Romans 5:7-9

For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.
Showing posts with label Theology: Historical. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Theology: Historical. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Concluding Remarks


Concluding Remarks
     
 So, as I conclude I will make a summary comparison of the atonement theologies of the three men in question. We can say that Anslem approached the theory of substitutionary atonement as expressed in Reformed and Evangelical circles today: satisfaction for sins, the necessity of Christ’s death for our life, etc. The Abelardian view maintained that by God’s grace we are made lovers of God so as to prove our fellowship with him. Often loosely interpreted in our day as the moral theory of the atonement, it far more emphasized the idea of God’s love being shown through Christ’s passion than an answer to His justice. And Thomas’ view was worked out in the difference between the imputation of and the infusion of Christ’s righteousness to the believer; Thomas saw the atonement as a provision of the grace God used to make a sinner righteous before He called him just. His theory, like Anselm’s, counted on God’s grace, but where Anselm saw this in terms of God’s grace extended in mercy by forgiving the guilty because He punished the Innocent, Thomas saw it in more of what we would now consider Roman Catholic terms, that in order for God to call someone just that person must actually be just, thus God makes them so by infusing Christ’s righteousness thereby transmuting their soul from wickedness to righteousness.
Thus in the final assessment, even though their lives were separated by no more than 200 years, neither Anselm of Canterbury, nor Peter Abelard, nor Thomas Aquinas shared the same view of the atonement. Some of their ideas overlapped but the three of them drew rather different conclusions and therefore have influenced the world of theology in different ways: Anselm: penal substitution, Abelard: moral influence, and Aquinas: Roman Catholic Sacramentalism.

Friday, April 2, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Aquinas - 2

Theological Comparisons

Aquinas

It must first be pointed out that Thomas saw the need to conciliate God’s justice, which was quite different than the terms Anselm employed in his theory. “This is Aquinas' major difference with Anselm. Rather than seeing the debt as one of honor, he sees the debt as a moral injustice to be righted.”[i] Now regarding Thomas on the act of atonement itself, he first, with Anslem saw the necessity of Christ’s incarnation. “Now a mere man could not have satisfied for the whole human race, and God was not bound to satisfy; hence it was needful for Jesus Christ to be both God and man.”[ii] Secondly, that the death of Christ was perfectly satisfactory because of His infinite deity and was necessary due to the highly offensive nature of our sin. “…a sin committed against God has a kind of infinity from the infinity of the Divine majesty, because the greater the person we offend, the more grievous the offence. Hence for adequate satisfaction it was necessary that the act of the one satisfying should have an infinite efficacy, as being of God and man.”[iii] Thirdly, that Christ came into the world to blot out both original and actual sin. “It is certain that Christ came into this world not only to take away the sin which is handed on originally to posterity, but also in order to take away all sins subsequently added to it…”[iv]Fourth that in some way in Thomas’ mind, Christ’s merit is extended to the whole church. Thomas pointed out the objections to the merit of Christ extending to others by asserting that, just as Adam’s demerit is extended to the whole race physically, Christ’s merit is extended to the members of His body, the church, because He is its head. Thomas responded to those objections in these varied ways. “But Adam’s demerits reached to the condemnation of others. Much more, therefore does the merit of Christ reach others.”[v] And here is his logical progress from the representation of Adam to the representation of Christ, “As the sin of Adam reaches others only by carnal generation, so, too, the merit of Christ reaches others only by spiritual regeneration, which takes place in baptism; wherein we are incorporated with Christ…and it is by grace that it is granted to man to be regenerated in Christ. And thus man’s salvation is from grace.”[vi] Now it is clear from this last statement that Thomas’ understanding of the sacraments is in contrast to the Reformers, and that the division of the Calvinistic categories of the church into “visible” and invisible” are likewise not yet present. Even further, it is clear that Thomas differed from Anselm in yet another way.
Aquinas articulated the formal beginning of the idea of a superabundance of merit, which became the basis for the Catholic concept of the Treasury of Merit…Aquinas also articulated the ideas of salvation that are now standard within the Catholic church: that justifying grace is provided through the sacraments; that the condign merit of our actions is matched by Christ's merit from the Treasury of Merit; and that sins can be classified as mortal and venial. For Aquinas, one is saved by drawing on Christ's merit, which is provided through the sacraments of the church. Aquinas' view may sound like penal substitution, but he is careful to say that he does not intend substitution to be taken in legal terms[vii]
     Thus Thomas—I believe contrary to Gesner’s assertion, alluded to earlier—is now aligned with the current Roman Catholic understanding of the atonement, in all its parts and implications.


[i] New World Encyclopedia contributors. “Atonement (satisfaction view)”. New World Encyclopedia; 2008 Sep 4, 22:35 UTC [cited 17 Mar, 2010]. Online: http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Atonement_%28satisfaction_view%29?oldid=799847.
[ii] Thomas Aquinas, The Suma Theologica of Saint Thomas Aquinas: vol. II Daniel J. Sullivan, ed., (Chicago, London, Toronto: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc., 1952), 702.
[iii] Ibid. 704
[iv] Ibid. 706
[v] Ibid. 820
[vi] Ibid. 821
[vii] New World Encyclopedia contributors. “Atonement (satisfaction view)”. New World Encyclopedia; 2008 Sep 4, 22:35 UTC [cited 17 Mar, 2010]. Online: http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Atonement_%28satisfaction_view%29?oldid=799847.
 

