Romans 5:7-9

For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.
Showing posts with label Theology: Justification. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Theology: Justification. Show all posts

Friday, April 2, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Aquinas - 2

Theological Comparisons

Aquinas

It must first be pointed out that Thomas saw the need to conciliate God’s justice, which was quite different than the terms Anselm employed in his theory. “This is Aquinas' major difference with Anselm. Rather than seeing the debt as one of honor, he sees the debt as a moral injustice to be righted.”[i] Now regarding Thomas on the act of atonement itself, he first, with Anslem saw the necessity of Christ’s incarnation. “Now a mere man could not have satisfied for the whole human race, and God was not bound to satisfy; hence it was needful for Jesus Christ to be both God and man.”[ii] Secondly, that the death of Christ was perfectly satisfactory because of His infinite deity and was necessary due to the highly offensive nature of our sin. “…a sin committed against God has a kind of infinity from the infinity of the Divine majesty, because the greater the person we offend, the more grievous the offence. Hence for adequate satisfaction it was necessary that the act of the one satisfying should have an infinite efficacy, as being of God and man.”[iii] Thirdly, that Christ came into the world to blot out both original and actual sin. “It is certain that Christ came into this world not only to take away the sin which is handed on originally to posterity, but also in order to take away all sins subsequently added to it…”[iv]Fourth that in some way in Thomas’ mind, Christ’s merit is extended to the whole church. Thomas pointed out the objections to the merit of Christ extending to others by asserting that, just as Adam’s demerit is extended to the whole race physically, Christ’s merit is extended to the members of His body, the church, because He is its head. Thomas responded to those objections in these varied ways. “But Adam’s demerits reached to the condemnation of others. Much more, therefore does the merit of Christ reach others.”[v] And here is his logical progress from the representation of Adam to the representation of Christ, “As the sin of Adam reaches others only by carnal generation, so, too, the merit of Christ reaches others only by spiritual regeneration, which takes place in baptism; wherein we are incorporated with Christ…and it is by grace that it is granted to man to be regenerated in Christ. And thus man’s salvation is from grace.”[vi] Now it is clear from this last statement that Thomas’ understanding of the sacraments is in contrast to the Reformers, and that the division of the Calvinistic categories of the church into “visible” and invisible” are likewise not yet present. Even further, it is clear that Thomas differed from Anselm in yet another way.
Aquinas articulated the formal beginning of the idea of a superabundance of merit, which became the basis for the Catholic concept of the Treasury of Merit…Aquinas also articulated the ideas of salvation that are now standard within the Catholic church: that justifying grace is provided through the sacraments; that the condign merit of our actions is matched by Christ's merit from the Treasury of Merit; and that sins can be classified as mortal and venial. For Aquinas, one is saved by drawing on Christ's merit, which is provided through the sacraments of the church. Aquinas' view may sound like penal substitution, but he is careful to say that he does not intend substitution to be taken in legal terms[vii]
     Thus Thomas—I believe contrary to Gesner’s assertion, alluded to earlier—is now aligned with the current Roman Catholic understanding of the atonement, in all its parts and implications.


[i] New World Encyclopedia contributors. “Atonement (satisfaction view)”. New World Encyclopedia; 2008 Sep 4, 22:35 UTC [cited 17 Mar, 2010]. Online: http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Atonement_%28satisfaction_view%29?oldid=799847.
[ii] Thomas Aquinas, The Suma Theologica of Saint Thomas Aquinas: vol. II Daniel J. Sullivan, ed., (Chicago, London, Toronto: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc., 1952), 702.
[iii] Ibid. 704
[iv] Ibid. 706
[v] Ibid. 820
[vi] Ibid. 821
[vii] New World Encyclopedia contributors. “Atonement (satisfaction view)”. New World Encyclopedia; 2008 Sep 4, 22:35 UTC [cited 17 Mar, 2010]. Online: http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Atonement_%28satisfaction_view%29?oldid=799847.
 

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Aquinas - 1


Theological Comparisons
Aquinas
     So much could be said of the good Doctor Angelicus, Saint Thomas Aquinas; short life though he lived, his copious collection of theological musings warranted a more Methuselan period of time. On the particular doctrine of the atonement, Thomas has been quoted by Roman Catholic and protestant scholars both, as having held to their position. One such extreme instance of this is an article in Table Talk magazine where Dr. John Gerstner claimed that Saint Thomas held to justification by grace, through faith alone; while others remain more cautious because of the dichotomy he made between congruent and condign merit: congruent being that merit that one has outside of the gracious work of Christ and condign being that merit graciously provided by God, yet still a merit that Thomas finds in the act of the justification of a sinner. Make no mistake, Thomas firmly believed that God’s grace was absolutely necessary and any good deed would ultimately be attributed to its infusion. Thomas proved this in his own words,
Now everlasting life is a good exceeding the proportion of created nature; since it exceeds its knowledge and desire, according to 1 Cor. 2:9: ‘Eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither hath it entered into the heart of man.’ And hence it is that no created nature is a sufficient principle of an act meritorious of eternal life, unless there is added a supernatural gift, which we call grace.[i]
But therein lays the true issue. Thomas proved this in his own words as he attempted to answer this question, May a man, by God’s grace, condignly merit eternal life? To that effect, “If, however, we speak of a meritorious work, inasmuch as it proceeds from the grace of the Holy Ghost moving us to life everlasting, it is meritorious of life everlasting condignly. For thus the value of its merit depends upon the power of the Holy Ghost moving us to life everlasting according to John 4:14.”[ii]
The major difference in Thomas’ theory of atonement and that of Anselm’s is this idea of righteousness infused. To import our own categories into the discussion, the Reformers were careful to say that we are not made righteous at all (especially by the infusion of meritorious acts such as belief), but that we are instead declared righteous on account of Christ’s merit for us. This was in fact Anselm’s position; he claimed that Christ’s death—which was an act over and above what God demands of all His creatures, a life of perfect obedience—merited infinite righteousness which would be imparted, as an alien source, to the sinner God chose to benefit. Thomas’s opinion of the sinner made righteous before God, graciously being given the capacity to do that which God commanded, was what he referred to as the transmutation of the human soul. By virtue of the soul being caused to obey, the person becomes righteous before God, therefore God can (and is in fact obliged—insinuated by Thomas) really and actually call the person righteous because they indeed are righteous.


