
b.Two eternally distinct peoples of God—His earthly people Israel, and His heavenly people, the Church.
c.Jesus will be made King in the Millennium—He has not yet assumed His Kingly office or duties.
2.The Church is unknown prior to Pentecost--The concept of "Church" as a people is a mystery not spoken of prophetically at all in the Old Testament.
3.The Church Age is parenthetical to God's dealings with ethnic Israel—The "Church Age" is a result of Israel's rejection of Christ's offer of the Kingdom, now.
a.Paul's Primary Apostolic Purpose—was to teach the "new age" of believer his distinction in redemptive history from the previous, old age believer, and the future Jewish believer.
Covenantal Hermeneutical Presuppositions
I.Theism—any Christian epistemological system must begin with the assumption that a Creator-god exists.
a.Immanence—the Creator-god has spoken; He has revealed a “Word” that His creatures have the capacity of receiving through their physical senses.
i.Primo Regnum—as a function of God having spoken, the Christian Theist must also assume that His special Word is revealed in the canonized scriptures alone. Not that the scriptures are the only authority in the life of the believer, but that their right interpretations are the primary and final authority. Not that every physically audible word of God, or vision or dream sent by God has been included in this collection of “Words”, but all of those Words necessary for the life and godliness of believer is therein revealed.
II.The Analogy of Faith - Let easily interpreted passages guide our interpretation of difficult passages.
a.Let the interpretation of the fulfillment of Old Testament prophesies/promises found in the New Testament amplify/expand the grammatical/historical understanding of a particular prophesy when it was given.
b.When a promise is made, the object of promise is always, to some degree, a shadow or type of the object of fulfillment; so if the fulfillment of a promise is limited to its "literal" or grammatical/historical manifestation, then it isn't as illustrative of God's goodness. But if the quality of the object of fulfillment is to be accurately represented by the object of promise, it cannot always be limited to its grammatical/historical manifestation.
i.Christ is the ultimate fulfillment of the types and shadows pictured in the Old Testament, so in that way, all the Old Testament points forward to Christ and not to a future manifestation of ethnic Israel, but Christ is the true Israel and those found “in Him” are true Israelites.
c.Let our understanding of the immediate context of a passage be interpreted under the larger umbrella of the entire context of Revelation; the "meta-narrative" or "big picture" perspective of redemptive history should be used to tailor our understanding of the immediate contexts of passages, such as the context provided by their human authorship, chronology in respect to other writings of Revelation, and literary genre.
d.Let the literary genre of a passage guide our understanding of symbols, types/shadows, parables, numbers, and prophesies (either their giving or fulfillment) i.e., historical narratives such as the gospel accounts of resurrection should be taken at face value, but apocalyptic literature when it presents visions such as dragons, lamp stands, 24 elders, etc, they may be symbols which represent something greater. The objects they represent either, could not have been understood if their future manifestation had been presented, or God has decided that the objects being represented are meant to be kept a mystery in part, until such a time when He sees fit to reveal their identity. Note that the object being symbolized is normally a literal and real object.
Whether one hales from a Calvinistic theology of God's providence or not, prayer really is a difficult thing for us finite creatures to wrap our minds around. As a matter of fact, we can't wrap our minds around this idea, and I don't think god intends for us to. All He would have us know about prayer in this age He has revealed in His Word and we can ascertain through our collaborative review of the historical, biblical and systematic theologies of prayer.
Prayer can be illustrated in this way. When I pray it is a bit like me throwing my self with my earnest desires against the immutable Rock of God's will and he chips away at my desires so as to make me look more like His Son the Christ, in Who's Image I have been re-created.
In obedience to His command for His children to come to Him in prayer, I humbly submit my requests, mediated by the righteousness of Christ before His throne, expecting him to do all His holy will, and wait for Him to work all things together for good, for those who love Him.
Whenever different theologians have tried in the past to devise various illustrations to better explain the Trinity on human terms, they have often gotten into trouble; some for trying to work the analogous picture too far, and others who simply have used the description in a limited sense but their audience misunderstood them to be saying that "God is only like this...".
So, naturally, I'll have to tread these dangerous waters. But one caveat before I do, I want to it absolutely clear that I don't think that this illustration is by any means complete, thorough or perfect as a depiction of the mystery of the Triune God or His work in creation. Note that a portion of this illustration has shamelessly been adapted from an analogy (I assume) that was invented by Kim Riddlebarger to describe the process of progressive revelation. With that, here goes.
Imagine that you are in a darkened room. No lights; it's as pitch as the darkest, starless, moonless rural night. Imagine God as a man who stands outside the room and speaks to you. You can only hear Him and the only things you know about Him are the things He has spoken to you through the door. Even the things you know about the darkened room in which you sit are limited to your vain sensual perception and what He has told you about the room. Imagine that one day, God opens the door just slightly and reaches His arm in and turns on the light in the room. You are absolutely amazed by what you see. The elements and character of the room are exactly as God had described them. You call out to God, and because all you see is the arm, and ask, "God, is that You?". God replies "yes, it is Me."
Obviously, God turning the light on represents what happened when He came in Christ to proclaim the Kingdom and explained the purposes of the Old Covenant cultic rituals. But when you ask, "God is that You?" and He answers yes, even though all you saw of Him was a hand, we know that God is more than just a hand, but just as if I was to quietly sneak around a corner of my house into a room occupied by my sons, and if they saw part of my body and cried out, "Dad, is that you?". even though the portion of my body they saw is only part of me, I can still say, and would say, yes, it is me. Likewise, Jesus IS God, but He is not all that God is. God is Father Son and Holy Spirit.