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Aquinas - 1


Theological Comparisons
Aquinas
     So much could be said of the good Doctor Angelicus, Saint Thomas Aquinas; short life though he lived, his copious collection of theological musings warranted a more Methuselan period of time. On the particular doctrine of the atonement, Thomas has been quoted by Roman Catholic and protestant scholars both, as having held to their position. One such extreme instance of this is an article in Table Talk magazine where Dr. John Gerstner claimed that Saint Thomas held to justification by grace, through faith alone; while others remain more cautious because of the dichotomy he made between congruent and condign merit: congruent being that merit that one has outside of the gracious work of Christ and condign being that merit graciously provided by God, yet still a merit that Thomas finds in the act of the justification of a sinner. Make no mistake, Thomas firmly believed that God’s grace was absolutely necessary and any good deed would ultimately be attributed to its infusion. Thomas proved this in his own words,
Now everlasting life is a good exceeding the proportion of created nature; since it exceeds its knowledge and desire, according to 1 Cor. 2:9: ‘Eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither hath it entered into the heart of man.’ And hence it is that no created nature is a sufficient principle of an act meritorious of eternal life, unless there is added a supernatural gift, which we call grace.[i]
But therein lays the true issue. Thomas proved this in his own words as he attempted to answer this question, May a man, by God’s grace, condignly merit eternal life? To that effect, “If, however, we speak of a meritorious work, inasmuch as it proceeds from the grace of the Holy Ghost moving us to life everlasting, it is meritorious of life everlasting condignly. For thus the value of its merit depends upon the power of the Holy Ghost moving us to life everlasting according to John 4:14.”[ii]
The major difference in Thomas’ theory of atonement and that of Anselm’s is this idea of righteousness infused. To import our own categories into the discussion, the Reformers were careful to say that we are not made righteous at all (especially by the infusion of meritorious acts such as belief), but that we are instead declared righteous on account of Christ’s merit for us. This was in fact Anselm’s position; he claimed that Christ’s death—which was an act over and above what God demands of all His creatures, a life of perfect obedience—merited infinite righteousness which would be imparted, as an alien source, to the sinner God chose to benefit. Thomas’s opinion of the sinner made righteous before God, graciously being given the capacity to do that which God commanded, was what he referred to as the transmutation of the human soul. By virtue of the soul being caused to obey, the person becomes righteous before God, therefore God can (and is in fact obliged—insinuated by Thomas) really and actually call the person righteous because they indeed are righteous.


[i] Thomas Aquinas, “Suma Theologica,” Christian Classics Ethereal Library ST Ia.114.2. Cited 17 March 2010. Online: http://www.ccel.org/ccel/aquinas/summa.FS_Q114_A2.html
[ii] Thomas Aquinas, “Suma Theologica,” Christian Classics Ethereal Library ST Ia.114.3. Cited 17 March 2010. Online: http://www.ccel.org/ccel/aquinas/summa.FS_Q114_A3.html.

Monday, March 29, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Anselm - 1


Theological Comparisons

 Anselm

     Anselm, being perhaps the first theologian in 800 years to say so, did not find propitious, this theory of atonement which had an exclusive emphasis on ransom, thus facilitating his proposition of another theory. Anselm’s pioneering ideas in general proved to have influenced a 1000 years of atonement theology since his death. 55 years ago one philosopher described Anselm in this way.
The theology of Anselm is so full of rational speculation that one of his historians has labeled it a “Christian rationalism,”[i] Its ambivalence is due to the fact that, expressing the inner life of faith that seeks understanding, it is both overflowing with a religious feeling which sometimes borders on mysticism and full of dialectical passion which translates faith into terms of rational necessity. Hence its twofold influence in the fields of theology and of philosophy.[ii]
Though this sounds somewhat critical, the influence can’t be denied. He went so far as to object to the contemporary trend of questioning the radical nature of the cross because of its abject violence—why would the God of the universe chose to show His love to His creatures in such a brutal way? Anselm was careful to point out that this God could only incarnate the way that He did and that incarnation could only lead to the end we observe through the narrative of the four Gospels. Anselm put to his readers this hypothetical objection to God’s death on a cross,
Therefore, if he was willing to save the human race only in the way you described when he could have done it by sheer will, to put it mildly, you really disparage his wisdom. For surely, if for no reason a man did by hard labor what he could have done with ease no one would regard him as wide. And you have no rational ground for saying that God showed in this way how much he loved us unless you can show that it was quite impossible for him to save man in some other way.[iii]
It’s not as though God was forced to restore the relationship of His creatures and creation to Himself after it had been broken by Adam’s sin, but when He chose to do so He chose to reconcile some of mankind to Himself by not imputing the consequence of Adam’s sin to them, thus forgiving them their debts and loving them instead. But it is not as though this sin and offense—one we know is infinite because it is an offense against an infinite God—no longer exists and God has simple shrugged it off the way we do when we are actually asked to forgive one another. On the contrary, the sins we have committed, the sin nature we have inherited from Adam must be dealt with even if it is not counted to our own debt. So Anselm postulated the representation of Christ as our sin bearer, converse to our representation in Adam as he sinned and stored up guilt for all his children to inherit. Christ on the other hand stored up positive merit for our inheritance which should be counted to us by the Father in place of our demerit.


