Romans 5:7-9

For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.
Showing posts with label Anthropology: Quotes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anthropology: Quotes. Show all posts

Monday, July 20, 2009

Bird on a Wire


"Like a bird on the wire
Like a drunk in a midnight choir
I have tried in my way to be free

Like a worm on a hook
Like a knight from some old fashioned book
I have saved all my ribbons for thee

If I have been unkind
I hope that you can just let it go by
If I have been untrue
I hope you know it was never to you

Like a baby, stillborn
Like a beast with his horn
I have torn everyone who reached out for me

But I swear by this song
And by all that I have done wrong
I will make it all up to thee

I saw a beggar leaning on his wooden crutch
He said to me, "You must not ask for so much"
And a pretty woman leaning in her darkened door
She cried to me, "Hey, why not ask for more?"

Like a bird on the wire
Like a drunk in a midnight choir
I have tried in my way to be free."
     These are the words of one of my favorite musicians, Leonard Cohen, from his song “Bird on a Wire”. As I listened to this song for the first time in a long while the stanza, “But I swear by this song and by all that I have done wrong; I will make it all up to thee”, really hit me in a different way than it ever had before. Perhaps because, since I have been considering theology more closely now than when I had first begun to examine Cohen’s lyrics, I thought of the way God promised Moses that He would lead the people out of Egypt. Moses asked who he should tell the people sent him as their deliver and God answered, “Tell them, I AM sent you.”; for there is no other name greater than Yahweh. And before that, God swore to Abraham about which the author of Hebrews makes this comment “13For when God made a promise to Abraham, since he had no one greater by whom to swear, he swore by himself, 14saying, "Surely I will bless you and multiply you." 15And thus Abraham, having patiently waited, obtained the promise. 16For people swear by something greater than themselves, and in all their disputes an oath is final for confirmation. 17So when God desired to show more convincingly to the heirs of the promise the unchangeable character of his purpose, he guaranteed it with an oath, 18so that by two unchangeable things, in which it is impossible for God to lie, we who have fled for refuge might have strong encouragement to hold fast to the hope set before us.” Likewise in the stanza I set apart, Cohen swears by two certain things: the existence of the words of the very song in which the oath is made and by the certainty of things wrongly done; if one thing we do in this life is certain it is doing things wrong. So an oath by the things we have done wrong contains two aspects to observe: the promise is in the certainty of the words of the swearing itself (sort of: “I promise by this promise that I will…”) and the great irony of making a promise on broken promises. In essence Cohen promises to make up for all that he has done wrong by swearing on the historical certainty of all that he has done wrong. And the promise rests on the honor of the song, by the truth of the song itself, he will make up for all he has done wrong. Circular and self-attesting as it may be, the words are gripping and their beauty may lie in their honest arrogance.

Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Quotes - Hoekema on Revelation 20

Below is a quote from Anthony Hoekema's "The Bible and the Future".  It is couched in a chapter discussing the major millennial views.  Anyone familiar with the debate over the nature of the millennium, is familiar with the importance of one's interpretation of Rev. 20.  The following is the third in a list of objections to Dispensational Premillennialism.
"(3) The return of the glorified Christ and of glorified believers to an earth where sin and death still exist would violate the finality of their glorification.  Why should believers, who have been enjoying heavenly glory during the intermediate state, be raised from the dead in order to return to an earth  return to an earth where sin and death still exist? Would this not be an anticlimax?  Do not glorified resurrection bodies call for lfe on a new earth, from which all remnants of sin and of the curse have been banished?  Why, further, should the glorified Christ return to an earth where sin and death still exist?  Why should He after His return in glory still have to rule His enemies with a rod of iron, and still have to crush a final rebellion against Him at the close of the millennium?  Was not Christ's battling against His enemies completed during His state of humiliation?  Did He not during that time win the final, decisive victory over evil, sin, death, and Satan?  Does not the Bible teach that Christ is coming back in the fulness of His glory to usher in, not an intrim period of qualified peace and blessing, but the final state of unqualified perfection?

