Romans 5:7-9

For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Sanctification by Faith Alone

Sanctification is the fruit of justification; it is the byproduct, not the end.

I think it was Warfield who said that the only victorious Christian life that has ever been lived was that of the Lord Jesus Christ. I agree with that assessment, and with that in mind, why do we still have a great majority of the visible church fighting in an intramural wrestling match, if you will, to gain various crowns which represent the fulfillment of promises that God has actually made to ALL believers; to every member of His elect body?

Many (at least American believers) have been sold a poor bill of goods which includes the idea that once we are saved we must then maintain God's favor toward us by obedience to His commands. This flies right in the face of grace and works itself out in at least two ways:
  1. When we sin we lose our justification and we must repent and be saved once again.
  2. We remain saved when we sin but our disobedience is actually punished in eternity by loss of possible "rewards" .

The first option, in my estimation, is barely Christian at all. I do insist though that there are Christians who hold this view and defend it theologically (not just traditionally) but it is also important to recognise the far reaching implications of such a theology. It goes back to one's understanding of what happens at regeneration/conversion/the new birth; the reformed view states that at that event, an individual is "counted righteous"--he is justified in the eyes of God because of Christ's accomplishments. If this view is correct, then how strange it would seem to have God justify an individual on account of what God did on the cross only to have that individual later "unjustify" himself by breaking God's Law?

The second opinion, although much more palatable to the Christian tongue, is strangely misguided about the faithfulness of God to keep His promises to His people and about just what promises were fulfilled in the cross; further, this opinion accentuates the desire for eternal rewards besides God Himself--I believe that when the desire for these rewards outweigh our desire for God Himself, it is idolatry.

Conclusions:

At the moment of our justification we are counted righteous before God. Beside our sanctification, also procured by faith, what more could one really want? It is God's faithful distribution of His benefits to us that fuels our sanctification even after He has graciously justified us. It is not the fear of the potential loss of our crowns or of our salvation that should drive us to obedience but rather, it is the reiteration of the gospel that should drive us to delight in Christ; Christ raised for us, our newness in Him; sin no longer has dominion over you, therefore your obedience only makes sense. The gospel creates faith, and the sacraments of communion and baptism present the gospel tactily for the strengthening of our faith--the faith through which we were once justified and through which we are continually being sanctified.

The Law could never save us, and obedience to the Law is also never the road to sanctification, but the destination...the road of sanctification is also the gospel road.

The Law could not justify me and it also cannot sanctify me.

Sunday, November 25, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #7: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Ephesians 2: Part Two

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Part 2 of the discussion of Ephesians 2

I submit that, if at any time in the future a physical temple is set up and sacrificial worship (as either an honorarium or memorial) is reinstituted, then that building and those sacrifices will be a blasphemy to Christ. If dispensationalism is correct in claiming that the ceremonial laws, rights and rituals of the Mosaic Covenant (the Old Covenant) will be reinstituted, then shouldn’t the sign of circumcision as a sign of corporate covenant obedience also be reinstated? And if so, then this teaching flies in the face of the Word of God that the Holy Spirit delivered through Paul, to the Galatians.

Galatians 1

6 I am astonished that you are so quickly deserting him who called you in the grace of Christ and are turning to a different gospel— 7 not that there is another one, but there are some who trouble you and want to distort the gospel of Christ.

Galatians 2

3 But even Titus, who was with me, was not forced to be circumcised, though he was a Greek. 4 Yet because of false brothers secretly brought in—who slipped in to spy out our freedom that we have in Christ Jesus, so that they might bring us into slavery— 5 to them we did not yield in submission even for a moment, so that the truth of the gospel might be preserved for you.

I believe that the advocate of a future temple Judaism must endorse a sort of digressive revelation because the whole of the New Testament is just that, a new testament, or a new covenant, and the old has passed away. Is it suggested that in this future epoch the words written to the Romans, the Galatians, in the book of Hebrews and elsewhere are voided? No, I’m certain no self respecting dispensationalist would say so, but how else is such a view of the temple supposed to be interpreted? Paul was obviously chastening the Galatian church because they had been fooled by false brothers that obedience to Old Covenant rituals was part of sanctification, and in the worst cases, part of justification—Paul called this another gospel; he didn’t say it was another preference, he didn’t say that they were simply imprudent, he called the Galatians fools! The new covenant plainly brings the Jewish man and the gentile man together in one group, not separated by ceremonies, ritual sacrifices, moons and Sabbaths, but identified together with Christ, and this is accomplished in a better covenant. Are we to believe that in God’s plan for redemptive history, He made a covenant with Abraham (which he planned to fulfill in Christ) then He had the old covenant set up to picture the coming Messiah, which would be put aside for the better, new covenant which was in Christ’s blood (which would eventually begin to see fulfillment in Christ) only for the new and better covenant to later, also be put aside so He could finish what He had only begun with ethnic Israel in the old covenant? I know that to say that the reinstitution of circumcision, ritual sacrifices and the temple will be for a memorial appears to be a clean and sharp answer that dispensationalism gives when it attempts to answer the critique of future animal sacrifices after Christ has been sacrificed himself, (once and for all, as put in the book of Hebrews), but it is neither clean nor right; you don’t have to have a memorial for a person who is not dead, and especial not for a person who is alive and who is in your presence.