[i] H. Bouchitte, Le rationalisme chretien de saint Anselme,—Anslem as “father of scholasticism”: M. Grabman, Geschichte der schol. Meth., I, (Paris, 1842), 58.
[ii] Etienne Gilson, History of Christian Philosophy in the Middle Ages (New York: Random House, 1955), 139.
[iii] Anselm, Cur Deus Homo, in A Scholastic Miscellany: Anselm to Ockham, trans. and ed. by Eugene R. Fairweather, M.A., B.D., Th.D, (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1956), 107
 

Friday, March 26, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Abelard - 2


Theological Comparisons

Abelard

His comment begins regarding Rom. 3:21 and Abelard was quick to separate the formal, covenantal Law from the natural transcendent law of God and he then went on to make a contrast between the age prior to Christ when that formal Law ruled, and his present age, ruled, as he said, by grace, the age in which Christ has been manifest through the teaching of the gospel. And when we read further we see that Abelard made an additional contrast between the Law (be it formal or natural, it is not clear from his comments here) and love for God. Whereas, I believe the more orthodox position is that love for God is the fulfillment of God’s formal Law, not only an aspect of God’s natural law. Here is that contrast, “A righteousness, I say, imparted to all the faithful in the higher part of their being—in the soul where alone love can exist—and not a matter of the display of outward works.”[i] And then there are those passages that seem to exonerate Abelard of a justification by anything other than faith and show a doctrine of atonement more like that of Anselm than of Niebuhr or Tillich. “‘In his blood.’ [citing Paul’s letter to the Romans] This means by his death; and since this propitiation is set forth and established by God, not for all but only for those who believe, he adds, ‘Through faith’[citing Paul’s letter to the Romans]; for this reconciliation affects them only who have believed it and hoped in it.”[ii] But then, as one might expect, there are the occasions of his leaning toward what we now call the “Moral Influence” theory,
By the faith which we hold concerning Christ love is increased in us by virtue of the conviction that God in Christ has united our human nature to himself and, by suffering in that same nature, has demonstrated to us that perfection of love…So we, through his grace are joined to him as closely as to our neighbor by an indissoluble bond of affection...[iii]
And this comment further on in Rom. 3:26, “In other words, to show forth his love to us, or convince us how much we ought to love him who ‘sparred not even his own son’ [citing Paul’s letter to the Romans] for us…That is to say that through this righteousness [the showing of God’s righteousness or justice as in v. 26]—which is love—we may gain remission of our sins”[iv]
The common view of Abelard in the last 100 years or so can be summed up in the words of Sam Storms, “In fairness to Abelard, it would be a mistake to conclude that he omitted all reference to the sacrifice of Christ as a payment for our sin. Yet, his emphasis is clearly on the subjective effects of that sacrifice rather than its objective relationship to the wrath of God.”[v] Abelard’s primary emphasis therefore being the equation of love and righteousness (being justified), I believe the Abelardian theory of the atonement is positively stated, by God’s grace we are made lovers of Him and those who love God are justified before Him. Or, in the final accounting we are justified by faith and our love for the Father; the Father gives us this capacity to love Him, by His grace, therefore we are saved by grace through our love of God. It must be noted that “love for God” in the sense that Abelard used in his commentary on Romans in particular, encompasses faith; so there is no justification without love for God, there is no love for God without faith.


[i] Ibid., 278

[ii]Ibid., 279
[iii] Ibid., 278
[iv] Ibid., 279

[v] Sam Storms, “11) Anselm” [cited 13 March, 2010]. Online: http://www.enjoyinggodministries.com/article/11-anselm/

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Abelard - 1


Theological Comparisons
Abelard
Peter Abelard’s view of the atonement is quite less obvious from a simple reading of his writings on logic and on the interaction of the Christian with unbelievers as in Dialogue Between a Philosopher, a Jew and a Christian. One must make more interpretation and speculate on his doctrine than when engaging Anselm or Thomas on the same topic, although, in his commentary on Romans there are a couple of revealing statements. In large part, the scholars among those who do now or have in the past held to the “Moral Theory” or “Exemplary Theory” of the atonement generally attribute the theories infancy to Abelard. This theory and his reasons behind Christ’s death were somewhat in the face of Anselm’s; where Anselm would have claimed that Christ’s punishment on the cross was a necessity born out of our offence toward His honor, Abelard would have claimed that His death was a cosmic illustration of the sheer love God had for humanity and we are called by such love, to love others in such a way—first receiving the love of Christ through the presentation of it on the cross and therefore loving others likewise, thus justifying ourselves before a loving God. So it is not so much that we owe God holiness and cannot provide it so Christ did on our behalf, but that God is so loving that we must show that quality (certainly by God’s grace) so that we are rendered righteous and acceptable. An Abelardian formula might be this: God is love so we must love in order to be reconciled to Him. On the other hand, the Anselmian formula might be like this: God is honorable so we must have Christ’s holiness to be reconciled to Him because our sin dishonors Him. So the primary effect of the atonement was not to satisfy God’s wrath against ungodliness but rather, to provide the ultimate example whereby we might become holy ourselves and accepted by a holy God. In the final analysis Abelard, while not technically an advocate of the “Moral Theory” of the atonement (for to say such a thing is to engage in anachronism) does emphasis the reason for Christ’s death as being the love of God toward men nearly to the exclusion of the Anselmian necessity of Christ’s death for the purpose of appeasing the Father’s honor. Thus he is interpreted by those actual proponents of an exclusively moral influence view of the atonement and credited as the theological forbearer of their own novel ideas of Christ’s work. What I find most interesting is that Abelard, as he describes his understanding of the meaning of Christ’s sacrifice, he seems to expose a sort of semi-Augustinian view of salvation. Whether his view of man’s capacity to actually love God in some satisfactory sort of way as to cause his merit leads to his view of the atonement or vice-versa, I dare not say with any degree of certainty. But I will say that it is easy to observe the relationship and ask this question: having rejected the “Ransom Theory” as the atonement’s exclusive purpose, did Abelard adopt a semi-Augustinian anthropology and henceforth react with the proposition of another extreme theory whereby sinners are made righteous before God by the exhibition of their own love for Him. Like most theologians, Abelard betrayed himself and appeared to answer both “sic et non”; “yes” and “no”. Here is one instance of such an amalgamation of these two ideas: justification is by faith (not yet alone as so strongly put forth by Luther four centuries later) and justification is by love,
I said that by particular works of the written law, that is, by those formal precepts of which natural law knows nothing, no one is justified in God’s sight; but now, in this dispensation of grace, a righteousness [translated justice elsewhere] of God—something which God approves and by which we are justified in God’s sight, namely love—has been manifested, through the teaching of the gospel, of course, apart from the law with its external and particular requirements. Still, this is a ‘righteousness witnessed by the law and the prophets,’ who also enjoin it. Upon what righteousness depends he [Paul] adds immediately by saying, ‘The justice of God’ [Rom. 3:22]. He means the faith of Christ which we hold concerning him—either by believing him or by believing in him. And when he [Paul] continued, ‘Them that believe,’ he did not specify anyone in particular, that it might impartially extended over all.”[i]