Monday, February 23, 2009

Quotes - The Edge

     An interesting quote occurred in the 1997 movie with Alec Baldwin and Anthony Hopkins, "The Edge".  "A good plan today is better than a perfect plan tomorrow." - Robert Green (As played by Alec Baldwin).
     I have always found it fascinating how playwrights and screen-playwrights have worked philosophical views into dramatic and theatrical media.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Quotes - The Office

"Also, I'm pretty sure she coughed up a hairball." - Oscar from "The Office".

Monday, February 9, 2009

Ministry Highlight - 9 Marks

     I'm beginning a ministry highlight post.  This will be the first in an ongoing series I plan to submit once every month.
     This first month will highlight 9 Marks ministries.  This is a ministry organized by Mark Dever and the folks at Capitol Hill Baptist Church.  Though there are countless written resources there, my favorite is the audio.  Every so often, Mark interviews a a person of faith, usually dealing with their personal involvement in the Kingdom, he asks probing questions that always produce an edifying experience.  About six months ago, he interviewed David Powlison.
     In the interview, David provided this humorous quote, "I never met a nuance I didn't like."

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Calvin on The Newness of the New Covenant - An Answer to My Question

In my last post I questioned Calvin's view of regeneration in the Old Covenant. As I read further in his comments on Jeremiah 31:31-34, I found this.

" A question may however be here moved, Was the grace of regeneration wanting to the Fathers under the Law? But this is quite preposterous. What, then, is meant when God denies here that the Law was written on the heart before the coming of Christ? To this I answer, that the Fathers, who were formerly regenerated, obtained this favor through Christ, so that we may say, that it was as it were transferred to them from another source. The power then to penetrate into the heart was not inherent in the Law, but it was a benefit transferred to the Law from the Gospel. This is one thing. Then we know that this grace of God was rare and little known under the Law; but that under the Gospel the gifts of the Spirit have been more abundantly poured forth, and that God has dealt more bountifully with his Church. But still the main thing is, to consider what the Law of itself is, and what is peculiar to the Gospel, especially when a comparison is made between the Law and the Gospel. For when this comparison ceases, this cannot be properly applied to the Law; but with regard to the Gospel it is said, that the Law is that of the letter, as it is called elsewhere, (Rom. 7:6) and this also is the reason why Paul calls it the letter in 2 Cor. 3:6, “the letter killeth,” etc. By “letter” he means not what Origen foolishly explained, for he perverted that passage as he did almost the whole Scripture: Paul does not mean there the simple and plain sense of the Law; for he calls it the letter for another reason, because it only sets before the eyes of men what is right, and sounds it also in their ears. And the word letter refers to what is written, as though he had said, The Law was written on stones, and was therefore a letter. But the Gospel — what is it? It is spirit, that is, God not only addresses his word to the ears of men and sets it before their eyes, but he also inwardly teaches their hearts and minds. This is then the solution of the question: the Prophet speaks of the Law in itself, as apart from the Gospel, for the Law then is dead and destitute of the Spirit of regeneration."

Calvin on The Newness of the New Covenant

In my absence I have continued to edit my paper on the contrast and comparison of Dispensationalism with Covenant Theology. In my study on Jeremiah 31:31-34, I came across this interesting paragraph by Calvin.

"As then God has added nothing to the Law as to the substance of the doctrine, we must come, as I have already said, to the form, as Christ was not as yet manifested: God made a new covenant, when he accomplished through his Son whatever had been shadowed forth under the Law. For the sacrifices could not of themselves pacify God, as it is well known, and whatever the Law taught respecting expiation was of itself useless and of no importance. The new covenant then was made when Christ appeared with water and blood, and really fulfilled what God had exhibited under types, so that the faithful might have some taste of salvation. But the coming of Christ would not have been sufficient, had not regeneration by the Holy Spirit been added. It was, then, in some respects, a new thing, that God regenerated the faithful by his Spirit, so that it became not only a doctrine as to the letter, but also efficacious, which not only strikes the ear, but penetrates into the heart, and really forms us for the service of God. The outward mode of teaching was also new, as it is evident to all; for when we compare the Law with the Gospel, we find that God speaks to us now openly, as it were face to face, and not under a veil, as Paul teaches us, when speaking of Moses, who put on a veil when he went forth to address the people in God’s name. (2 Cor. 3:13) It is not so, says Paul, under the Gospel, but the veil is removed, and God in the face of Christ presents himself to be seen by us. This, then, is the reason why the Prophet calls it a new covenant"