The ordinance of communion is what Christ told us to practice until He returns, and what of the Jew in that dispensational future who reads the Word and hears Col. 2:16 Therefore let no one pass judgment on you in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath. 17 These are a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ, or the words of Romans 4, Galatians 3, Hebrews 8, etc? The Jew in any future age will been given no authority subsequent to the writings of the New Testament to make him believe that those words will not also apply to him, but only to those who had passed in the age before. I know that we, present, new testament saints look at the commands of the Mosaic ceremonial and civil law and say, “…that is not for us…”, though Paul and others must look at it the same way we do, unless we are to believe that God will reveal more words in later years.

You might say that those Jews have precedence for rebuilding the temple and reinstating temple sacrifices because of the words of Ezekiel and other texts tell them to do this in the future, but this denies the New Testament interpretation of Ezekiel in specific and the Old Testament as a whole. The problem for dispensationalism remains, that revelation is progressive and there are many New Testament texts that explain how we should understand Old testament texts—even if that understanding is that they are not to be taken "literally"—as dispensationalists count things literal.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #6: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Ephesians 2: Part One

Who are the Children of Abraham?

In this article I continue my attempt to answer the question once again posted above.

Part 1 of the discussion of Ephesians 2

11 Therefore remember that at one time you Gentiles in the flesh, called "the uncircumcision" by what is called the circumcision, which is made in the flesh by hands—12 remember that you were at that time separated from Christ, alienated from the commonwealth of Israel and strangers to the covenants of promise, having no hope and without God in the world. 13 But now in Christ Jesus you who once were far off have been brought near by the blood of Christ. 14 For he himself is our peace, who has made us both one and has broken down in his flesh the dividing wall of hostility 15 by abolishing the law of commandments and ordinances, that he might create in himself one new man in place of the two, so making peace, 16 and might reconcile us both to God in one body through the cross, thereby killing the hostility. 17 And he came and preached peace to you who were far off and peace to those who were near. 18 For through him we both have access in one Spirit to the Father. 19 So then you are no longer strangers and aliens, but you are fellow citizens with the saints and members of the household of God,

Paul tells the Gentiles in the flesh (that is us) that we were at one time far off, but we have now by Christ, been brought near to the commonwealth of Israel, no longer strangers to the covenants of promise, and now having hope. The dividing wall in the temple which separated gentiles from Jews, even circumcised Gentiles from Jews, was broken down by Christ on the cross. It was a wall of hostility; a wall of violence which cause division and animosity between the Jews and the Gentiles; a wall which caused the Pharisees to hate the Samaritans. Paul tells us that this wall has been broken down because Christ abolished the law of commandments and ordinances, and He did this by fulfilling all righteousness and making the debt payment for sin which is death; Christ has fulfilled the consequences God demanded of us because of Adam’s failure in the covenant God made with that first man (not that in His victory Christ destroyed the immutable commandments of God) but rather, He destroyed the ordinances of that Old Covenant and thus God fashions the individual recipients of the New Covenant as new men—not like the old man in the Old Covenant, and not like the old man who was far off from the Old Covenant, but a new man who receives the benefits of the covenant God made with Adam and which He reiterated in the covenant He made with Abraham and which He now, finally and forever, has fulfilled by Christ in the New Covenant, in order to bring together in one new group, all of the saints through all time: those who before were strangers to and those who were familiar with the covenants of promise.