[i] Peter Abelard, Exposition of the Epistle to the Romans, trans. and ed. by Eugene R. Fairweather, M.A., B.D., Th.D, (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1956), 278.

Monday, March 22, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Anselm - 2


Theological Comparisons
Anselm
In his formulation of God’s purpose in the atonement, Anselm used an idea that nearly every Medieval European could have understood; His ideas were illustrated by the cultural practices in which he found himself imbedded. In his attempt to rationally explain the incarnation of God, Cur Deus Homo, Anselm found himself describing what the atonement meant and why God did it the way that He did. He spoke of our offence against God as being akin to the offence against a nobleman—and in the feudal structure to which they were so very accustomed, they knew all too well that the offence against one of nobility would result in the harshest kind of punishment and required the most laborious type of compensation. It was in this context that Anselm developed his understanding of the atoning work of Christ—or at least attempted to illustrate it. It should be noted that Anselm received some critique for his use of feudal terms to illustrate the glorious atonement of Christ. Some were scandalized that he would speak of God’s honor rather than His holiness, but in the view of this author, the idea presents the same result, especially for us looking back. We see Anselm’s rendering in contrast to others of his day and that being the case, we should easily stomach his use of feudal nomenclature to describe the atonement differently than the “Ransom Theory” before him.
To add nuance to this idea of God’s honor being offended as a vassal might offend his king, listen to Anselm’s own words, “B. What is the debt which we owe God? A. Every inclination of the rational creature ought to be subject to the will of God…One who does not render this honor to God take away from God what belongs to him, and dishonors God, and to do this is sin.”[i] Put positively Anselm’s theory is this, that the offence of man against God was so heinous and God’s holiness is so contrary to it that, the penalty for the offence had to be reconciled, and that reconciliation had therefore to be made by God Himself, hence His own death on a cross. One primary element of Anselm’s theory was that all persons, all humans, Christ included, owed God perfect obedience. Obviously Christ is the only One who will ever fill that demand, but Anselm’s point was that God required something over and above that He required, that Christ would die to fulfill the obligation for the forgiveness of the human race. And Christ would be rewarded with the salvation of His bride. Some extrapolated version of this formula is the current atonement theory that Reformed community and a majority of Evangelicalism regards as orthodox. We call it “penal substitution”, “substitutionary atonement”, or the “Satisfaction Theory”.


[i] Ibid. (119)


Saturday, March 20, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Preface

     Now we will begin to consider the varied renderings of atonement theology as represented by these three monumental figures. In the years prior to Anselm, the prevailing view of the atonement was called the “Ransom Theory”. Perhaps this idea was in part a hold-over from the dualistic tendencies of the Gnostics or Manicheans, it presents the ultimate goal of the atonement as being one where God was on mission to rescue or ransom sinners from their owner and master, the devil. So, after Adam’s sin his posterity was plunged into the servant-hood of God’s antithesis, Satan. And God, loving those He had predetermined to save, paid the penalty those poor sinners owed the devil so to ransom them out of their bondage to him and free them to the service of the King Jesus.

Friday, March 19, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Introduction