Means of Grace or Means of Memorial; Sacraments or Ordinances.
The way in which you refer to the elements of the Lord's Supper, and Baptism may be rooted in a philosophy derived from your theology. The methods your church employs in the practice of these implements will reflect the theology that backs their practice in the first place. Both sides of the issue believe that God has ordained certain practices for our observance, but the question is, are these practices considered sacred.
The Ordinances as Memorial
Largely, I believe, the fruit of non-reformed theology (neither Calvinistic nor Covenantal) the memorialist view of the Lord's Supper at least, is an over-reaction on Ulrich Zwingli's part against the Roman Catholic doctrine of trans-substantiation. Granted, the Roman view of the Eucharistic meal was then and is now heretical however, the adoption of a memorialist view diminishes in the minds of the parishioners the sanctifying power of the Lord's Supper. If we see the Supper only as a way to remember what Christ has done in the atonement, then we will not receive the God ordained and gracious sanctification that He intends to deliver through this mean, and the frequency with which we partake of it together will be lessened.
Likewise with baptism. The debate over paedo or believer's baptism aside, if we view this only as an individual's identification with Christ, an outward sign of his belief and commitment to the Lordship of Christ only, then we may miss the larger picture of Christ redeeming an entire people for Himself, and our identification with the community of God in Christ can become overshadowed by our individualistic identity as a new creation in Christ.
The Sacred Desk
Another sacred element of our corporate worship is the desk. And by desk I mean the pulpit upon which the very Word of God is elevated above our heads to indicate His condescension. Different from the sacraments of the Supper and baptism, the right proclamation of the Word of God (therein contains the Law and Gospel) is the means of both, justifying and sanctifying grace, proceeding from the mouth of the shepherds of God and carried with force into the hearts of unsuspecting men by the Holy Spirit, it should be elevated in our hearts and considered all together sacred. thus it's physical place during the corporate worship of God's people is likely a symptom of the place it inhabits in our stated theologies.
The Sacraments as a Means of Grace
When we view the Lord's Supper and baptism as means of grace, we are not suggesting that these are a means to justifying grace; they do not confer the righteousness of Christ to us.What we mean is that God has ordained the practices of preaching, baptism and the Supper as means to the sanctification of His people and that the practice of them are so important that their absence in the life of a child of God will result in his eventual spiritual starvation. The grace that is conferred in the sacred meal and by the observance of baptism is the grace that renews our faith as often as they are practiced, thus the practice of baptism as often as one is (depending on one's view) either saved, or given the covenant sign, and the practice of eating the covenant meal with other believers perhaps as often as you gather, is as useful in the display and reception of God's sanctifying grace as His Word is useful in the proclamation of the grace that justifies.
Believe it or not, I have posted this article one year to the minute since I posted my first blog article. This comes 25 posts after my 1ooth post, and after almost 1000 visitors.
I would like to draw upon the interests of my readers to help me to decide the topics on which I should post for much of the next year. So, if you have a particular topic or issue you would like addressed, please feel free to comment on this article listing your suggestion.
Note that the categories I divide the topics into are:
Creation - Anything related to that which has been created by God. Art - Anything related to that which has been created by man. Theology - Anything related to the study of God. Anthropology - Anything related to the study of man.
I believe any conceivable topic or issue will fit into at least one of these categories.
In the English language there is a set of absolutes that apply to the grammatical structure of language. We commonly try to teach our children to write with correct grammar, and to use the language accurately in their speech. But have you ever wondered why? Why really bother to correct them on a daily basis when the speak incorrectly? As Christian parents there are so many other things we should feel a need to correct, so many other instances when the Law of God should be presented to our children, so why bother to clutter their minds with another, man-made set of laws; why not just allow their teachers to present the right and wrong way to write and speak, and then leave it at that; why "disciple" our children in the way of English language when we have the infinitely more important task of discipling them in the way of the Kingdom?
One answer to this question is, because correct grammar is an integral part of efficient communication. And ntoe here tahtwehn I say "garmamr" I am inculding the tsak of splelnig correctly as well. So if my premise is correct, that the primary goal of language is efficient communication, then doesn't correct grammar become a necessary means to that end? In answering this question, I think there are two challenges to consider. One, the trans-linguistic nature relationships today and two, the trans-cultural nature of relationships.
The Trans-Linguistic Nature of Relationships
The world is more and more like a village. In the attempt to communicate (for business or pleasure) the possibility is likely that you will encounter, as you are speaking in your native language, someone speaking in a language that is second to their native tongue.
We are experiencing more homogenization of culture, race and even language, than I believe has been experienced by any previous culture since Babel. Don't get me wrong, I don't see anything inherently sinful in the effort to communicate by building these types of bridges, so don't think that I am trying to compare these efforts to the efforts made by those God judged prior to the confusion at the tower of Babel. Just as language has been, and will remain, fluid over time, it is also, now, increasingly fluid from one language to another as one language adopts and applies a word whose transliteration is to difficult for common usage, and with the onset of the global electronic nature of economy, even the adoption of product names (which use words from the source language) from languages of a different family. For instance, words that transition from Asian to Latin based languages.
The Trans-Cultural Nature of Relationships
If the end is, to efficiently communicate the content of the words being spoken and their idea, then is it actually being accomplished when a person is constantly concerned with using correct English grammar in a context where the application of such a concern in that aspect of audible communication is perceived as arrogant and condescending? What we have is a conflict of competing means. The conclusion must be that, while correctly spoken grammar is a means to the end of efficient communication, it is not a "necessary means", nor is it a "sufficient means".