While it is entirely possible that I have misunderstood Calvin, I do have a few questions. It seems that he is saying that, "regeneration by the Holy Spirit" is one of the new things in the New Covenant, hence the word, "added". Perhaps I have misread him here because he goes on to say, "God speaks to us now openly, as it were face to face, and not under a veil, as Paul teaches us, when speaking of Moses, who put on a veil when he went forth to address the people in God’s name. It is not so, says Paul, under the Gospel, but the veil is removed, and God in the face of Christ presents himself to be seen by us. This, then, is the reason why the Prophet calls it a new covenant".

If anyone has any insight here, I would greatly appreciate their advice.

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Quotes on Sanctification - Calvin

I thought this quote from John Calvin was illuminating.  It is taken from his comments on Galatians 3:22.

"No man who has a choice given him will be so mad as to despise freedom, and prefer slavery."

It appears that Calvin considered those (as Paul probably did) who preferred to place themselves under the strict tutelage of the Law, crazy.  We fallen creatures are bent in that direction even today, when we prefer the moralistic position of the weaker brother to the freedom of the mature.

Thursday, December 18, 2008

Quotes on the Gospel: Sanctification

Below is a quote from John Calvin from his commentary on Romans 2, verse 25 specifically.  I found this as I read through his comments on chapter two, looking to be enlightened on the topic of Amillennialism, and stumbled onto this brief statement that I find describes what it really means to be under the gracious sanctification of God.

"...for no one, who is seriously touched and moved by the fear of God, will ever dare to raise up his eyes to heaven, since the more he strives after true righteousness, the clearer he sees how far he is from it."

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

The Theology of Art

I guess its because most Christians are not forced to think about it formally day to day, but the question of beauty is neglected in our "world-view".  If anyone knows of a published systematic theology that includes a treatment on beauty, please let me know.  I am aware of several theologians who have written on the subject, Edwards, Sproul, and Kuyper (regarding the theology of art), who I have quoted below.
"And all these because the beautiful is not the product of our own fantasy, nor of our subjective perception, but has an objective existence, being itself the expression of a Divine perfection."  Abraham Kuyper from, "Lectures on Calvinism"
It seems important to me, not only because I am confronted with ideas of aesthetics on a daily basis due to my vocation, but also (and perhaps more importantly) because Americans are constantly , through all sorts of mediums, being told what is beautiful by untrustworthy sources.  Ultimately, that which is true is that which is beautiful.  So, beauty directly corresponds to truth; the degree to which something is true is the degree to which it is also beautiful.  And now for a bit of sarcasm...

"Don't teach me about truth and beauty, just label my music"  Derek Web from his song, "New Law".

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

The Importance of Past Theological Opinions

Below is are a couple quotes I took from a recent post on the blog, Between Two Worlds.

Michael Horton: "The best way to guard a true interpretation of Scripture, the Reformers insisted, was neither to naively embrace the infallibility of tradition, or the infallibility of the individual, but to recognize the communal interpretation of Scripture. The best way to ensure faithfulness to the text is to read it together, not only with the churches of our own time and place, but with the wider 'communion of saints' down through the age."

Larry Woiwode: "There is rugged terrain ahead for those who are constitutionally incapable of referring to the paths marked out by wise and spirit-filled cartographers over the centuries."