In light of the declarations in this passage, it is backwards to take the prophesy of Ezekiel’s temple and an interpretation of Romans 11 (which affirms some sort of future for ethnic Israel) to mean that, at some time in the future God will measure the obedience of the nation of Israel by their faithfulness to rebuild a physical temple, and sacrifice bulls and goats. Even if the purpose of this practice in a future age were only for memorial, the advocate must maintain that Christ is present and ruling on an Earth while the “people of God” are not focused on the substance to which those sacrifices pointed but rather, they would center their worship around the shadows and the types while the substance of the shadows and the archetype is there—it’s scandalous! Can you imagine trying to honor your brother in eulogy while he is still alive, and even in the same room? This is paramount to going to the beach and instead of gazing out into the vastness of the ocean to marvel at its size, you stand on the sandy shore, turn your back away from the ocean, pick up a seashell and put it up to your ear—proclaiming the greatness of the sounds of the ocean; smelling the shell and delighting in how much like the beach it smells; touching your tongue to the inside of the shell and likening its flavor to the salty taste of ocean water, when all the while the object to which the shell is only a sign, is right there before you. The pre-incarnation Saints only had the shell to lift to their ear to hear the echo of the waves; to lift the shell to their nose to see how the sea smelled; to taste what the salty sea was like by touching their tongue to the shell. Those of us after the birth of Christ can bask in the glory of the presence of the Sea itself and can stand before it and smell His misty waves as they crash on the shore, and we have the privilege of tasting the salty flavor of His waters in the flesh, and this is done in communion; not now nor at any time in the future will we trade that covenant feast for a lesser sign of physical sacrifice, but we will one day trade it for the physical presence of our Lord Himself.

Friday, November 16, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #5: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Galatians 4:22-26

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Galatians 4

22 For it is written that Abraham had two sons, one by a slave woman and one by a free woman. 23 But the son of the slave was born according to the flesh, while the son of the free woman was born through promise. 24 Now this may be interpreted allegorically: these women are two covenants. One is from Mount Sinai, bearing children for slavery; she is Hagar. 25 Now Hagar is Mount Sinai in Arabia; she corresponds to the present Jerusalem, for she is in slavery with her children. 26 But the Jerusalem above is free, and she is our mother.

Here Paul formally states what he said in the previous chapter of Galatians, that there are two covenants in mind: the one of promise and the one of flesh. Interestingly enough Paul uses an Old Testament text and allegorizes it to illuminate his audience to the fuller meaning of the text. Paul and his readers certainly believe that the two literal women existed in history and that the literal account of their lives was written down in scripture, but God had a bigger, fuller purpose with those women, and the events spoken of here are meant to do more than merely establish ancestral integrity or historical validity. So we have a contrast of two covenants, a tale of two cities, if you will:

Hagar ------- Sarah
Moses ------- Abraham
Sinai/Jerusalem ------- Heavenly Jerusalem (the Jerusalem above)
Slavery and law ------- Promise of Freedom
Flesh ------- Spirit
Sons of flesh ------- Sons of promise

There are two items in the study of this text that I believe argue against dispensationalism, and they are:

  1. Paul contrasts the blessings of the Abrahamic and Mosaic Covenants.
  2. Paul allegorizes the historical/grammatical interpretation of an Old Testament event.

It is my understanding that both of these items above are contrary to rudimentary dispensational hermeneutics, which states that the meaning of the Old Testament text to its then, contemporary audience is the only meaning of that text, thus rendering it the so called “literal” interpretation. Also (according to dispensational theology), the promises God made to Abraham (land and many seed) were reiterated and expanded in the Mosaic Covenant and given even more strenuous stipulations; and even today they have not been realized, thus they cannot be arrogated by the gentile/Jewish “Church” because God never made those promises to that group and He still plans to fulfill those promises of physical seed and land to a group strictly made up of believing Jews in the future in a literally physical way.

As I close this post, take a look at another statement that clearly associates Old and New Testament believers in the same covenant.

Philippians 3:3 For we are the real circumcision, who worship by the Spirit of God and glory in Christ Jesus and put no confidence in the flesh—

In Paul’s mind there were two circumcisions, one made with hands and one made by the Spirit (the real one). Obvious from more passages than can be listed, Abraham was of the real circumcision, and according to Galatians 3:29 we are Abraham’s spiritual children, but what makes us so? It certainly isn’t our physical Jewish heritage because in Christ there is neither Jew nor Greek. We are grafted into the Abrahamic Covenant and made fellow recipients of the promises thereof, because it is an overarching covenant, one which is ultimately fulfilled in the New Covenant and which affords gracious provisions for all of God’s children throughout the entirety of redemptive history.

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #4: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Galatians 3:7-29

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Galatians 3

I realize this is a very lengthy passage, but please bear with me—it is after all, Scripture.