     When comparing three of the most prominent theologians of the Medieval Scholastic period: Anselm, Peter Abelard and St. Thomas Aquinas, one must note their relative places in time. Thus I will rightly begin with Anselm, born in the Italian village of Aosta, who lived from 1033 to 1109. His memory enjoys the titles, “The Tongue of Augustine” and “The Second Augustine” because of his self conscious effort to appropriate that great man’s theology, and as we shall hopefully see—if one can imagine it—even emulate certain aspects of it. And rightly so, for whom else in the 1000 years prior to Anselm was a theological mind worthy of such flattery? Would anyone dare to disagree that before Anselm, Augustine was the name that sticks out among those theologians whose words are necessary to consult. It is true, many great men and women lived in those so called, “Dark Ages” between these two men: Gregory the Great in the 6th century and Scotus Erigena in the 9th are but two examples. But the scope of this paper lies within the 2nd millennia.
Like Augustine before him was posthumously referred to as the “Father of Medieval Theology”, Anselm turned out to be considered the father of the time following his life; in hindsight, he is considered the “Father of Medieval Scholasticism”. I make these observations, as I will likewise do with Peter Abelard and Saint Thomas Aquinas, in order to highlight the importance of these men in the progress of theological thoughts and philosophical meanderings that take us on a journey from the Ransom Theory of the atonement to the various theories adopted in the Scholastic Period.
Peter Abelard lived from 1079 to 1142; being born in a village in France called Le Pallet, lived most of his life in France. Abelard’s most notable historical moment may actually have had nothing to do with his work on the theory of universals called, conceptualism, or his ideas on the atonement, or his being condemned as a heretic, but his forbidden romance with his most beautiful and intellectually deserving student Heloise. Their love for one another has been burned in the annals of time by pen and brushstroke alike.
Where Anselm is lauded by the Church as a hero, Abelard was condemned as a heretic under the judgment of Bernard of Clairvaux only one year before his death in 1142, having aged 63 years). Though he stood against the Nominalists with Thomas on the issues of universals, his heterodox views along with his extracurricular interests cause his memory to thus be rewarded by a strange mix of both scathing remarks and admiration.
Lastly, one of the 33 esteemed “Doctors of the Church”, Saint Thomas Aquinas, the Angelic Doctor, “…was born in 1225, in the family castle at Roccasecca. Forty-nine years later on March 7, 1274, he died at Fossanova, perhaps 20 kilometers distant from his birthplace. Between those two he had lived in Naples, Cologne, Paris, Rome, Orvieto, Viterbo, Paris again, and finally Naples.” [i] Thomas is considered by many to be the foremost Catholic Theologian, having contributed to the doctrinal definitions now extolled by Roman Catholics and also having shaped the pagan philosophy of the late Medieval Period and Western thought thereafter. Like Anselm and Abelard—and their intellectual ancestor Origin—he too was largely concerned with the marriage of faith and knowledge. Though the three of them would have disagreed on the vows and terms of this marriage, the thought of divorcing the two disciplines wasn’t even marginal. Thomas’ contribution to the world of philosophy has been far reaching, having philosophers even as recent as Etienne Gilson referring to themselves as “Thomists”; a category bearing the name of its pioneer, Thomas Aquinas.


[i] Ralph M. McInerny, Aquinas (Blackwell Publishing Ltd: Oxford, 2004), 3.

New Series - Theories of Christ's Atonement

Today, after a long respite, I will begin a new series of posts that will be generated out of a paper I just completed. The topic is the doctrine of Christ's atonement and its formulation through the Medieval Scholastic Period (1000-1500). This series will deal with three theologian/philosophers from that period: Anselm the Bishop of Canterbury, Peter Abelard, and Saint Thomas Aquinas.

Monday, September 7, 2009

God's Knowledge, Who Can Know it? - part 4


The bible, openness, and the spaces between (continued)
     Another author writes, “Middle knowledge pertains to possibilities and it comes after His decree to create.” In other words, God knows every combination and contingency fathomable.  One modern-day Molinist is William Lane-Craig and this is what he had to say about that subject.
“Third, the Scriptures are replete with counterfactual statements, so that the Christian theist, at least, should be committed to the truth of certain counterfactuals about free, creaturely actions. The Church has never, until the modern age, doubted that God possesses knowledge of true counterfactuals concerning free, creaturely decisions; the whole dispute focused on whether He possessed that knowledge logically prior to the divine creative decree or only posterior to the divine decree. The Church's confidence that God knows such truths is rooted in the Scriptures themselves. To pick but one example, Paul, in reflecting upon God's eternal salvific plan realized in Christ, asserts, "None of the rulers of this age understood this; for if they had, they would not have crucified the Lord of Glory" (I Cor. 2.8). By "the rulers of this age" Paul means either the Jewish and Roman authorities such as Herod and Pilate who were the historical agents who instigated or carried out the crucifixion (cf. Acts 4. 27–28) or, more plausibly, the spiritual principalities and powers who rule "this present evil age" (Gal. 1. 4; cf. I Cor. 2. 6). In either case, we have here a counterfactual about creaturely free actions. So is Paul's assertion true or not? Will we have the temerity to say that Paul was wrong? Since the Church believes that Paul was inspired by the Holy Spirit to write these words, she accepts them as revealed truth from God. Thus, we have strong prima facie warrant for holding that there are true counterfactuals concerning what creatures would freely do under various circumstances.[i]”
We must first observe the deficiency of Craig’s exegesis of the passage. Paul’s point has nothing to do with the presumed assertion that Christ might not have been crucified. Does Craig actually mean to suggest that among the possible threads of contingencies (futurabilia), from which God chose, there existed the possible future where Christ did not have to die for the Church? Craig falsely states that the church has never doubted God’s knowledge of counterfactuals. He contends that the Church in all times prior to the modern age (which depending on who you ask, started sometime in the 1900’s) upheld his Molinistic view as orthodox; this simply is not true. The Westminster Confession of faith clearly discredits his assertion.
“I. God from all eternity, did, by the most wise and holy counsel of His own will, freely, and unchangeably ordain whatsoever comes to pass; yet so, as thereby neither is God the author of sin, nor is violence offered to the will of the creatures; nor is the liberty or contingency of second causes taken away, but rather established.
II. Although God knows whatsoever may or can come to pass upon all supposed conditions; [4] yet has He not decreed anything because He foresaw it as future, or as that which would come to pass upon such conditions
III. By the decree of God, for the manifestation of His glory, some men and angels are predestinated unto everlasting life; and others foreordained to everlasting death.[ii]”
The contingencies spoken of in this confession are in regards to second causes or creaturely actions. In II it is stated that God knows whatever “may or can come to pass” but the statement following (4) explicitly denies the idea of counterfactual knowledge—that God may have decreed the actual future because He foresaw all “possible” futures.
And the 1689 London Baptist Confession echoes the essence of this sentiment exactly. Craig affirms that the debate is actually the debate between him and open theists, and while it is true that the essence of Open Theism has a history that reaches far back, so also does the current denial of counterfactuals find its history rooted in Reformational theology.  It is easy for one to say that Paul said X means y, so non-y is false.  Don’t we find it clear that one could easily interpret Paul’s statement differently thus concluding something different?  Craig fails to substantiate his interpretation here and falsely asserts that anyone taking a position contrary to his own would in fact be calling Paul a liar. If it was much more obvious that Paul, as Craig seems to think, was clearly substantiating a doctrine of counterfactuals in that passage, then Craig’s argument might have weight. But Paul’s words aren’t clearly, or even implicitly, making a case for the possibility of “futurabilia”.