Friday, October 3, 2008

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - VIII

In light of some of the content of my past few posts, I would like to present a few quotes from J. N. Darby.  Not the only voice hailing from what we refer to as the "brethren" movement, but likely the most known.  The following quotes are all taken from "The Notion of a Clergyman, dispensationally the sin against the Holy Spirit".  We must note here that, in large measure, his definition of "clergyman" was made in the historical context of a battle against "Puseyism", or "Tractarianism", which was, according to the definition given the term by Merriam-Webster, "a system of High Church principles set forth in a series of tracts at Oxford (1833-41)".  Even so, Darby is helpful in manifesting his distaste really for any form of ecclesiastical authority.

Again (to use a couple metaphors with sharp tools) I'm not trying to "grind an axe", or "bury the hatchet", but in my attempt to understand Dispensationalism more fully, I am trying to step into the shoes of those who took part in its historical development and evolution.  In the process of this research, I have seen several tangential theologies, philosophies, and practices that have caught my attention: a neglect of historical theology and its categories, a rejection of Calvinistic & and Reformed theology, and as we shall see, a general disregard for the distinction between layman and elder/pastor (to put it in the categories we recognize today).  So, if there are any dispensationalists reading this article, the questions are, what do you make of these quotes, do you think that Dispensationalism is inherently non-Calvinistic, individualistic in its polity, and largely uninterested in historical theology and its bearing on how we form our own theology?

"It is a question of the dispensational standing of the church in the world - a statement that that depends wholly on the power and presence of the Holy Ghost, and that the notion of a clergyman contradicts His title and power, on which the standing of the church down here depends. It is the habitation of God through the Spirit. Scripture is clear, that if the Gentiles do not abide in God's goodness, they will be cut off like the Jews. It equally predicts a falling away, which is not continuing in God's goodness. I believe these times are hasting greatly."
"I must be observed here to say nothing whatever against offices in the church of Christ, and the exercise of authority in them, whether episcopal or evangelical in character. It were a vain and unnecessary work here to prove the recognition of that on which scripture is so plain. But they are spoken of in Scripture as gifts derived from on high: "He gave some apostles" (Eph. 4: 5, 7, 11); so in 1 Corinthians 12, they are known only as gifts. My objection to the notion of a Clergyman is, that it substitutes something in the place of all these, which cannot be said to be of God at all, and is not found in Scripture. Now, I believe the whole principle of this to be contained in this dispensation in the word clergyman, and that this is the necessary root of that denial of the Holy Ghost which must, from the nature of the dispensation, end in its dissolution… But if clergymen have the exclusive privilege of preaching, teaching, and ministering communion, which they claim, and which is the very sense and meaning of their distinctive title, then must it be all evil. That is, the notion of a Clergyman necessarily involves the charge of evil on the work of the Holy Ghost, and therefore, I say, that the notion of a Clergyman involves the dispensation, where insisted upon, in the sin against the Holy Ghost."
"Sinners are converted to God, souls called out of darkness, the truth preached with energy and love to souls, with the Holy Ghost sent down from heaven, in the constraint and constancy (in whatever weakness) of the Redeemer's love: men are gathered from evil and wickedness (for I will put the fullest case my adversaries could wish) into the communion of the Lord's love, to bear witness to their sole dependence on His dying love; and this is producing confusion and schism - of which God is not the author, but Satan - because they are not, nor are brought together by, clergymen! What is this but to charge the work of divine grace with proceeding from, and having the character of, the author of evil, which is blasphemy? and this is the immediate and direct effect, the necessary effect, of the notion - the exclusive notion of a Clergyman."
"And let us for a moment look at what the word means, and we shall very remarkably find the same great characteristic mark of apostasy upon it: the substitution of a privileged order whom man owned for the Church which God owned, and the consequent depression of the Church and the despisal of the Holy Ghost in it, or blasphemy against it. What does clergy mean? It means in scripture the elect body, or rather bodies, of believers, as God's heritage, as contrasted with those who were instructors, or had spiritual oversight over them; and it is used in the place where the apostle warns such against ever assuming the place in which - in much worse than which - the ministers have now put themselves; for they are not merely lords over, but the whole cleroi themselves. The present use of the word is precisely the sign of the substitution of ministers in the place of the Church of God: as men are accustomed to speak of "going into the church." Now, all this is of the essence of apostasy: power attached to ministry, and its becoming the church in the eye of the world, so that the world can save itself the trouble of being religious by throwing it on the clergy, and so the church and the world be all one thing, and irreligious people do for the church as laity, because religion is the clergy's business, and, if theirs, nobody's (for they do not want it for irreligious laymen); and thus that which has the name of the church, being really the world, serves to exclude and set aside the operations of the Spirit of God in His children as schism and evil; and who is to decide? The church; but they are the world: and will the world ever receive the Spirit of God? It cannot. What then? They hold themselves, of course, the church; they have the clergy, which is God's church in their estimation; and the Spirit of God and His work is voted schismatic. Such is the real and simple meaning of the word clergy so used. But to produce the passage in Scripture - "Be not lords," says Peter, "over God's heritage," to the elders or instructors. That is, over God's Clergy - to give it in its English form of letters, cleroi. The bodies of Christian believers were called God's "lots" (the meaning of the original word cleros) answering to Deuteronomy 9: 29. Now the clergy have assumed to themselves to be God's lot only, but the only use of clergy in Scripture is, as applied to the laity if you please, contrasted with ministers: charging these to assume no lordship."
"The operation of the Reformation was to introduce a statement of individual faith, and to break off, generally, all without the limits of the Roman Empire, from the immediate power of Rome and Popery. It in no way separated the church from the world, but the contrary; and, while it changed the relations, left the principle of the structure just where it was. The King's Arms took the place, in the rood-loft, of the image of Christ. Christ and His Spirit ruled in neither case, save in honour. I verily believe, that the principle of a clergyman, as it is part and parcel of the structure of Popery, will reintroduce the power of Popery as far as the name of religion remains; for as it hangs on the doctrine and principle of succession, not on the presence of the Spirit, there is no ground on which a Protestant minister, as a clergyman, can prove his title, which does not validate the title of the Pope and his followers more even than his own."