7 Know then that it is those of faith who are the sons of Abraham. 8 And the Scripture, foreseeing that God would justify the Gentiles by faith, preached the gospel beforehand to Abraham, saying, "In you shall all the nations be blessed." 9 So then, those who are of faith are blessed along with Abraham, the man of faith. 10 For all who rely on works of the law are under a curse; for it is written, "Cursed be everyone who does not abide by all things written in the Book of the Law, and do them." 11 Now it is evident that no one is justified before God by the law, for "The righteous shall live by faith." 14 so that in Christ Jesus the blessing of Abraham might come to the Gentiles, so that we might receive the promised Spirit through faith. 15 To give a human example, brothers: even with a man-made covenant, no one annuls it or adds to it once it has been ratified. 16 Now the promises were made to Abraham and to his offspring. It does not say, "And to offsprings," referring to many, but referring to one, "And to your offspring," who is Christ. 17 This is what I mean: the law, which came 430 years afterward, does not annul a covenant previously ratified by God, so as to make the promise void. 18 For if the inheritance comes by the law, it no longer comes by promise; but God gave it to Abraham by a promise. 19 Why then the law? It was added because of transgressions, until the offspring should come to whom the promise had been made, and it was put in place through angels by an intermediary. 20 Now an intermediary implies more than one, but God is one. 21 Is the law then contrary to the promises of God? Certainly not! For if a law had been given that could give life, then righteousness would indeed be by the law. 22 But the Scripture imprisoned everything under sin, so that the promise by faith in Jesus Christ might be given to those who believe.

27 For as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ. 28 There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. 29 And if you are Christ's, then you are Abraham's offspring, heirs according to promise.


In this passage Paul refers to us, those of faith, as the Abraham’s offspring (v 29) because of our relationship with Christ—being in Christ; Abraham is the man of faith, and we are those who are of faith, and if Abraham’s offspring and heirs according to promise (v 29) then we are obviously part of the same spiritual family—now and in Heaven, in eternity because he is not referring to us as the physical descendants of Abraham, and if we are the offspring of Abraham, heirs according to the promise, then we are also sons of Abraham. If so, then by what line of reasoning can we conclude that we will be of a different group or family or kingdom in eternity? For further support that we are in the same group as Abraham consider that the blessing which comes to all the nations through Abraham was the same good news (gospel in v 8) that was preached to Abraham by the scriptures, which foretold of the gentiles being justified by faith and they are in the company of Abraham because he is the man of faith, not the man of law and not the man of circumcision. We are blessed along with Abraham, and this cannot merely be the blessing of physical land because that was the blessing of the Mosaic covenant. We know that our blessing is not limited to that of a physical place in an unredeemed earth, but our blessing, our inheritance is the redeemed Heaven’s and Earth, as Christ said, “the meek shall inherit the Earth”, so too must Abraham’s ultimate blessing be spiritual because, according to this passage we are blessed together with him.

Verse 16 tells us that Christ is The Seed of whom God was speaking to Abraham; the promise is to Christ, and those counted in Christ are joint heirs, thus receiving the inheritance promised to Abraham’s seed. But the question might be posed, “but the Law of Moses came after the covenant with Abraham so it must fulfill it or cancel it out, right?” But Paul answers this question by telling us that the Law, though it did come 430 years after Abraham does not annul a covenant previously ratified by God. These two covenants are separate and the promises of the covenant God made with Abraham are not appropriated when the stipulations of the covenant made on Mount Sinai are fulfilled or Paul would not have to answer the question about the law, and the question would not have been pressing in the minds of his contemporaries if they had not confused the two covenants. Paul does go on to explain that the Law is not therefore useless, but that it was put in place because of sin, and elsewhere, Paul tells us that the law points out the exceeding sinfulness of sin. Perhaps the phrase that best explains the existence of the law though the promises were received by faith is in verse 22, “But the Scripture imprisoned everything under sin”; that is what the Law did, it imprisoned all our works under sin so that it would be very clear that even our “good works” would not purchase the promises of the Abrahamic covenant for us.