[i] Lane Craig, William.  “Middle Knowledge, Truth-makers, and the ‘Ground Breaking’ Objection” Article on
[ii] Westminster Confession Chapter III.  Of God's Eternal Decree


Saturday, June 13, 2009

The "Crux" is the Crux of the Matter

     "This is the heart of the matter."  Most of us have heard that said during conversation; when someone wants to make a particularly salient point, one that they believe encapsulates the very focus of the idea they are presenting, they may employ this adage, "now this is the crux of the matter".  The word "crux" is Latin and translates into English as the word "cross".  It is interesting that the Latin word for cross is used in a saying which is attempting to set apart a certain portion of one's conversation as being the most important part.  It is no mistake that this has happened.  Aside from the obvious involvement of the Cause of Causes, men who knew the importance of the cross to the body of Christian doctrine and fundamentals have used it in the past to highlight what they are saying by, in essence, claiming, "this is as important and central to what I am attempting to say as the cross is to Christianity".  (1 Cor. 15:13-17) Resurrection necessitates physical death, the death of the cross in particular in our discussion.
      The use of the term cross in the saying is for good reason—for it is true to say that the cross is the heart of the matter of Christianity, and without its truth and efficacy there is no resurrection, no redemption, no life after death, and no meaning to our present existence; no inalienable rights, and no real cause for what might be referred to as goodness, regardless of cultural moras.

Friday, June 12, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 3


     After studying the doctrine of sanctification as represented in the three confessions I consulted: The Westminster Confession of Faith (WCF), the Belgic Confession (BCF), and the 1689 Baptist Confession of Faith (LBC), I have drawn the following conclusion about their contents.
     Christ’s death and resurrection are the power behind sanctification (WCF).  Believers are sanctified by the virtue of His work, (LBC) and sin’s dominion is destroyed (WCF) as the regenerate have been freed from the slavery of sin (BCF).  Even our lust after sin is mortified (WCF).  At our regeneration we are made new creatures capable of living the “new life”. (BCF)  Sanctification is a manifestation of “true faith” that comes by the hearing of God’s Word (BCF) and true believers are progressively strengthened in all saving graces for to practice holiness (WCF).  This holiness is perfected in the fear of God as we seek a heavenly life through evangelical obedience to all God’s commands (LBC).  Believers are warmed to pious and holy living out off a love for God (BCF).  Only the holy see God, (WCF) but the truly regenerate necessarily bare fruit (do what God has commanded) (BCF).  Good works done by believers are acceptable to God because those works are sanctified by His grace (BCF), and it is God who works those good works in us (BCF).  Always keeping in mind that salvation is not based on our good works, and our assurance of regeneration does not come from those works (BCF).  Nevertheless, even though our good works do not merit God’s favor, He does reward them with crowns (BCF).  Finally, sanctification is imperfect and the believer does struggle against temptation and sin, (WCF) but overcoming sin, growing in grace, and the fear of God are characteristics of believers (WCF).  Certainty in our justification should rest on the merit of Christ our Savior (BCF).
     In later posts in this series I plan to quote recent (and by recent I mean in the last 200 or so years) authors regarding the topic of sanctification, and contrast these statements above with opposing views.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Calvin on The Newness of the New Covenant - An Answer to My Question

In my last post I questioned Calvin's view of regeneration in the Old Covenant. As I read further in his comments on Jeremiah 31:31-34, I found this.

" A question may however be here moved, Was the grace of regeneration wanting to the Fathers under the Law? But this is quite preposterous. What, then, is meant when God denies here that the Law was written on the heart before the coming of Christ? To this I answer, that the Fathers, who were formerly regenerated, obtained this favor through Christ, so that we may say, that it was as it were transferred to them from another source. The power then to penetrate into the heart was not inherent in the Law, but it was a benefit transferred to the Law from the Gospel. This is one thing. Then we know that this grace of God was rare and little known under the Law; but that under the Gospel the gifts of the Spirit have been more abundantly poured forth, and that God has dealt more bountifully with his Church. But still the main thing is, to consider what the Law of itself is, and what is peculiar to the Gospel, especially when a comparison is made between the Law and the Gospel. For when this comparison ceases, this cannot be properly applied to the Law; but with regard to the Gospel it is said, that the Law is that of the letter, as it is called elsewhere, (Rom. 7:6) and this also is the reason why Paul calls it the letter in 2 Cor. 3:6, “the letter killeth,” etc. By “letter” he means not what Origen foolishly explained, for he perverted that passage as he did almost the whole Scripture: Paul does not mean there the simple and plain sense of the Law; for he calls it the letter for another reason, because it only sets before the eyes of men what is right, and sounds it also in their ears. And the word letter refers to what is written, as though he had said, The Law was written on stones, and was therefore a letter. But the Gospel — what is it? It is spirit, that is, God not only addresses his word to the ears of men and sets it before their eyes, but he also inwardly teaches their hearts and minds. This is then the solution of the question: the Prophet speaks of the Law in itself, as apart from the Gospel, for the Law then is dead and destitute of the Spirit of regeneration."

