Romans 5:7-9

For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.
Showing posts with label Art: Analytical. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Art: Analytical. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Abstract Versus Real

There used to be a great deal of debate surrounding the legitimacy of certain forms of "Modern" art, particularly the reductionistic/deconstructionistic sort.  In sort of a neo-renaissance, artists and architects alike reacted to Victorianism in a way similar to the proponents of realism reacted to the idealism of ancient Greek and Roman aesthetics.  This debate was brought back to my mind when I walked into my oldest son, Jeffrey's room and asked him what he was up to.  The response I got was unexpected, "I'm doing abstract art, Dad".  Some involved in the debate over the legitimacy of abstract art (for the purpose of this article I will limit the term art to mean 2 dimensional expression) charged those artists with a lack of talent because the realistic rendering of figure was not present.  I for one would not make the same claim, but I will say this, forms of abstract art display the artist's talent for composition, harmony, positive versus negative space, and other fundamentals taught in "2D" classes.  But those same artists don't display in their abstract works, the same degree of talent in realism, even if they are capable of it.  On the other hand, the those artists involved in realistic portraiture or landscape rendering, assuming the posses the same handle on the fundamentals, display in their expressions of realism, the talent of realism in addition to a talent for the fundamentals.
 
Jeffrey's Art

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

The Theology of Art

I guess its because most Christians are not forced to think about it formally day to day, but the question of beauty is neglected in our "world-view".  If anyone knows of a published systematic theology that includes a treatment on beauty, please let me know.  I am aware of several theologians who have written on the subject, Edwards, Sproul, and Kuyper (regarding the theology of art), who I have quoted below.
"And all these because the beautiful is not the product of our own fantasy, nor of our subjective perception, but has an objective existence, being itself the expression of a Divine perfection."  Abraham Kuyper from, "Lectures on Calvinism"
It seems important to me, not only because I am confronted with ideas of aesthetics on a daily basis due to my vocation, but also (and perhaps more importantly) because Americans are constantly , through all sorts of mediums, being told what is beautiful by untrustworthy sources.  Ultimately, that which is true is that which is beautiful.  So, beauty directly corresponds to truth; the degree to which something is true is the degree to which it is also beautiful.  And now for a bit of sarcasm...

"Don't teach me about truth and beauty, just label my music"  Derek Web from his song, "New Law".

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - III

Two posts ago I included a quote from Charles Ryrie in which he uses Acts 13:39 as an example of a major shift in the responsibility of man, and this indicates a change in administration, a change from one dispensation to another.

The false assumption that he seems to be making, one that is likely enforced by his hermeneutic, is that this statement in the book of Acts indicates that the saints in "The Age of Law" were required to obey the covenant law of Moses in order to be justified. In the very verse itself is the idea that this was never the case...it never was possible that the Law of Moses could justify. Covenant Theology would submit that the practice of those Old Covenant rituals were a part of the sanctification of the saints under that covenant, but never their justification.

Another, and related, outworking of the Dispensational hermenetical structure is that major shifts in what God has revealed to mankind are emphasized and are either caused by or the effect of the change from one dispensation to another. On the other hand, Covenant Theology places emphasis on the subtle shift of what God has reveled to mankind, not as indicators of a change in administration or dispensation, but rather, these shifts show that God cumulatively reveals knowledge about His relation to His creation and creatures.

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - II

There seems to be an historic Protestant way in which we have referred to the theological concept of justification. And if anyone reading this article can correct or expand my understanding here, particularly with a written source specifically on this subject, please do.

The ground of justification is the Passion of Christ; His life for our righteousness imputed, and His death for our sins atoned. The instrument of justification is faith.. The means of justification is the proclamation of the gospel and the Holy Spirit applying it.

Covenant Theology affirms that the entire formula above applies to justification in all ages. I believe that all types of Dispensationalism, generally speaking, would affirm this formula for what they call the "Age of Grace", or the "Church Age", and they too would affirm that the ground and instrument are the same in every age. The disagreement I believe would arise when we talk about the means in every age. It is here that I believe we get the reason for the oft heard claim that Dispensationalism teaches two "ways" of salvation. Though it seems to be clear that Darby, Scofield, Chafer and Ryrie would all deny this claim but, even if they would say that the means of justification in the "Age of Law" was the proclamation of the gospel, would they agree that the content of the gospel was the same? I think the answer is no. This begs the question, what is the content of the gospel?