Paul says that if the inheritance came through Law, then it can’t also come through a promise. In other words, if the covenant of Moses came to hold out the same promises as the covenant with Abraham, then its blessings and benefits are no longer by the promise, but by Law, and Paul maintains that this is not the case. So one of the conclusions we must make regarding verses 16-19 is that the promises made to Abraham were neither fulfilled or annulled in the covenant with Moses, but that the previous covenant continues and the Mosaic Covenant, though it was good to point out sin, was the parenthesis inside the timeline of the promise and fulfillment aspects of the Abrahamic covenant. Paul further explains the differences of the Mosaic and Abrahamic Covenants by contrasting one as law and the other as promise, not that they are fighting against each other, but that the Mosaic Covenant was never put in place to accomplish the same thing. The Mosaic Covenant was only ever typical of the Abrahamic Covenant. Though there may have been a temporal aspect to the promises made to Abraham, the greater fulfillment of them would be spiritual and granted unconditionally, and the blessings of the Mosaic covenant were strictly temporal and conditioned upon the corporate or federal obedience of the nation “…all this we will do.” (like the covenant God made with Adam, who was the representative of all). If the law (which was never given to provide life) had not imprisoned us in sin then life could not be given by faith alone in Jesus Christ. A few verses later Paul concludes the section by telling his listeners that there is no difference between Jew and Greek regarding the promise and blessing to Abraham because if you are in Christ then you are Abraham’s offspring because it is by promise, not by ethnicity or law or circumcision.

Monday, November 12, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #3: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Romans 4:9-12

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Romans 4


9 Is this blessing then only for the circumcised, or also for the uncircumcised? We say that faith was counted to Abraham as righteousness. 10 How then was it counted to him? Was it before or after he had been circumcised? It was not after, but before he was circumcised. 11 He received the sign of circumcision as a seal of the righteousness that he had by faith while he was still uncircumcised. The purpose was to make him the father of all who believe without being circumcised, so that righteousness would be counted to them as well, 12 and to make him the father of the circumcised who are not merely circumcised but who also walk in the footsteps of the faith that our father Abraham had before he was circumcised.

In all of Romans 4 Paul is talking about how Abraham’s faith was given to him before he obeyed any stipulations that God had set up in a covenant; faith even then was the instrument God used to rescue individuals from the wrath to come, not the individual’s personal piety or obedience to the “rule of life” for that particular dispensation—salvation has never been granted any other way by grace alone, through faith alone, in The Christ (future or come) alone.

Covenantal obedience in Romans 4 is specifically characterized by the act of circumcision. In the Apostolic age the gentile Christians might have questioned their legitimate claim on a Jewish Messiah, but in Paul’s letter to a gentile city and church, he writes about how faith is given apart from or before the obedience to a peculiar Jewish custom—which in this case was circumcision.

The peculiar act of circumcision pictured the curse by which God Himself would be defecated if He did not uphold the unconditional promises He made to Abraham in that covenant. It was a sign of the animals cut in two when God “cut” that covenant with Abraham, and a seal to all the children of Abraham afterward that God would remain faithful, not that all those who were circumcised were the spiritual children of Abraham, but that it pictured the promises God made to him and his offspring, thus the removal of his foreskin is typical. On the cross, Christ was “cut off” in the place of Abraham and all his spiritual children. He was the cut off foreskin in the place of those who couldn’t fulfill the law for righteousness. It was a strange ritual, but it makes sense when you consider the nature of the promise, that it would come through Abraham’s Seed (Christ), to Abraham’s offspring (those counted “in Christ”). The misunderstanding of many, because it was formerly a mystery, was that the spiritual blessing that came to Abraham and will come to his offspring through Christ is not only for those who were circumcised in the flesh, but for those who were circumcised in their heart; those who were and are spiritually circumcised, and Paul establishes his claim by telling us that Abraham was counted righteous before he was circumcised, not after, and the purpose of God doing it in that order was so God could count both the physically circumcised and the physically uncircumcised righteous—by faith alone, not by faith plus circumcision. Just consider the harsh words Paul had for the Galatians.

Furthermore, if Abraham is the Father of all those who have faith and are counted righteous, then he is obviously in the same redeemed group as all of those who are counted righteous; all those who are counted as his children. He cannot be “the father of all who believe without being circumcised” and at the same time, the member of a completely different group in eternity. Paul places Abraham in the same group as all who believe (circumcised or not); who “walk in the footsteps of the faith that Abraham had before he was circumcised”.

In Galatians 3:29 Paul calls all of those in Christ Abraham’s seed or offspring. We can logically and biblically equate the term “Abraham’s offspring” with the term, “children of Abraham”. Every redeemed person is counted in Christ instead of being counted in Adam, and if counted in Christ, then counted as the seed or offspring or children of Abraham. How then can anyone say that Abraham is the father of all of those in Christ, and yet he is not part of that same eternal group? We cannot!