Calvin on The Newness of the New Covenant

In my absence I have continued to edit my paper on the contrast and comparison of Dispensationalism with Covenant Theology. In my study on Jeremiah 31:31-34, I came across this interesting paragraph by Calvin.

"As then God has added nothing to the Law as to the substance of the doctrine, we must come, as I have already said, to the form, as Christ was not as yet manifested: God made a new covenant, when he accomplished through his Son whatever had been shadowed forth under the Law. For the sacrifices could not of themselves pacify God, as it is well known, and whatever the Law taught respecting expiation was of itself useless and of no importance. The new covenant then was made when Christ appeared with water and blood, and really fulfilled what God had exhibited under types, so that the faithful might have some taste of salvation. But the coming of Christ would not have been sufficient, had not regeneration by the Holy Spirit been added. It was, then, in some respects, a new thing, that God regenerated the faithful by his Spirit, so that it became not only a doctrine as to the letter, but also efficacious, which not only strikes the ear, but penetrates into the heart, and really forms us for the service of God. The outward mode of teaching was also new, as it is evident to all; for when we compare the Law with the Gospel, we find that God speaks to us now openly, as it were face to face, and not under a veil, as Paul teaches us, when speaking of Moses, who put on a veil when he went forth to address the people in God’s name. (2 Cor. 3:13) It is not so, says Paul, under the Gospel, but the veil is removed, and God in the face of Christ presents himself to be seen by us. This, then, is the reason why the Prophet calls it a new covenant"

While it is entirely possible that I have misunderstood Calvin, I do have a few questions. It seems that he is saying that, "regeneration by the Holy Spirit" is one of the new things in the New Covenant, hence the word, "added". Perhaps I have misread him here because he goes on to say, "God speaks to us now openly, as it were face to face, and not under a veil, as Paul teaches us, when speaking of Moses, who put on a veil when he went forth to address the people in God’s name. It is not so, says Paul, under the Gospel, but the veil is removed, and God in the face of Christ presents himself to be seen by us. This, then, is the reason why the Prophet calls it a new covenant".

If anyone has any insight here, I would greatly appreciate their advice.

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Analogia de Haeresis - The Correct Analogy

The Man makes a statue that bears His resemblance.  The statue trips over his own shadow and breaks into pieces when he hits the ground.  The Man makes a statue which He can inhabit, and enters the room where the statue resides; He then remakes the statue and he lives with The Man forever.

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Analogia de Haeresis

Below is an analogy of "heresies".  Though the term heresy seems to have as many definitions as there are persons willing to apply it, I think it is necessary to offer one more to help explain my purposes in this article.  I simply refer to the term as an idea or conception of truth  and reality that at least appears Christian, but upon measurement against scripture and orthodox historical theology, it is found to deny such doctrines so as to render it non-Christian.   Having said that, here is a list of such bodies of belief to which I've applied the analogy of a man and his creation of a statue as a self portrait so to explain in the simplest way possible, the teachings behind the terms that name them.

Arianism - The Man makes a statue that bears His resemblance.  The Man then sits on top of the statue and proclaims his existence to the statue.

Marcianism - The Man makes a statue that bears His resemblance.  The Man hates the statue and contemplates its destruction.  The Man has a Son and The Son and The Son loves the statue and, against His Father's wishes, He claims it for His own.

Pelagianism - The Man makes a statue that bears His resemblance. The Man leaves the statue to its own devises, and the statue is left to will itself to life.

Romanism - The Man makes a statue that bears His resemblance. The Man gives the statue life, but it must wonder back and forth in order to maintain its life.  If it stumbles, then it must bring its broken pieces to another man whom The Man has hired, so that man can take the pieces to The Man so He can mend its pieces.  If the statue stumbles and breaks its head off in a fall, it must take its head to the hireling and the hireling entreats The Man to remake the statue and re-constitute it with new life.  Once The Man decides not to remake the statue, the pieces are loaded into a dump truck which drives aimlessly around until The Man decides the statue's worth is such that it can finally go to the New Quarry to work for His Son.

Unitarianism - The Man makes a statue that bears His resemblance. The Man has no son of His own, but adopts a son ans sends him to stand beside the statue and proclaim his adopted Father's existence.

Annihilationism - The Man makes 2 statues, both bearing His resemblance. The Man gives one of them life,but He leaves the other alone.  The one given life, eventually ends up at the New Quarry working for The Man's Son, while the other is completely destroyed.

Universalism - The Man makes 2 statues, both bearing His resemblance.  The Man gives them both life and they both end up working for His Son at the New Quarry.