[i] Thomas Aquinas, “Suma Theologica,” Christian Classics Ethereal Library ST Ia.114.2. Cited 17 March 2010. Online: http://www.ccel.org/ccel/aquinas/summa.FS_Q114_A2.html
[ii] Thomas Aquinas, “Suma Theologica,” Christian Classics Ethereal Library ST Ia.114.3. Cited 17 March 2010. Online: http://www.ccel.org/ccel/aquinas/summa.FS_Q114_A3.html.

Friday, March 26, 2010

A Comparison of Christ's Atonement in the Medieval Scholastic Period - Theological Comparisons: Abelard - 2


Theological Comparisons

Abelard

His comment begins regarding Rom. 3:21 and Abelard was quick to separate the formal, covenantal Law from the natural transcendent law of God and he then went on to make a contrast between the age prior to Christ when that formal Law ruled, and his present age, ruled, as he said, by grace, the age in which Christ has been manifest through the teaching of the gospel. And when we read further we see that Abelard made an additional contrast between the Law (be it formal or natural, it is not clear from his comments here) and love for God. Whereas, I believe the more orthodox position is that love for God is the fulfillment of God’s formal Law, not only an aspect of God’s natural law. Here is that contrast, “A righteousness, I say, imparted to all the faithful in the higher part of their being—in the soul where alone love can exist—and not a matter of the display of outward works.”[i] And then there are those passages that seem to exonerate Abelard of a justification by anything other than faith and show a doctrine of atonement more like that of Anselm than of Niebuhr or Tillich. “‘In his blood.’ [citing Paul’s letter to the Romans] This means by his death; and since this propitiation is set forth and established by God, not for all but only for those who believe, he adds, ‘Through faith’[citing Paul’s letter to the Romans]; for this reconciliation affects them only who have believed it and hoped in it.”[ii] But then, as one might expect, there are the occasions of his leaning toward what we now call the “Moral Influence” theory,
By the faith which we hold concerning Christ love is increased in us by virtue of the conviction that God in Christ has united our human nature to himself and, by suffering in that same nature, has demonstrated to us that perfection of love…So we, through his grace are joined to him as closely as to our neighbor by an indissoluble bond of affection...[iii]
And this comment further on in Rom. 3:26, “In other words, to show forth his love to us, or convince us how much we ought to love him who ‘sparred not even his own son’ [citing Paul’s letter to the Romans] for us…That is to say that through this righteousness [the showing of God’s righteousness or justice as in v. 26]—which is love—we may gain remission of our sins”[iv]
The common view of Abelard in the last 100 years or so can be summed up in the words of Sam Storms, “In fairness to Abelard, it would be a mistake to conclude that he omitted all reference to the sacrifice of Christ as a payment for our sin. Yet, his emphasis is clearly on the subjective effects of that sacrifice rather than its objective relationship to the wrath of God.”[v] Abelard’s primary emphasis therefore being the equation of love and righteousness (being justified), I believe the Abelardian theory of the atonement is positively stated, by God’s grace we are made lovers of Him and those who love God are justified before Him. Or, in the final accounting we are justified by faith and our love for the Father; the Father gives us this capacity to love Him, by His grace, therefore we are saved by grace through our love of God. It must be noted that “love for God” in the sense that Abelard used in his commentary on Romans in particular, encompasses faith; so there is no justification without love for God, there is no love for God without faith.


[i] Ibid., 278

[ii]Ibid., 279
[iii] Ibid., 278
[iv] Ibid., 279

[v] Sam Storms, “11) Anselm” [cited 13 March, 2010]. Online: http://www.enjoyinggodministries.com/article/11-anselm/

Friday, March 19, 2010

New Series - Theories of Christ's Atonement

Today, after a long respite, I will begin a new series of posts that will be generated out of a paper I just completed. The topic is the doctrine of Christ's atonement and its formulation through the Medieval Scholastic Period (1000-1500). This series will deal with three theologian/philosophers from that period: Anselm the Bishop of Canterbury, Peter Abelard, and Saint Thomas Aquinas.

Friday, July 17, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 12

     In light of my current study on progressive sanctification I'd like to draw this particular series of articles to a close, appropriately so I think, by addressing the idea of the assurance of pardon. Lest you think that I believe I've exhausted any study of the topic, I reserve the right to contemplate what the Bible says about sanctification and assurance in some later series with a slightly different focus.
     Assurance is a tricky thing, especially when a local church takes the Law and the depravity of man very seriously. Many such churches also don't, in my opinion, take the administration of the Lord's Supper seriously enough, so coupled together the "smoldering wick and bruised reed" may be harshly treated.  Some churches don't see The Lord's Supper as a means God has ordained to distribute sanctifying grace by showing us once again the drama of election, effectual calling, regeneration, faith, justification, adoption, sanctification, preservation and glorification, played out before our eyes as it is framed in the New Covenant Passover  meal where the Lamb's life of righteousness and passion on the behalf of all who believe is displayed. If that church also finds it difficult to see Christ in all of Scripture, and doesn't see the practicality of the benediction—reminding its people at or near the end of the service that God has forgiven all the sins of all those who believe and His wrath is never upon them—then the believer doesn't go away assured, in fact their faith may even be desperately challenged that whole week because they know the can't live up to God's Law, they heard that on Sunday. What they didn't hear was that Christ lived up to it for them.
      I suppose this is the place to mention that balance and serious inquiry into the pertinent biblical texts is required when approaching this topic because there are passages that indicate, as the WCF puts it, that God's "Fatherly displeasure" will be on His children who disobey. Not that His wrath is directed towards them, because Christ swallowed the entire contents of that cup on the cross, but like an earthly father He is not forced to disown His children when He chooses, for their own good mind you, to discipline them. So to wrap up my thoughts on the topic for now I'd say this. The warnings found in the New Testament in particular are very real, and so is the accomplishment of Christ's blood. I've formulated a syllogism to illustrate: Believers do persevere to the end by faith, through the struggle against their sin. Unbelievers face eternal separation from God in Hell. If, by faith, you do not struggle against your sin to the end, you face eternal separation from God in Hell.
     Having said that though, go you child of God and hear this, "The Lord bless you and keep you; the Lord make His face shine upon you and be gracious to you; the Lord lift up His countenance upon you and give you peace." (Num. 6:24-26)