Thursday, November 8, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #2: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Romans 2:26-29

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Romans 2

26 So, if a man who is uncircumcised keeps the precepts of the law, will not his uncircumcision be regarded as circumcision? 27 Then he who is physically uncircumcised but keeps the law will condemn you who have the written code and circumcision but break the law. 28 For no one is a Jew who is merely one outwardly, nor is circumcision outward and physical. 29 But a Jew is one inwardly, and circumcision is a matter of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the letter. His praise is not from man but from God.

Three statements must first be made: the Jews in Paul’s day considered themselves the children of Abraham by virtue of their covenant relationship through Moses and Sinai; for Paul, “keep[ing] the precepts of the law” is the same as one having been regenerated, which is the same as one having had the law of God written on his heart; and last, those “who have the written code and circumcision” are those to whom Moses gave the Decalogue; the members of the Old Covenant; those who in Paul’s day, considered themselves Jews exclusively.

Paul clarifies here what God has been doing throughout history: that which was once veiled as a mystery but is now revealed more clearly after Christ (the Lamb of God, the Seed of Abraham) has come, that the ethnic Jew (the Jew by sole virtue of his family heritage) is not necessarily the one blessed to receive the promises of God even if, along with that heritage, he obeyed the stipulations of the Mosaic covenant and received some of the physical promises of God with the covenant community as a whole but rather, the true Jew is the one who is circumcised of heart, not just circumcised of flesh; the one who has the precepts of the moral law written on his heart by God’s elective work, not the one who only obeys the precepts of the civil and ceremonial law of Moses as a member of the Old Covenant community.

When Paul mentions circumcision here he is referencing the outward obedience to the Mosaic Law, which is why he draws the contrast between the one who is merely circumcised and the one who has the law inwardly; the one who has had the law written on his heart; that one is the one who is regarded as actually having been circumcised.

Having the law written on the heart of an individual, as is mentioned in Jeremiah 31, is not the futuristic portion of that prophesy, the future aspect of it was that one day, all those in the covenant God has made will have the law written on their hearts. There were many under the Old Covenant who were members of that community but who had not had the law written on their hearts, likewise there were individuals in the Old Covenant who did have that law written on their hearts—they were saved, they were born again—but the law had not been written on the hearts of the community at large. One day in that New Covenant, all its members will have that blessing; all of those covenant members will be the spiritual children of Abraham. We will discuss this a bit more when we deal with the Jeremiah passage in particular, as we attempt to answer the question: who are the partakers of the New Covenant?

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #1: Introduction

I am beginning a series on my thus far accumulated thoughts on the dispensational system and why I think the bible teaches otherwise. I am dreadfully aware of the controversy that might result from the title alone, but to call this series by any other name would be to betray the very nature of its content.

There will be four major sections in the series:

1. Who are the Children of Abraham?
2. Who are the partakers of the New Covenant?
3. The types and shadows of Christ
4. A few exposing questions for dispensationalists

I look forward to any discussion which may result from this series and I pray that my rhetoric is not hurtful and in no way misrepresents those from the dispensational camp.

Discussion on this topic has been all the rage this year and I believe it was kicked off by John MacArthur’s polemic against Amillennialism at this year’s Shepherd’s Conference. Many blogs are still periodically posting articles relating to the topic, even though the frequency has diminished. I do see much of what has transpired in the last 7 months or so as useful (excepting the harshness of some of the discussions) and I agree with John Piper when he says in his book, Contending for Our All, that, “The witness of church history is that seasons of controversy have often been seasons of great growth and strength.”, and as he wrote concerning Athanasius’ stand for the deity of Christ that, “Without controversy there would have been no gospel, and therefore no church.” J. Gresham Machen also spoke wisely about the controversies of his day, “Every true revival is born in controversy, and leads to more controversy. That has been true ever since our Lord said that he came not to bring peace upon the earth but a sword.”

So with that introduction behind us, let’s delve into the realm of controversy and pray that a revival might break out locally and abroad.

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

An Illustration of the Concurrence of Our Plans and God's Plans

This morning I considered an illustration of the way our wills and choices coincide with God's will and eternal decrees.

I work in the design field where I am drawing on a daily basis. We often find ourselves tracing over the lines of an existing drawing using tracing paper (a translucent paper). With that in mind, imagine that the lines of the existing drawing are the lines of God's decree; the lines of God's eternal plan. Now imagine that the tracing paper represents the Word of God, so we are suppose to interpret God's plan through the tracing paper (the Word of God). As we trace the lines on the existing drawing, because we are imperfect and affected by the curse, we don't see through the tracing paper as we ought, so we sometimes misinterpret the lines on the existing drawing underneath, thus we often do not trace over the lines properly. The less understanding we have of the scriptures, the thicker the tracing paper seems to be and in that case it is more difficult for us to see the lines of the existing drawing through the tracing paper.