According to Covenant Theology, the content of the gospel is always at least this, that God will (or already did depending on the perspective) provide the ultimate sacrifice to satisfy the demands of His Holiness. It is in the distinct expression of this promise that we find a difference as revelation progresses, but the shifts in the knowledge of the content of this promise are most often gradual: from the proto-evangel in the garden, to the salvation of Noah's family in the ark, to the substitute ram provided in the place of Isaac on Mount Moria, to the Suffering Servant desribed by Isaiah, on up to the culmination of all of those shadows in the revelation of Jesus on the cross.

On the other hand, Dispensationalism says (at least according to Ryrie, and this is where I need more information about other forms of Dispensationalism) that the content of that promise prior to the Church Age was not that specific, and that Old Testament saints did not necessarily have to see a coming Messiah/Redeemer in the shadows of the Old Covenant sacrifices, or that Abraham really only believed that God would bless him with many decendants and a physical land. Granted, these promises to Abraham, in their limited historical expression were very great promises which challenged the faith of Abraham, but to limit the content of his faith to just those things ignores the revelation previously provided for us. Though Abraham did not have a written copy of the pentetuch as the Jews later did, he would have had the stories of the garden and Noah to consider, and those types of Christ that would expand the content of his faith past what I believe Dispensationalism generally allows.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Further Questions for Dispensationalists

Another question for my dispensational friends is regarding Ryrie's distinction between the object of faith and the content of faith. In my assessment, this distinction is novel yet demanded as a consequence of a focus on the discontinuity between the Old and New Covenants (between the dispensations as they would say), but I would like to hear your thoughts on this. Below are two quotes from Charles Ryrie concerning this issue,

‘Through Him everyone who believes is freed [justified] from all things, from which you could not be freed [justified] through the Law of Moses’ (Acts 13:39). Here is unquestionably a distinguishable and different way of running the affairs of the world regarding man's responsibility in relation to the most important area of justification. Whatever his responsibility was under the Mosaic Law may be left unspecified at present (see chapter 6), but with the coming of Christ the requirement for justification became faith in Him. This, too, is obviously a distinctive stage in the progress of revelation. Therefore, we conclude that a new dispensation was inaugurated, since the economy and responsibility changed and the new revelation was given.”- Dispensationalism Today

"The basis of salvation in every age is the death of Christ; the requirement for salvation in every age is faith; the object of faith in every age is God; the content of faith changes in the various dispensations. It is this last point, of course, that distinguishes dispensationalism from covenant theology, but it is not a point to which the charge of teaching two ways of salvation can be attached. It simply recognizes the obvious fact of progressive revelation." - Dispensationalism Today

I now am wondering if this is consistent with the current form of argumentation regarding the "way" saints from previous ages were saved.

Friday, August 29, 2008

Addendum to Last Post

In my last post I called for the recommendations from Dispensationalists for sources citing the definition and defense of any form of that position. I mentioned in that post, several representatives of the faceted position, but I did fail to mention the proponents of what is called, "Progressive Dispensationalism". Craig Blaising and Darrell Bock are two of the major proponents, as well as Robert Saucey. After some prompting, I felt compeled to mention their names.

Monday, August 25, 2008

Calling All Dispensationalists, of Whatever Stripe or Shade

I am in the process of composing an essay on the differing hermeneutical assumptions of the Dispensational and Covenantal systems of theology, and their consequences on bible interpretation. In this process I have already consulted several sources on both sides of the issue. Of course I am writing from the side of Covenantal Theology, and in the progress of the essay I will argue that position. Even though I grew up in and was somewhat nurtured into Dispensational Theology, I still would like those who still hold that view to aid in my choices of sources for representation of that position, and its historical survey.

For instance, from the Brethren camp I have read and/or cited J.N. Darby, C.H. Mackintosh, and T.B. Baines. From the Fundamentalist Baptist camp, C.I. Scofield, L.S. Chafer, J. D. Pentecost, John Walvoord, and the more contemporary, Charles Ryrie. From the more progressive camp (and perhaps Calvinistic Dispensationalists) Michael Vlach, John MacArthur, Barry Horner, and Dennis Swanson.

I am making a call now to any dispensationalist reading this blog, to help me to quote the best sources in the areas of: scholastic/academic Dispensationalism, and surveys of that theology's occurrence in history made by trustworthy Dispensational sources.