Monday, September 29, 2008

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - VI

Below are some supposed "quotes" that I came across, which were attributed to Chafer.  I am now trying to confirm there validity.  If anyone can help identify these, I would be very appreciative.
“With respect to regeneration, the Old testament saints were evidently renewed; but as there is no definite doctrinal teaching relative to the extent character of that renewal, no positive declaration can be made”—Chafer from ?????

“The silence of God must be respected relative to what constituted one a just man according to the Mosaic demands…The Old Testament will be searched in vain for a record of Jews passing from an unsaved state to a saved state, or for any declaration about the terms upon which such a change would be secured.  In other words, their national covenant standing was a tremendous spiritual advantage; but it cannot rightfully be compared with the estate of the believer today who is justified and perfected forever, having received the pleroma of the Godhead through vital union with Christ.”—Chafer from ???

Saturday, July 5, 2008

The Nature of the Kingdom as Described by Ladd

Below is a quote from GE Ladd.

"The central thesis of this book [The Presence of the Future] is that the Kingdom of God is the redemptive reign of God dramatically active to establish his rule among men, and that this Kingdom, which will appear as an apocalyptic act at the end of the age, has already come into human history in the person and mission of Jesus to overcome evil, to deliver men from its power, and to bring them into the blessings of God’s reign. The Kingdom of God involves two great moments: fulfillment within history, and consummation at the end of history."

Thursday, June 12, 2008

Quotes on the Covenant: Election & Assurance

After listening to a conference held about thirty years ago, I have reflected this morning on several statements that were made during one of the panel discussions. I think the speaker who made these statements was Dr. Smith or Dr. Sanders. The conference took place at Covenant Seminary and Jimmy Carter was the President at the time (just to date it), but I don't know all the speakers, just that it is distributed by Mt. Olivet tape library.

"The covenant is the instrument by which election is realized in the world."

"Election is not a means to get anybody lost, but it is a means of getting people saved."

And a quote from the WCF, "Assurance is not of the essence of faith." "I take that to mean that you can be saved and not know it....we can not lose our salvation but we can lose our assurance."