Friday, July 10, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 11

     Below I comment on the final Forde quote:
"If we are turned around to get back down to earth by grace, then it would seem that true sanctification would show itself in taking care of our neighbor and God’s creation, not exploiting and destroying either for our own ends, religious or otherwise. It would mean concern for the neighbor and society, caring for the other for the time being. Here one should talk about the place of morality and virtue and such things. Although we do not accept them as the means by which we are sanctified, they are the means by which and through which we care for the world and for the other. This is what the Reformers meant when they insisted that good works were to be done, but one was not to depend on them for salvation."
     Here Forde rightly categorizes virtue and morality to such things as “concern for the neighbor and society” and “taking care of our neighbor and God’s creation”. The prescription to do these things is explicitly Law and neither Forde nor Reformed theology suggests we lean on our doing of them as the merit or assurance of our pardon.  Only the repetition of the gospel can give us assurance in the midst of our struggle against sin, and only the repetition of the gospel can cause the type of life change that acts on such commands as to love one’s neighbor as oneself and to love God above all else.
     In conclusion I’d like to reiterate Forde’s thesis that, “Sanctification, if it is to be spoken as something other than justification is perhaps best defined as the art of getting used to the unconditional justification wrought by the grace of God for Jesus’ sake.” Perhaps it is stated in typical Lutheran hyperbole, but in this thesis Forde indicates that a distinction should not be made between justification and sanctification, except to say that sanctification is the “art of getting used to” being justified by grace alone. Reformed theology certainly disagrees with the idea that the two shouldn’t be distinguished. Justification is historically spoken of as the momentary event when God declares one righteous before His holiness on account of Christ’s merit. And sanctification, though it has its moment of eventfulness (John 17:19; Acts 20:32, 26:18; 1 Cor. 1:2, 6:11; 2 Tim. 2:21; Heb. 2:11, 10:10; Jude 1:1), has been referred to additionally (and in distinction to justification) as a process toward glory—and as support, scriptures that say we are “being conformed to the image of Christ” (Rom. 12:1-3), and “being made” like the Son of God (Phil. 3:8-11), or “being made perfect or holy” (Gal. 3:3; Heb. 10:14). Forde agrees with the Reformed position in that whatever progress in sanctification, whatever obedience is rendered in the believer’s life is due to the pouring out of the unconditional grace of God. So it is right not only to express justification as being by grace alone through faith in Christ alone but also to speak of sanctification as being by grace alone through faith in Christ alone.
     Also, whatever spontaneous care-taking we see in our lives, or humility we express regarding our sanctification is still a measurement against the Law and should not be used as an agent of assurance. Only that historical fact of Christ’s life for our life and death for our death can assure us of our adoption and give us hope of a future freedom from even the desire to sin. Though our good works, to which believers were in fact predestined, are evidence to others of some difference about us, and though they may serve to a certain degree as a confirmation of faith along with continued repentance and belief, even they are tainted and marred by Adam’s indelible mark. As it was once penned in a Puritan prayer…”I need to repent of my repentance, I need my tears to be washed”. I believe we would do well to be reminded of the depth of our sin so the gospel of Christ grows increasingly sweeter thus we are assured because of its certainty.

Thursday, July 9, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 10

     Below I continue my comments on the Forde quotes.
"The second aspect of the transition of the Christian from old to death to life, is that all our ordinary views of progress and growth are turned upside down. It is not that we are somehow moving toward the goal, but rather that the goal is moving closer and closer to us. This corresponds to the eschatological nature of the New Testament message. It is the coming of the kingdom upon us, not our coming closer to or building up the kingdom. That is why it is a growth in grace, not a growth in our own virtue or morality. The progress, if one can call it that, is that we are being shaped more and more by the totality of the grace coming to us. The progress is due to the steady invasion of the new. That means that we are being taken more and more off our own hands, more and more away from self, and getting used to the idea of being saved by the grace of God alone. Our sanctification consists merely in being shaped by, or getting used to, justification."
     In my opinion there is very little if any to disagree with in the above statement, assuming the way Forde frames the progress of sanctification, as the Kingdom coming ever closer to the justified man, means that it carries the broad idea of our going from justification to glorification through sanctification. He mentions at the first, the progress from the old man—the death of the old man—to new man, so there is a progression of sorts. But the matter that needs to be worked out is whether the new man is capable of sin or if he, by virtue of his new position in Christ, is not, and perhaps it is only the old man warring against him. If by having our ideas of progress and growth turned upside down, Forde does NOT mean the new man does NOT sin then I agree with his description. The concept of “compatibilism” also comes to mind, thus I’ve included these posts in that category on the blog. On monergism.com, B.B. Warfield is quoted as defining the term this way, “Compatibilism (also known as soft determinism), is the belief that God’s predetermination and meticulous providence is “compatible” with voluntary choice.” The term is generally thought of in regards to regeneration but it really covers the entire realm of human choice, which also includes our choices as believers, to obey and experience that moment of sanctification or disobey and not. Our choices to obey God’s Law and leading are mysteriously and sometimes strangely compatible with the foreordination of God that we either do or do not conform to that Law. We make real choices according to our present and most aggressive affection or desire—in fact we must operate that way, for the only factors constraining our “creaturely” free choices are our affections or desires and God’s perfect knowledge of our future choices. It is here I would like to draw the distinction between the indicative or positional and experiential natures of the believer’s sanctification. On the one hand the New Testament says that we are or already have been sanctified or set apart (John 17:19; Acts 20:32, 26:18; 1 Cor. 1:2, 6:11; 2 Tim. 2:21; Heb. 2:11, 10:10; Jude 1:1). When we were regenerated we were set apart to God. On the other hand, sanctification seems to be the progress through the interim period between justification and glorification, as the New Testament says, but not in as many places, we are being sanctified (1 Thess. 4:3; Heb. 10:14). So it is imperative that we obey God’s Law and be sanctified. At the risk of sounding politically incorrect, consider the following event as an analogy because most of us can relate to the emotion of it. During a bank robbery a woman is held hostage and the thief calls for the male security guard cowering in the corner to go to the safe, but in his angst he can’t move. Finally one of the other customers calls out to him and says, “…be a man!” The fact that the guard was petrified in the corner did not change his gender, during the entire episode he was a man. His gender hadn’t suddenly changed as his fear overtook him. But the other customer was encouraging him to fulfill in action, the position he already occupied.
     Reformed theology would agree that the progress of sanctification is not the growth of our own virtue, but what does “being shaped more and more by the totality of the grace coming to us” mean except that our actions change? To be sure, the shaping would include at the very least an increase of repentance and belief over the entire period of “sanctification” in a believer’s life, but I am coming to the conclusion that it can’t be that alone. Even in Forde’s description of what being shaped by grace means he puts up life change as a sign of the growth; change which can only really be measured against the Law of God unless one sets up another tablet of prescribed actions in its place. But we would agree that any change made in that direction is not of our own conjuring but of the Kingdom coming upon us in the person of the Holy Spirit, and I would add, by whom we have been sanctified, and by whom we are being sanctified, or growing by grace, into our new position. Like someone who has been hired as a product developer who has never performed in that capacity before, even though he is called the Vice President of Product Development he must grow into the position as his actions change to reflect his title.
     Quotes and comments to be continued...

