Romans 5:7-9
Tuesday, April 6, 2010
A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Concluding Remarks
Friday, April 2, 2010
A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Aquinas - 2
Wednesday, March 31, 2010
A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Aquinas - 1
Monday, March 29, 2010
A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Anselm - 1
Anselm
Anselm, being perhaps the first theologian in 800 years to say so, did not find propitious, this theory of atonement which had an exclusive emphasis on ransom, thus facilitating his proposition of another theory. Anselm’s pioneering ideas in general proved to have influenced a 1000 years of atonement theology since his death. 55 years ago one philosopher described Anselm in this way.
Friday, March 26, 2010
A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Abelard - 2
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Abelard - 1
Monday, March 22, 2010
A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Anselm - 2
Saturday, March 20, 2010
A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Preface
Friday, March 19, 2010
A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Introduction
New Series - Theories of Christ's Atonement
Monday, September 7, 2009
God's Knowledge, Who Can Know it? - part 4
Saturday, June 13, 2009
The "Crux" is the Crux of the Matter
Friday, June 12, 2009
Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 3
Wednesday, January 21, 2009
Calvin on The Newness of the New Covenant - An Answer to My Question
" A question may however be here moved, Was the grace of regeneration wanting to the Fathers under the Law? But this is quite preposterous. What, then, is meant when God denies here that the Law was written on the heart before the coming of Christ? To this I answer, that the Fathers, who were formerly regenerated, obtained this favor through Christ, so that we may say, that it was as it were transferred to them from another source. The power then to penetrate into the heart was not inherent in the Law, but it was a benefit transferred to the Law from the Gospel. This is one thing. Then we know that this grace of God was rare and little known under the Law; but that under the Gospel the gifts of the Spirit have been more abundantly poured forth, and that God has dealt more bountifully with his Church. But still the main thing is, to consider what the Law of itself is, and what is peculiar to the Gospel, especially when a comparison is made between the Law and the Gospel. For when this comparison ceases, this cannot be properly applied to the Law; but with regard to the Gospel it is said, that the Law is that of the letter, as it is called elsewhere, (Rom. 7:6) and this also is the reason why Paul calls it the letter in 2 Cor. 3:6, “the letter killeth,” etc. By “letter” he means not what Origen foolishly explained, for he perverted that passage as he did almost the whole Scripture: Paul does not mean there the simple and plain sense of the Law; for he calls it the letter for another reason, because it only sets before the eyes of men what is right, and sounds it also in their ears. And the word letter refers to what is written, as though he had said, The Law was written on stones, and was therefore a letter. But the Gospel — what is it? It is spirit, that is, God not only addresses his word to the ears of men and sets it before their eyes, but he also inwardly teaches their hearts and minds. This is then the solution of the question: the Prophet speaks of the Law in itself, as apart from the Gospel, for the Law then is dead and destitute of the Spirit of regeneration."
Calvin on The Newness of the New Covenant
"As then God has added nothing to the Law as to the substance of the doctrine, we must come, as I have already said, to the form, as Christ was not as yet manifested: God made a new covenant, when he accomplished through his Son whatever had been shadowed forth under the Law. For the sacrifices could not of themselves pacify God, as it is well known, and whatever the Law taught respecting expiation was of itself useless and of no importance. The new covenant then was made when Christ appeared with water and blood, and really fulfilled what God had exhibited under types, so that the faithful might have some taste of salvation. But the coming of Christ would not have been sufficient, had not regeneration by the Holy Spirit been added. It was, then, in some respects, a new thing, that God regenerated the faithful by his Spirit, so that it became not only a doctrine as to the letter, but also efficacious, which not only strikes the ear, but penetrates into the heart, and really forms us for the service of God. The outward mode of teaching was also new, as it is evident to all; for when we compare the Law with the Gospel, we find that God speaks to us now openly, as it were face to face, and not under a veil, as Paul teaches us, when speaking of Moses, who put on a veil when he went forth to address the people in God’s name. (2 Cor. 3:13) It is not so, says Paul, under the Gospel, but the veil is removed, and God in the face of Christ presents himself to be seen by us. This, then, is the reason why the Prophet calls it a new covenant"
While it is entirely possible that I have misunderstood Calvin, I do have a few questions. It seems that he is saying that, "regeneration by the Holy Spirit" is one of the new things in the New Covenant, hence the word, "added". Perhaps I have misread him here because he goes on to say, "God speaks to us now openly, as it were face to face, and not under a veil, as Paul teaches us, when speaking of Moses, who put on a veil when he went forth to address the people in God’s name. It is not so, says Paul, under the Gospel, but the veil is removed, and God in the face of Christ presents himself to be seen by us. This, then, is the reason why the Prophet calls it a new covenant".