So it also is with the concurrence of our plans and God's plans. Often, we lay out our plans on the tracing paper without tracing over the lines of God's plans because we do not see them clearly, but God's plans exist objectively and they do not change. Other times we do see the line of God's plans clearly through the tracing paper of scripture and we line the drawing of our own plans up with the lines of God's plan; God's glory is magnified and our joy results. Still other times we do see the lines of God's plan clearly and yet we rebel against those clearly draw lines and we scribble off in another direction, noticing that our scribbling has not changed the lines on the existing drawing underneath but instead, we find that our scribbling has driven us to joyless despair and fear, and as God's children we eventually and enevitably repent of our sinful misdirection, and by God's grace, once again we trace the existing lines of the plan God has drawn.

Monday, November 5, 2007

The Mighty Savior of All Creation

Holiness be to the Lord our God;
The Mighty Savior of all creation!

He resists the pride of haughty men,
but He comforts the weak and afflicted.

Oh, how we praise His name;
how we lift it up before the lords of earth.
Hallelujah He will save us!
Hallelujah praise His name!

The name of the All Mighty we will proclaim;
sovereign over all His creation!

He is good and wise and powerful,
yet He stooped down to share our distress.

Oh, how we praise His name;
how we lift it up before the lords of earth.
Hallelujah He will save us!
Hallelujah praise His name!

He came and died and He rose again;
all creation must worship The Anointed!

He was seen by many in resurrection body,
then to His Father’s right side He ascended!

Oh, how we praise His name;
how we lift it up before the lords of earth.
Hallelujah He will save us!
Hallelujah praise His name!

Friday, November 2, 2007

Another Example of Equivocation

I heard an interesting example of equivocation this morning:

The host of a Christian radio show introduced their topic while he was interviewing the speaker. The topic was, "myths about evangelism", and the host labeled the first one, "people do not want to hear about Jesus." The speaker then began to elaborate on the myth by stating its converse, "people are open to the gospel".

All other errors aside, it is one thing to suggest that people do want to hear about Jesus; this statement could be considered true if one qualified it by saying that a person wanting to hear about Jesus is not the same as a person seeking after God, which Paul in his letter to the Romans explicitly states as not being the case, but to liken the idea that, "people want to hear about Jesus" with the idea that "people are open to the gospel", is to equivocate a potentially true statement with an out-right error.

The context on the program was this: we as Christians tell ourselves lies (myths) about unbelievers and about the nature of evangelism so that we might not feel so guilty about not proclaiming the gospel. But in that context, we can never say that persons (ones we should be evangelising) are open to the good news, which is that Christ has born the penalty of our sins, and raised from the dead to placate the wrath of the Father. If anyone believes that then they do not need to be evangelised...they need to be discipled.

As a result of, what I believe is a disregard for what have historically been considered biblical categories: evangelism, seeker, and the gospel, and for what has been the historical understanding of the human condition, i.e., depraved, persons often think that unbelievers are open to the gospel, or that they are even seeking it or seeking Jesus for salvation prior to being regenerated, when we know from scripture that all of us who once were, and all present unbelievers not only are not seeking the gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ, but in their hearts we hated Him; those considered "seekers" by many evangelicals may very well want to know more about Jesus the person who existed in history, they may even want to know more about the historical truth claims of Christianity, but unless they are called by The Spirit of God, they are never open to the gospel...at least not until one is regenerated is he open to the gospel.

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Memorable Quote

"Once you assume the gospel, you're already in danger of losing it."

D.A. Carson during an interview with Mike Horton of The White Horse Inn - October 2007

Tuesday, October 30, 2007

The Gospel As Law

In the theological circles in which I travel, most are aware of the recent discussion of Joel Osteen on The White Horse Inn. On the right side of this blog under "Places I Go" I have a link to their site. I am certain that it is not the intention of the White Horse Inn hosts, nor is it my intention to simply criticize and bash another man who at least calls himself a Christian. The intention is to protect the children of God from those things that are very dangerous. Though he smiles a great deal, though he communicates friendliness and concern through his soothing tone and his passive body language, his message, I'm afraid, is ultimately one that brings death.