Monday, December 15, 2008

Christological Predestination? - Lapsarianism

     In many discussions about predestination, the ominous word, "Lapsarianism" may possibly come up.  It comes from the Latin word lapsus, and means "fall" in theological usage.  Some may say from the outset, that any discussion that attempts to apprehend the order in which God decreed events (and that is the topic with which Lapsarianism is concerned) is arrogant and presumes that the creature could actually understand and speculate on such an order.  I certainly don't pretend to have figured out for myself, topics such as these, and I don't expect to resolve this matter in a simple blog article, nor do I submit that, because our minds are finite, this discussion is wholly off limits.
     There are two primary forms of lapsarianism and they are used to describe one's view of the timing of God's decrees: Supralapsarianism and Infralapsarianism.  The former posits that God decreed the election and reprobation of the human race before He decreed the fall, and the later submits that God must have decreed the election and reprobation of humanity after He had decreed the fall.  For a detailed description of these two terms, please see Herman Bavinck's article.
     In the context of this series of articles on "Christological Predestination", Lapsarianism is useful precisely because it focuses in on the nature and order of God's decrees regarding the salvation or damnation of His creatures.  It is readily apparent that any type of Lapsarianism assumes God's decree or ordination of the fall, an idea that many evangelicals (particularly those breathing the air of democracy) hold in contempt against their libertarian freedom from God's sovereignty.  For instance, those who promote  Christological Predestination as opposed to God's positive predestination of individuals in addition to setting Christ aside as the Elect one, are likely to use the idea of God's direct decree only of the election of Christ (Isaiah 42) to deny that His foreknowledge of one's regeneration is not conditioned upon His foresight of their future faith, that the Holy Spirit never fails in the attempt to regenerate those who will believe, thus proponents of Christological Predestination also deny the actual atonement made specially for those who God has elected in favor of an atonement that only potentially covers everyone. In other words, those who hold to the doctrine of Christological Predestination are likely to deny the doctrines of grace (Calvinism), in fact, that seems to be its very point.  But the converse statement is not true; those who do hold to the doctrines of grace do not deny that Christ is the Elect One, just as He is the True Israel.

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Christological Predestination?

I have recently been engaged in a discussion of "Christological Predestination".  Though this idea was not new to me yesterday, I had not given it a great deal of thought until now.  I believe this will result in a brief series on the topic and its consequent beliefs.  By the way, anyone else who has thought about this, doesn't it sound a bit like the teachings of Norm Shepard and the Auburn Ave. crew?

What is Christological Predestination?

As far as I can gather, it is the idea that God elected Christ, and those who believe are, as Paul so often puts it, "in Christ", but to the exclusion (or neglect) of God's election of individuals, but that persons "elect" themselves by believing.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - IX

Below is a copy of the most recent comment regarding this discussion, compliments to my friend Kerry Lewis over at, Hymnus Deo.  I thought it was significant enough to reproduce here.

"To quote the Mad Hatter, "I'm late! I'm late!" Here, in a few words, is what I had intended to post last week.

According to Brethren biographer Robert Baylis, Darby traveled through Continental Europe between 1839 and 1845. He was fluent in French, German, and Italian, and so he was able to travel and move among the various countries fairly easily. According to Wikipedia, he translated the Bible into French and German. Whether or not he wrote in any language other than English, however, I still don't know.

In Darby's tract, as I remember, he did mention "pastors" in a favourable way, but I would guess that he was using the term as synonymous with "elder", which for him would carry the idea of lay offices only.

Between what is called the Open Brethren and what is called the Closed or Exclusive Brethren, however, there have been differences. (There are even differences between the Closed and the Exclusive Brethren for some - at least, in the way they use the terms. Generally, however, my understanding is that the terms "Closed" and "Exclusive" refer to the same type of Brethren. So that is how I'm using them here.) If I showed up at an Open Brethren assembly this Sunday (such as Shannon Hills in Greensboro, which I attended growing up), I could partake of worship and the Lord's Supper, so long as I professed faith in Jesus Christ, whether or not I held to the principles uniquely held by the Brethren. With the Exclusives, however, you not only have to be in fellowship with a Brethren assembly in order to participate in worship, you have to be in fellowship with an accepted Closed Brethren assembly. They actually have two sets of chairs set up in an Exclusive Brethren meeting hall. The inner circle is for those who are Exclusives and able to participate (not under church discipline, etc.). The outer circle is for those who, for whatever reason, aren't allowed to participate. They are allowed to observe only. (There was a great low-budget film put out this past Spring by Paramount Vantage called Son of Rambow. It's about an Exclusive Brethren boy in England and the trials he has trying to balance his life with the Brethren and his life with those outside of the Brethren. The treatment of the Exclusives is slightly exaggerated, but not much, and it captures the spirit of the movement - the Opens, but especially the Exclusives - very well. It was my favourite movie this year. See it, if you get a chance. It's on dvd now. I saw it at the Carousel Grande when it was playing.)

The Exclusive or Closed Brethren usually utilize the phrase "Gospel Hall" in their assembly names (such as "Hickory Gospel Hall", which actually exists in Hickory, N. C.). The Open Brethren usually utilize the phrase "Chapel" or "Bible Chapel" in their assembly names (as in "Shannon Hills Bible Chapel").

The Closed Brethren descend from Darby. The Open Brethren descend from leaders like George Mueller and Anthony Norris Groves. Of course, there have been splits and variations since then, and these started within just a few years of the movement, the first split being between the Open and the Closed Brethren.

Among the Open Brethren, the form of church government is Independency for each assembly, and each assembly is ruled by a body of elders and deacons, whose roles operate largely after the manner of Presbyterianism. But there was a variation on this that happened among the Exclusives. In 1838, they began holding a meeting every Saturday night composed of leaders from the various Closed assemblies in and around London. The stated intention was to help smaller assemblies in matters of policy and administration. But the practical effect was the creation of a central ruling body, that claimed for itself enough power to discipline members and bar them from the Lord's Table. We would call that a Presbytery, though they wouldn't appreciate us using such a label for them, and their meeting assumed more power to itself than any well-working Presbytery would in Reformed churches. Also, Darby ended up being a sort of default leader for the group, and so they ended up with what we would call a Bishopric or Episcopacy, though they once again wouldn't appreciate us accusing them of this. So Darby went full circle, leaving Episcopacy and ending up there again. The end results of this screwy system is legend, and I couldn't begin to talk about them here.

If you want some other interesting thoughts on the Brethren view of church government, you might check out my brief post from a couple of years ago here:

http://hymnusdeo.blogspot.com/2006/12/exclusive-brethren-elders.html
"