Wednesday, May 7, 2008

Words from Hoekema on the Word

From his book, "The Bible & the Future", Anthony Hoekema has these words to say concerning God's Word,

"Though it is true, therefore, that God reveals himself in the Bible which is his Word, we must not forget that he reveals himself primarily in the historical events which are recorded in the Bible. Revelation occurs through acts as well as through words. But the acts need to be interpreted before their revelatory message can be understood. God reveals himself, therefore, through both acts and words--through his acts as interpreted by his words. So, for example, it is only as the event of the exodus is interpreted by the writers of the Old testament that it is understood to be a revelation of the redemptive power and love of Israel's God who, in the fulfillment of his promises and in answer to their prayers, delivered his people from Egyptian bondage."

This statement causes me to ask just what we think has been "revealed" when we think of the "revelation of God?. One is the revelation of His existence, another thing revealed is His sustaining power, but these two things are revealed also (in more obscure a manner) in the creation itself. In the Bible we find that God revels who He is, His character, who we are and our nature, the fact that we have violated His holiness in Adam and the specific way in which we can be rescued from our unholiness and be reconciled to Him in covenant relationship.

Before the events of history were recorded in the Bible, they were really just part of general revelation and their interpretations could have suffered many widespread errors. Just think of how the Judiazers had misinterpreted the meaning of Christ's fulfillment of all the rituals of the Old Covenant like circumcision. When Paul wrote his letter to the Galatians it had probably been at least 20 years after Christ died. This was ample time for misinformed or malicious persons to arrive at erroneous interpretations of that great historical event before it had been recorded by men, born along by the Spirit of the Author of History Himself, as its interpretation was solidified in special revelation. So, in effect, our understanding of scripture is an interpretation of records which were (at least in its narrative genre) interpretations of historical events. Even though this is the relationship we have to the revelation of God, its complexity doesn't end there The good and simple exposition of the words of the Bible in their contexts do not fully exhaust their meaning for us.

Just as it is absurd (and heretical) to suggest that, because God is a Spirit and He is Holy, then all material things are evil, thus He cannot be incarnate, it is likewise absurd to suggest that just because the Bible does not lay out an idea explicitly, then no "extra-biblical" implication may ever be drawn in support of that idea. It has been the perennial criticism against Covenant Theology that (it's doctrine of a "realized" millennium in particular and its covenantal hermeneutic in general) its working assumptions are only implications drawn from scripture (false implications at that) rather than explications seen on its pages directly. We know of course, that we cannot find a particular verse that explicates the doctrine of particular redemption; "Christ Jesus our Lord died for the individuals the Father predestined and gave to Him and only for them did He shed His blood.", but this doctrine is so clearly implied in scripture that (as far as the historical testimony is concerned) the majority report of Christian orthodoxy affirms it, and so it is with the existence of the covenantal relationships God has ordained in order to commune with His people and His creation at large.

My point is this, I think that the further Christians are removed by time from the cross, the more difficult a time we have interpreting the Bible with its historical generation in mind. This I think is seen clearly in theologies that try to force a hyper-literal or exclusively literal interpretation on texts that (with the entire context of the Bible in mind) do not themselves limit the words that were used to interpret historical people, places, things, and events.

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

"Why I believe in God" by Cornelius Van Til

Below is a quote from Cornelius Van Til's, "Why I Believe in God", which was published by Westminster Theological Seminary, and he was a part of the conservative group that founded the institution, and at which he served God along side such men as J. G. Machen. He was a Dutch Reformed theologian and possibly on of the greatest philosophical minds of the last 100 years. He lived from May 3, 1895 - April 17, 1987.

"I must make an apology to you at this point. We who believe in God have not always made this position plain. Often enough we have talked with you about facts and sound reasons as though we agreed with you on what these really are. In our arguments for the existence of God we have frequently assumed that you and we together have an area of knowledge on which we agree. But we really do not grant that you see any fact in any dimension of life truly. We really think you have colored glasses on your nose when you talk about chickens and cows, as well as when you talk about the life hereafter. We should have told you this more plainly than we did. But we were really a little ashamed of what would appear to you as a very odd or extreme position. We were so anxious not to offend you that we offended our own God. But we dare no longer present our God to you as smaller or less exacting than He really is. He wants to be presented as the All-Conditioner, as the emplacement on which even those who deny Him must stand."