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 9

     Below is the continued discussion of Forde's article on the Lutheran view of sanctification.

"So it is impossible to put God's unconditional act of justifying sinners for Jesus' sake alone together with our ideas of progress based on conditions. It doesn't work either logically or in the life of faith."
     At least in the reformed camp, sanctification is not a work of man for God, but a work of God for man. Not even the regenerate man who in Christ is, before his glorification, made posse peccatore—who has the possibility to not sin in a given moment—can render to God without grace, the good works for which he has been foreordained. So perhaps it is against another non Reformed theory of sanctification that Forde is arguing, because Reformed theology agrees, “progress [in sanctification] based on conditions” is as improbable as God’s very plan for one’s life coming about by conditions. I believe the correct way to look at the relationship between the transpiring of God’s plan for our lives and our willingness to be guided into that plan by His wisdom is the same as the relationship between prayer and God’s actions, and the relationship between our obedience and the progress of our sanctification. Our “willingness”, prayers, and obedience are means to the ends ordained by God: His plans and our salvation, and He has ordained the means as well.
"So it is always as a totality that unconditional grace attacks sin. That is why total sanctification and justification are in essence the same thing."
     This is where, I guess, my confessionalism shines and my love for historical theology and the weight I think they both should carry for subsequent believers is manifest. I don’t think that there is in any way that we can say that justification and sanctification are “essentially the same thing”. The Protestant Reformers were very careful to distinguish the two: justification as an event in time where the believer is declared righteous before God on the grounds of Christ’s work, and through faith—which is also the gift of God—and sanctification being the process or series of events between justification and glorification. The purpose of Martin Luther pointing this out in the 16th century was to challenge the Roman Catholic high-sacramentalism and the working out of the doctrine of salvation (specifically justification) to reform from a process wherein the covenant child was baptized, having original sin washed away producing the state of tabula rasa (blank slate), maintaining that state revived in continued cleansing of venial sins through the sacrament of the Eucharist, and finally the believer paying for his remaining sins in Purgatory, to an event which the description thereof was encapsulated in the five “solas”. So for a Lutheran to imply through a confusing statement that justification is perhaps a process is unfortunate. Certainly Forde would consider himself Protestant, even at his description of the differences of justification and sanctification, but denying any difference between justification and sanctification at their essence seems to me to be unhelpful. Even if his motive is altruistic, assuming it is to protect individuals from measuring their progress in grace up against to Law, or using the Law to try to find assurance of their justification by emphasizing the fact that we have been set apart and made holy, acquiring all the righteousness we need to stand before God our Father. But to jettison the idea of any actual warning to the Christian to make sure your calling and election is sure, and to render the New Testament imperatives impotent is not going to protect individuals from legalism, nor does it do justice to the text. Pastor Reggie Kimbro has said that when one finds himself to be a legalist he doesn’t need to remedy the situation by becoming  a little more antinomian, likewise when one finds himself a bit too antinomian the prescription is not to become a little bit more legalistic to balance one’s self. So what is the answer, how do we protect ourselves from falling off the right side of the horse into the error of legalism or falling off the left side into the error of antinomianism? That will be a question to be answered toward the end of the discussion.
     Quotes and comments to be continued...

Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 8

     Below are my continued comments on Forde's words:

"Conditional thinking is wedded to the schemes of law and progress characteristics of this age. Sin is understood primarily as misdeed or transgression of such a scheme...The logic would then be that with the help of grace one progressively gains more and more righteousness and thus sins less and less. One strives toward perfection until, theoretically, one would need less and less grace or perhaps finally no more grace at all."
"Whose fault is it if the scheme doesn't work?...Either I have not properly responded to or cooperated with the free divine grace, or most frightening of all, the God of election who presides over such grace has decided, in my case, not to give it."
     Again we hear in the above statements the visceral groaning of pastoral concern…to which I most certainly can relate. However, the total relegation of one’s progress in sanctification or growth in Christ to the “scheme of law and progress characteristic only of this age” is far too simple a distinction. Protestants of all shapes and sizes are jealous to separate Law & Gospel in some degree. The idea behind the Reformed view of sanctification through the mortification of sin is not one of conditionality: if I mortify sin, then God gives me more righteousness, but one of imputation as with justification: Christ lived in perfect obedience to the Law, meriting my righteous standing before God and died to pay the debt I merit with sins I commit even after I’ve been justified. So I am at war within myself to do real good, good that is a result of a holy standing before a holy God, not to retroactively merit what God has already done for me in justification but because God has predestined those whom He has justified, to actually do good works.
     The term “conditional thinking” can be defined contextually as the idea that, if believers obey God’s Law, then they will be sanctified, thus considered holy. Forde goes on to define sin according to those who promote such a scheme, as the transgression of that if/then system. In my own mind, I agree that if one is lead to believe that they are left to perform in this scenario without the gracious provision of God, then he has been misled. But, like God’s use of means in the regeneration of individuals (Rom. 10) and the means of atonement
     Assuming the correctness of the particular view of sanctification which Forde is fighting (which I don’t believe Reformed theology does), that the regenerated person “gains more and more righteousness” thus striving toward a theoretical perfection, I believe Forde is right to surmises that that individual might need less and less grace because of his performance. But this exposes Forde’s presupposition, at least at this point, that free divine grace isn’t the driving factor of the mortification of sin and calls to mind Paul’s words in Romans 6 that we should not sin more and more so that grace may abound more and more, God forbid. The fact is that grace abounds really in the life of a believer whether (in the eyes of man or his own eyes) he is conformed or lacked to be conformed to the Law of God. Grace abounds over a sinner saved by it regardless of the degree of fruit he produces. The most outwardly and inwardly obedient child of God has no more righteousness before Him that the technically worst sinner among the Kingdom. If he is a true convert of Christ, fruit will be produced by the same grace it took to regenerate him, yet the same grace shades him from the wrath of God when he commits sin and the righteousness of Christ that was once imputed to him neither waxes nor wanes but, like light in the universe, is constant—never changing but ever presenting us as sons and daughters, spotless as Christ. Furthermore, certain that Forde would agree that we are not made more and more righteous before God even if we do sin less and less by being more and more conformed to the image of Christ. Our righteousness is really gained at our justification (1 Cor. 6:11), otherwise how could God call us just, and what more righteousness needs to be involved except that of Christ’s which He merited for us in His life? Not withstanding, when we do sin it really does grieve the Spirit in us, thus the picture of war in our members, but there is no war in the unbeliever, just submission and slavery to sin.
     Quotes and comments will continue...

Monday, July 6, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 7

Below I continue to post quotes and comments on Forde's article.
"Talk about sanctification can be dangerous in that it misleads and seduces the old being into thinking it is still in control. We may grudgingly admit we cannot justify ourselves, but then we attempt to make up for that by getting serious about sanctification."
Forde’s essential conclusion here is that talk about sanctification as progressive in nature can be “dangerous” and I can sympathize with this concern when such talk of our theology of sanctification either leads to a practical application that doesn’t include God’s gracious gift of that progress, or if it stems from a theology that denies the same type of graciousness from God which is subsequent to the grace of justification. The Westminster Divines, among others, concluded that the justified life necessarily involves some degree of the mortification of sin. Dying to the desires of the flesh, recognizing and repenting of (seeing it in light of God’s holiness) personal sin, confessing it and believing that Christ died with it on His shoulders, and having it once for all cast away is the sanctified life. But it is this matter of progression that is somewhat nebulous, even in the definition given in ages past. So I must admit that many a bruised reed and smoldering wick has been broken and snuffed out by well-meaning pastors (those intending to fight heartily against “Easy-believism” as they have taught on the progressive nature of sanctification. At times I’ve wondered if the gospel was simple left behind as though it was simply the boarding pass to get on the jet of sanctification. And in that way I sympathize with Forde’s (and what I think is peculiarly the present Lutheran concern for souls who have been prepared for legalism in the midst of the practical application of the doctrine of progressive sanctification. However, I must part ways when it is suggested that simply because the doctrine has been abused, it must therefore be erroneous. Consider Luther himself as he answered the Roman Catholic objection to sola fide, that if it were true, then a flood-gate of iniquity will be opened. To that protestation he said, “…so be it.”
Quotes and comments to be continued...

Friday, July 3, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 6


     Below are some comments on Forde’s words:
"It [sanctification] is what happens when we are grasped by the fact that God alone justifies."
"It is what happens when the old being comes up against the end of its self-justifying and self-gratifying, however pious. It is life lived in anticipation of the resurrection."
     Certainly no protestant would disagree that a very large portion of what it means to be sanctified is, being “grasped by the fact that God alone justifies”, and living life in light of the resurrection. It is the realization of this fact (essentially belief in the gospel) that sets us and our belief apart from the world in the first place—the mental ascent to the dire need for salvation and finding it only through Christ’s life, death, and resurrection is part of what it means to have been justified by God but, and perhaps this is the main issue Forde is attempting to counteract in his argument, after being justified by grace through faith we are not then left to be sanctified by any other means.  It is by the same grace and through the same faith that we are sanctified until the end of our lives; until that time when we “see Him as He is” and are glorified and rid of all possibility of sin.
"Now, living morally is indeed an important, wise and good thing. There is no need to knock it. But it should not be equated with sanctification, being made holy. The moral life is the business of the old being in this world. The Reformers called it "civil righteousness." Sanctification is the result of the dying of the old and the rising of the new. The moral life is the result of the old being's struggle to climb to the heights of the law. Sanctification has to do with the decent of the new being into humanity, becoming a neighbor, freely, spontaneously, giving of the self in self-forgetful and uncalculating ways."
     My only real objection here, and it turns out to be a major one, is that I must, because I believe the Scriptures to do so as well, include “becoming a neighbor, freely, spontaneously, giving of the self in self-forgetful and uncalculating ways" as part of living the moral life. Jesus says that the greatest commandment or the summation of the Law is to love God with all your soul and mind to and love your neighbor as yourself (Matt. 22:34-40). So I must ask Forde how “becoming a neighbor” is not part of the moral life—“the old being’s struggle to climb”.
     Quotes and comments to be continued...