If anyone has any insight here, I would greatly appreciate their advice.
Wednesday, January 14, 2009
Analogia de Haeresis - The Correct Analogy
Tuesday, December 30, 2008
Analogia de Haeresis
Monday, December 15, 2008
Christological Predestination? - Lapsarianism
Wednesday, December 10, 2008
Christological Predestination?
What is Christological Predestination?
As far as I can gather, it is the idea that God elected Christ, and those who believe are, as Paul so often puts it, "in Christ", but to the exclusion (or neglect) of God's election of individuals, but that persons "elect" themselves by believing.
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Further Questions for Dispensationalists - IX
"To quote the Mad Hatter, "I'm late! I'm late!" Here, in a few words, is what I had intended to post last week.
According to Brethren biographer Robert Baylis, Darby traveled through Continental Europe between 1839 and 1845. He was fluent in French, German, and Italian, and so he was able to travel and move among the various countries fairly easily. According to Wikipedia, he translated the Bible into French and German. Whether or not he wrote in any language other than English, however, I still don't know.
In Darby's tract, as I remember, he did mention "pastors" in a favourable way, but I would guess that he was using the term as synonymous with "elder", which for him would carry the idea of lay offices only.
Between what is called the Open Brethren and what is called the Closed or Exclusive Brethren, however, there have been differences. (There are even differences between the Closed and the Exclusive Brethren for some - at least, in the way they use the terms. Generally, however, my understanding is that the terms "Closed" and "Exclusive" refer to the same type of Brethren. So that is how I'm using them here.) If I showed up at an Open Brethren assembly this Sunday (such as Shannon Hills in Greensboro, which I attended growing up), I could partake of worship and the Lord's Supper, so long as I professed faith in Jesus Christ, whether or not I held to the principles uniquely held by the Brethren. With the Exclusives, however, you not only have to be in fellowship with a Brethren assembly in order to participate in worship, you have to be in fellowship with an accepted Closed Brethren assembly. They actually have two sets of chairs set up in an Exclusive Brethren meeting hall. The inner circle is for those who are Exclusives and able to participate (not under church discipline, etc.). The outer circle is for those who, for whatever reason, aren't allowed to participate. They are allowed to observe only. (There was a great low-budget film put out this past Spring by Paramount Vantage called Son of Rambow. It's about an Exclusive Brethren boy in England and the trials he has trying to balance his life with the Brethren and his life with those outside of the Brethren. The treatment of the Exclusives is slightly exaggerated, but not much, and it captures the spirit of the movement - the Opens, but especially the Exclusives - very well. It was my favourite movie this year. See it, if you get a chance. It's on dvd now. I saw it at the Carousel Grande when it was playing.)
The Exclusive or Closed Brethren usually utilize the phrase "Gospel Hall" in their assembly names (such as "Hickory Gospel Hall", which actually exists in Hickory, N. C.). The Open Brethren usually utilize the phrase "Chapel" or "Bible Chapel" in their assembly names (as in "Shannon Hills Bible Chapel").
The Closed Brethren descend from Darby. The Open Brethren descend from leaders like George Mueller and Anthony Norris Groves. Of course, there have been splits and variations since then, and these started within just a few years of the movement, the first split being between the Open and the Closed Brethren.
Among the Open Brethren, the form of church government is Independency for each assembly, and each assembly is ruled by a body of elders and deacons, whose roles operate largely after the manner of Presbyterianism. But there was a variation on this that happened among the Exclusives. In 1838, they began holding a meeting every Saturday night composed of leaders from the various Closed assemblies in and around London. The stated intention was to help smaller assemblies in matters of policy and administration. But the practical effect was the creation of a central ruling body, that claimed for itself enough power to discipline members and bar them from the Lord's Table. We would call that a Presbytery, though they wouldn't appreciate us using such a label for them, and their meeting assumed more power to itself than any well-working Presbytery would in Reformed churches. Also, Darby ended up being a sort of default leader for the group, and so they ended up with what we would call a Bishopric or Episcopacy, though they once again wouldn't appreciate us accusing them of this. So Darby went full circle, leaving Episcopacy and ending up there again. The end results of this screwy system is legend, and I couldn't begin to talk about them here.
If you want some other interesting thoughts on the Brethren view of church government, you might check out my brief post from a couple of years ago here:
http://hymnusdeo.blogspot.com/2006/12/exclusive-brethren-elders.html "