Monday, December 17, 2007

Sproul Quote on Understanding Scripture

Here is a quote by the very quotable, R.C. Sproul, from his book on the interpretation of scripture, Knowing Scripture.


"Absurdities often sound profound because they are incapable of being understood. When we hear things we do not understand, sometimes we think they are simply too deep or weighty for us to grasp when in fact they are merely unintelligible statements like "one-hand clapping". the Bible does not talk like that. The Bible speaks of God in meaningful patterns of speech. Some of those patterns are more difficult than others, but they are not meant to be nonsense statements that only a guru can fathom."


Tuesday, December 11, 2007

Bob Dylan Quote & My Comments

Below is a quote from a Bob Dylan song.

"Yes, 'n' how many times must the cannon balls fly
before they're forever banned?
The answer, my friend, is blowin' in the wind,
the answer is blowin' in the wind."

Normally, Dylan rejected any attachment to a particular social movement: the hippy movement, the folk movement in music, etc. On many occasions he even claimed that there was no real deep message invested in the lyrics of his songs, and that most of his audience takes them too seriously. Even though that claim itself is considered by his fans to be satirical, it was obvious that he did not intend for his lyrics to be co opted as a rally cry by any organization or organised movement.

All that being said, I do want to comment on the underlined portion of the lyrics I quoted above. It certainly is a noble desire to have wars and conflicts end, in fact it is one that I share. Dylan released this song on the 1963 album titled, "The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan", this was a tumultuous time in American history: the civil rights movement, the death of the President in November, and about one year earlier, several nations (the US included) signed an agreement to insure the neutrality of Laos, and the conflict in Vietnam had been escalating since 1959, so it is clear to see how his environment ( a nation being polarized by a clash in cultures and the threat war) might have fueled such lyrics. Unfortunately, though the sentiment is valid, the argument disguised in the question, "...how many times must the cannon balls fly before they're forever banned?" is utterly unrealistic. This lyric makes me ponder the reality of original sin, and the falleness that typifies the world in which we live. Imagine a world where the government was united under one state head; lead by one body of legislators to create laws, and one body to carry them out worldwide. Imagine that this world government does ban the "cannonball", the problem is that, the very governing body which bans them must exempt themselves so as to be invested with the power to weld cannonballs themselves to prevent anyone else from doing so...I'm thankful that, even in this fallen world, by the common grace of God, He granted the fathers of our country the wisdom to decide that each citizen (with some necessary exclusions) has the right to bear "cannonballs". Unfortunately, the world in which Dylan made his plea is not the one in which his dream could come true, in fact, the banning of cannonballs would inevitably lead to the tyrannizing of the entire world under the government of fallen men which make fallen laws.

Fortunately for those redeemed by Christ, they will live in a future world, redeemed even of the cannonball. If the answer is truly "blowing in the wind", as Dylan suggests, then that Wind must be the Holy Spirit.

Friday, November 30, 2007

Providential Perspectives

Regardless of God's revelation to us, our perception of God is bound up in time; the fact that our senses and perceptions are limited by our temporal existence is perhaps a reminder that men's descriptions of God are always abstractions of the reality of God’s being—we can’t help it. In the same way, a photograph—however realistic—is still an abstraction of the reality which it attempts to represent.

Below is a quote from Mike Horton's "God of Promise

"While much of the debate over God's sovereignty and human freedom turns on endless speculation about philosophical possibilities, the covenantal structure of God's relationship to creaturely reality is a much safer and profitable resource. The covenant is always the site where the Great King and his servants are recognized for what they are: unequal partners with their own way of existing, knowing, willing, and acting--one as Creator, the other as creature."

We must all be very careful when we meditate on the knowledge of God and how He has that knowledge. I am aware that we have Scriptural precedence to delve these depths somewhat, by those precedence are also boundaries.