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 5


     After reading Forde's treatment of sanctification I can see several main conclusions he has drawn.  The thesis statement of his article is this, "Sanctification is simply the art of getting used to justification." Below are some other quotes I've taken to show Forde's conclusions.
"It [sanctification] is what happens when we are grasped by the fact that God alone justifies."
"It is what happens when the old being comes up against the end of its self-justifying and self-gratifying, however pious. It is life lived in anticipation of the resurrection."
"Now, living morally is indeed an important, wise and good thing. There is no need to knock it. But it should not be equated with sanctification, being made holy. The moral life is the business of the old being in this world. The Reformers called it "civil righteousness." Sanctification is the result of the dying of the old and the rising of the new. The moral life is the result of the old being's struggle to climb to the heights of the law. Sanctification has to do with the decent of the new being into humanity, becoming a neighbor, freely, spontaneously, giving of the self in self-forgetful and uncalculating ways."
"Talk about sanctification can be dangerous in that it misleads and seduces the old being into thinking it is still in control. We may grudgingly admit we cannot justify ourselves, but then we attempt to make up for that by getting serious about sanctification."
"Conditional thinking is wedded to the schemes of law and progress characteristics of this age. Sin is understood primarily as misdeed or transgression of such a scheme...The logic would then be that with the help of grace one progressively gains more and more righteousness and thus sins less and less. One strives toward perfection until, theoretically, one would need less and less grace or perhaps finally no more grace at all."
"Whose fault is it if the scheme doesn't work?...Either I have not properly responded to or cooperated with the free divine grace, or most frightening of all, the God of election who presides over such grace has decided, in my case, not to give it."
"So it is impossible to put God's unconditional act of justifying sinners for Jesus' sake alone together with our ideas of progress based on conditions. It doesn't work either logically or in the life of faith."
"So it is always as a totality that unconditional grace attacks sin. That is why total sanctification and justification are in essence the same thing."
"The second aspect of the transition of the Christian from old to death to life, is that all our ordinary views of progress and growth are turned upside down. It is not that we are somehow moving toward the goal, but rather that the goal is moving closer and closer to us. This corresponds to the eschatological nature of the New Testament message. It is the coming of the kingdom upon us, not our coming closer to or building up the kingdom. That is why it is a growth in grace, not a growth in our own virtue or morality. The progress, if one can call it that, is that we are being shaped more and more by the totality of the grace coming to us. The progress is due to the steady invasion of the new. That means that we are being taken more and more off our own hands, more and more away from self, and getting used to the idea of being saved by the grace of God alone. Our sanctification consists merely in being shaped by, or getting used to, justification."
"Sanctification under the invasion of the new, however, holds out the possibility of actually coming to hate sin, and to love God and his creation, or at least to make that little beginning. It is not that sin is taken away from us, but rather that we are to be taken away from sin heart, soul and mind, as Luther put it. In that manner, the law of God is to be fulfilled in us precisely by the uncompromising totality and unconditionality of the grace given."
"If we are turned around to get back down to earth by grace, then it would seem that true sanctification would show itself in taking care of our neighbor and God’s creation, not exploiting and destroying either for our own ends, religious or otherwise. It would mean concern for the neighbor and society, caring for the other for the time being. Here one should talk about the place of morality and virtue and such things. Although we do not accept them as the means by which we are sanctified, they are the means by which and through which we care for the world and for the other. This is what the Reformers meant when they insisted that good works were to be done, but one was not to depend on them for salvation."
   In my next post I intend to comment on some if not all of these quotes.

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 4

   Below is a quote from former (he has since died and gone to be with the Lord) professor of theology at Lutheran Seminary, Gerhard Forde. I've posted this as I continue to search out the biblical view of progressive sanctification. The entire article can be found here.
"SANCTIFICATION, IF IT IS TO BE SPOKEN OF AS SOMETHING other than justification is perhaps best defined as the art of getting used to the unconditional justification wrought by the grace of God for Jesus’ sake. It is what happens when we are grasped by the fact that God alone justifies. It is being made holy, and as such, it is not our work. It is the work of the Spirit who is called Holy. The fact that it is not our work puts the old Adam/Eve (our old self) to death and calls forth a new being in Christ. It is being saved from the sickness unto death and being called to new life...It is not something added to justification. It is not the final defense against a justification too liberally granted. It is the justified life. It is what happens when the old being comes up against the end of its self-justifying and self-gratifying ways, however pious. It is life lived in anticipation of the resurrection."

Friday, June 12, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 3


     After studying the doctrine of sanctification as represented in the three confessions I consulted: The Westminster Confession of Faith (WCF), the Belgic Confession (BCF), and the 1689 Baptist Confession of Faith (LBC), I have drawn the following conclusion about their contents.
     Christ’s death and resurrection are the power behind sanctification (WCF).  Believers are sanctified by the virtue of His work, (LBC) and sin’s dominion is destroyed (WCF) as the regenerate have been freed from the slavery of sin (BCF).  Even our lust after sin is mortified (WCF).  At our regeneration we are made new creatures capable of living the “new life”. (BCF)  Sanctification is a manifestation of “true faith” that comes by the hearing of God’s Word (BCF) and true believers are progressively strengthened in all saving graces for to practice holiness (WCF).  This holiness is perfected in the fear of God as we seek a heavenly life through evangelical obedience to all God’s commands (LBC).  Believers are warmed to pious and holy living out off a love for God (BCF).  Only the holy see God, (WCF) but the truly regenerate necessarily bare fruit (do what God has commanded) (BCF).  Good works done by believers are acceptable to God because those works are sanctified by His grace (BCF), and it is God who works those good works in us (BCF).  Always keeping in mind that salvation is not based on our good works, and our assurance of regeneration does not come from those works (BCF).  Nevertheless, even though our good works do not merit God’s favor, He does reward them with crowns (BCF).  Finally, sanctification is imperfect and the believer does struggle against temptation and sin, (WCF) but overcoming sin, growing in grace, and the fear of God are characteristics of believers (WCF).  Certainty in our justification should rest on the merit of Christ our Savior (BCF).
     In later posts in this series I plan to quote recent (and by recent I mean in the last 200 or so years) authors regarding the topic of sanctification, and contrast these statements above with opposing views.

Tuesday, June 9, 2009

Progressive Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon - 2

     I think it is important to consider what has historically been believed regarding almost any doctrine, especially when there are a variety of positions held within the loosely bound category of Evangelicalism.  I realize that some of you don't have the same regard for historical theology as the Reformed tradition does.  So to ease your possible concern, note that we do not believe that writings other than those inscripturated have actual authority over the Christian's doctrine and practice—the Scripture alone has that authority.  Having said that, we do hold those theological writings that have been preserved for us by the providence of God in high regard.  Here is what the Westminster Confession says about sanctification.
     "CHAP. XIII. - Of Sanctification.
1. They, who are once effectually called, and regenerated, having a new heart, and a new spirit created in them, are further sanctified, really and personally, through the virtue of Christ's death and resurrection, by His Word and Spirit dwelling in them, the dominion of the whole body of sin is destroyed, and the several lusts thereof are more and more weakened and mortified; and they more and more quickened and strengthened in all saving graces, to the practice of true holiness, without which no man shall see the Lord.
2. This sanctification is throughout, in the whole man; yet imperfect in this life, there abiding still some remnants of corruption in every part; whence ariseth a continual and irreconcilable war, the flesh lusting against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh.
3. In which war, although the remaining corruption, for a time, may much prevail; yet, through the continual supply of strength from the sanctifying Spirit of Christ, the regenerate part doth overcome; and so, the saints grow in grace, perfecting holiness in the fear of God"
     And here is the doctrine of sanctification as defined in the Belgic Confession.
"Article 24: The Sanctification of Sinners
We believe that this true faith, produced in man by the hearing of God's Word and by the work of the Holy Spirit, regenerates him and makes him a "new man,"57 causing him to live the "new life"58 and freeing him from the slavery of sin.
Therefore, far from making people cold toward living in a pious and holy way, this justifying faith, quite to the contrary, so works within them that apart from it they will never do a thing out of love for God but only out of love for themselves and fear of being condemned.
So then, it is impossible for this holy faith to be unfruitful in a human being, seeing that we do not speak of an empty faith but of what Scripture calls "faith working through love,"59 which leads a man to do by himself the works that God has commanded in his Word.
These works, proceeding from the good root of faith, are good and acceptable to God, since they are all sanctified by his grace. Yet they do not count toward our justification-- for by faith in Christ we are justified, even before we do good works. Otherwise they could not be good, any more than the fruit of a tree could be good if the tree is not good in the first place.
So then, we do good works, but nor for merit-- for what would we merit? Rather, we are indebted to God for the good works we do, and not he to us, since it is he who "works in us both to will and do according to his good pleasure" 60-- thus keeping in mind what is written: "When you have done all that is commanded you, then you shall say, 'We are unworthy servants; we have done what it was our duty to do.' "61
Yet we do not wish to deny that God rewards good works-- but it is by his grace that he crowns his gifts.
Moreover, although we do good works we do not base our salvation on them; for we cannot do any work that is not defiled by our flesh and also worthy of punishment. And even if we could point to one, memory of a single sin is enough for God to reject that work.
So we would always be in doubt, tossed back and forth without any certainty, and our poor consciences would be tormented constantly if they did not rest on the merit of the suffering and death of our Savior.
     And lastly, the docrrine of sanctification according to the 1689 London Baptist Confession.
"Chapter 13: Of Sanctification
1. They who are united to Christ, effectually called, and regenerated, having a new heart and a new spirit created in them through the virtue of Christ's death and resurrection, are also farther sanctified, really and personally, through the same virtue, by His Word and Spirit dwelling in them; the dominion of the whole body of sin is destroyed, and the several lusts thereof are more and more weakened and mortified, and they more and more quickened and strengthened in all saving graces, to the practice of all true holiness, without which no man shall see the Lord.
( Acts 20:32; Romans 6:5, 6; John 17:17; Ephesians 3:16-19; 1 Thessalonians 5:21-23; Romans 6:14; Galatians 5:24; Colossians 1:11; 2 Corinthians 7:1; Hebrews 12:14 )
2. This sanctification is throughout the whole man, yet imperfect in this life; there abideth still some remnants of corruption in every part, whence ariseth a continual and irreconcilable war; the flesh lusting against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh.
( 1 Thessalonians 5:23; Romans 7:18, 23; Galatians 5:17; 1 Peter 2:11 )

3. In which war, although the remaining corruption for a time may much prevail, yet through the continual supply of strength from the sanctifying Spirit of Christ, the regenerate part doth overcome; and so the saints grow in grace, perfecting holiness in the fear of God, pressing after an heavenly life, in evangelical obedience to all the commands which Christ as Head and King, in His Word hath prescribed them.
( Romans 7:23; Romans 6:14; Ephesians 4:15, 16; 2 Corinthians 3:18; 2 Corinthians 7:1 )"
     In the next post regarding this topic I will attempt to provide a comparison and analysis of these views on sanctification, not to insinuate that they are different, but in doing so I also intend to boil it down to a composite statement and bring in other popular views that oppose the Reformed conclusion.

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

"Progressive" Sanctification & the Assurance of Pardon

     In recent months I've been more intentional in my consideration of the topic at hand.  Just what is the nature of sanctification and what doctrine assures us of our salvation from God's wrath?
     At one point in my race with Christ, I believed that there was no real pressure for the child of God to pursue holiness or good works; they were just supplemental actions not linked to our justification in any way.  After some time in the faith, and some small measure of study and discipleship, I came to understand the intended  (and undeniable) connection between justification and sanctification, the old adage, "you are saved through faith alone, but not by a faith that is alone (Jam. 2).  But that doctrinal truth was rarely tempered with the gospel; I mean, we were certain about being regenerated by grace through faith alone(Eph. 2), but the relationship between grace and sanctification didn't seem so clear—at least not in praxis.  It seemed as though the "progressive" nature which I then believed was part of the process, was emphasized far more often than the gracious power of the Spirit needed in order to mortify my sin.  As a result of adopting the "Lordship" position, I began to tie my assurance of pardon to my performance or progress in the mortification process.  This, as I see now, is deadly, especially when coupled with a high view of ecclesiastical discipline and a low view of the Lord's Supper.  The next shift in my theology concerned my view of the Lord's Supper.  Over time I no longer saw it as a simple memorial of what Christ did in time—a periodic reminder needed because it might have been the only time during the month that we heard so loudly and clearly about Christ's work for us, and before which we were charged to confess any known sin so as to make ourselves suitable for the participation in the ordinance—I soon came to see the sacrament as a means to an end:  the end was the outpouring of God's gracious benefits, so I no longer saw the practice only as a reminder of Christ's death, one such practice my heart was never really prepared to take, but instead, as another means for God to be good to me on account of His Son; a visual, tactile proclamation of the gospel for weak sinners whose whole persons (bodies and all) are being saved.
     When that theological shift was well under way, I began to question the "progressive" nature of sanctification.  Maintaining my view of church discipline, and beginning to see the great necessity of protecting the Table from unbelievers, and protecting unbelievers from hypocrisy, I started to tie my assurance of pardon more to Christ's merit rather than the progress of my sanctification; I had begun to see the actual/biblical separation of Law and Gospel; I had been convinced that it was not my obedience to the imperatives of scripture that should make me sure of my justification, but rather my belief, against all hope, in the gospel laden indicatives of scripture: that I have been made a son of God, a child of the Kingdom, a new creation.  But therein lies the true struggle of this journey, if I am set apart to Christ, and I am a new creature, and I have been declared just in God's eyes, and it is in those declarations that I find my assurance of guiltlessness, then is my mortification of personal sin necessarily progressive, and what is really meant by that term?  It is this question over which I intend to muse in the next several posts.

Saturday, October 25, 2008

The Place of Personal Testimony in Evangelism

I do believe that there is a place for testimony. But, evidenced by the continuing errors we make, contemporary American Evangelicalism is post-modern in that (however unintentional) we often replace the objective truths of the gospel, necessary to believe and be saved, with the utter subjectivity of personal testimony. I do believe that personal testimony has its place in the edification of believers, but because of the subjectivity of having ones quality of life improved, or being given the power to obey God's Law to a greater degree, those things really should have a minimal place in an evangelistic situation. The personal testimony that is useful in those cases is if we can point to a time when we once did not believe and repent, and contrast that with the times when we do, thus testifying to the power of God by highlighting His ability to recreate persons who see their sin in contrast to His holiness and believe the gospel. I think a lot of the times we want to substitute transformation for salvation, and this is symptomatic of our mistake of confusing sanctification with justification; confusing Law and Gospel. What eternal good is it if an unregenerate person is inspired in some way by the testimony of my personal transformation, to "change his life" by going to rehab so he can replace bad habits with good ones if he has not first had his heart changed from a heart of stone into a heart of flesh? I'm certain that most Christians would say that it is of no good, and that is the point I'm trying to make--the business of the Kingdom is that of calling persons to see their sinfulness in light of the holiness of God (as reflected in His Law) and to repent of those sins and believe that Christ, in history, lived the perfect life and died the perfect death on a Roman cross, and was raised to glorious life in the place of lowly sinners. Personal transformation (sanctification) will be a result of that continued repentance and belief.

Monday, June 11, 2007

By Faith through Grace?

The five “solas” of the Protestant Reformation were: sola scriptura, sola fide, sola gratia, sola Christo, and soli Deo Gloria.

The regular articulation of the resultant soteriology was that we are saved “by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone”. Founders pastor Douglas Shivers had this to say about the doctrine of justification and the Southern Baptist's confusion of it and how to make it clear,

“When preachers cannot distinguish and articulate these truths, and then cannot find help to do so in a sound confession, the task is made much more difficult. Recovery of salvation by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone ought to be our priority.”

Christians by necessity are confessional, therefore our creeds ought to be as clear statements of our beliefs as possible. Sadly, what we find in a quick overview of at least American Christianity is that the vast majority of persons calling themselves Christians cannot articulate the doctrine of justification and its immediate theological context. What’s more is that many of them don’t even think that is important! Just check out some of the polls conducted by Shane Rosenthal at “The White Horse Inn”.

One symptom of this nonsense is contained in Rick Warren’s latest offering where he says that (paraphrase) we need to participate in a second reformation; the first was about reforming creeds, but this present one is about the reformation of deeds. This sloppy handling of the distinction between law and gospel is born out of a mishandling of the doctrine of justification. In a theological environment influenced by the likes of Zane Hodges and his model of sanctification, it should surprise no one that Warren and others stomp out the mantra about deeds. The problem isn’t that we have truck loads of Christians who have all their theology straight and simply need to reform their deeds (and we all certainly should do that every day) but what we do have is truck loads of persons who are only professing to be Christians who actually need to repent and believe before they make any attempt at behavioral reformation.

The denial of creeds and the adoption of behavioral reform outside of Christian discipleship are for some, the symptoms of a semi-Pelagian view of regeneration and for others, they are the disease that causes them to embrace a semi-Pelagian view of regeneration. But as far as the Reformation is concerned, both the grace of regeneration and the faith by which it is received are contained in the gospel, but today instead of hearing the biblical statement from Eph. 2:8-9 "For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast.”, what we actually hear is exactly backwards, because so many have forsaken God’s sovereignty over regeneration many have a theology that states that: the simple faith of man obliges God toward his regeneration, in other words, …for by faith you are saved, through grace, and that grace not of yourselves: that grace is the gift of God.

The problems that lie therein are both deep and wide!