Instead of the Law of a holy God: do all this and you shall live, he presents moralistic advise: just try a little harder and you'll get it right. Instead of the gospel of a merciful and just God: Christ has done for sinners all that God has commanded in His Law, he attempts to absolve his listeners of their guilt by advising them to obey God's commands and God will be obliged to make them happy. In the end, that presentation is just another form of law; there is no mention of Christ's work on our behalf: even on our behalf to give us joy, which it most certainly does. Though Osteen may mention Christ's death in some of his preaching, he does not attach it to the holy justice of God and His wrath against unbelievers, so the Osteen "gospel" becomes law. Instead of presenting the Law and commands of God: your sins have set you against God and His wrath is upon you, Osteen says, even if you don't think that you measure up, it's OK because God loves you anyway. Instead of presenting the good news: believe and repent of your sins, Osteen says: obey God's commands and He will lead you on the path of happiness and self-fulfillment.

While Joel Osteen's message is mingled with truth: God does love humanity, excessive self abasement is harmful (particularly if it does not drive one to the gospel), his presentation of "good news" is not all that good. Are you really telling us Pastor Joel, that the way we earn God's favor is by obeying His Law; the way we insure our "best life now" is to line ourselves up more strictly with a form of biblical moralism?

A few scripture come to my mind in this case:

Jude

3 Beloved, although I was very eager to write to you about our common salvation, I found it necessary to write appealing to you to contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints. 4 For certain people have crept in unnoticed who long ago were designated for this condemnation, ungodly people, who pervert the grace of our God into sensuality and deny our only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ.

2 Peter 2

1 But false prophets also arose among the people, just as there will be false teachers among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies, even denying the Master who bought them, bringing upon themselves swift destruction. 2 And many will follow their sensuality, and because of them the way of truth will be blasphemed. 3 And in their greed they will exploit you with false words. Their condemnation from long ago is not idle, and their destruction is not asleep.

I know some of my words seem harsh, but they are not nearly as destructive as the ignorance of the gospel which Olsteen's words promote.

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

Eight Revealing Questions: Question #8 & Conclusions: Installment #7

And finally, the last question to be asked (at least in this series) is:

Was my choice determined?

If I have answered the previous questions correctly and with biblical accuracy, then:

1. God does know my future choices; God knows all the future perfectly.

2. I do choose freely.

3. I cannot be forced to choose something that I do not want.

4. I make the choices I make based on my affections and my strongest desires.

5. My affections and God's decree are causes of the choices I make.

As we consider the choices I have already made:

6. I could never have chosen differently.

7. I cannot choose against the eternal decree of God.

Then the answer to question #8, was my choice determined is, yes. And it must be if God knows what He knows perfectly and those things He knows includes my choices, then my choice is necessarily predetermined. God has determined my future choice by His infallible decrees which are their primary cause, but He has also determined that I will make the choices I make based on my affections/desires/inclinations, which are the secondary causes of my choices. They are the means by which God will accomplish His ends through my free choices; and He has ordained both the means and the ends. Take once again the instance where I chose to turn left instead of right: if God knew I was going to turn left, even though there were various causes (secondary to His knowledge of my future choice and His decree of it) for my decision, and I ended up turning right--contrary to His knowledge--then we must either change our definition of the word know or God didn't actually know that I was going to decide to turn left.

After ruminating over these questions, I think it is clear how one ends up with an "open" view of God if one has rejected the orthodox view of providence, compatibilism and God's decrees and replaced it with an unorthodox view of libertarian free will (the view that claims that in order for the creature to make really free choices, in hindsight it must have had the ability to have chosen otherwise and cannot have been constrained by any determining cause...even its own desires and affections) the next "logical" step in such a system, in order to maintain one's consistency, is to say that God does not actually know my future choices, and if He did and if I couldn't have chosen otherwise, then my choices are never really free because they are constrained by God's knowledge of them and my affection toward, them based on my strongest desire.

What is further is that God's knowledge of future events, creatures and their choices is not subject to His observation of a future that exists outside of His decree. The set of events which we (bound in time) look forward to as future, and which we look back at and call history does not exist as an arbitrary object which God had to discover and about which He now submits His knowledge. NO, the reality is that time and history are subject to Him because He has ordained all their means and ends.

There are two sets of implications that can be drawn from this information:

Those conclusions which are subject to biblical evidence lead to the Reformed view of God's providence:

1. God knows my future choice perfectly, therefore my choice is predestined.

2. Because God has perfect knowledge of future events and choices, He necessarily must have decreed their occurrence.

3. God knows my future choice perfectly, therefore I can’t choose against His decree.

4. God knows my future choice perfectly, therefore I can’t choose differently; I cannot make a choice which is contrary to His decree.

Those conclusions about God's providence which are based solely in human sophistry lead to a non-Christian view of God.

1. If my choice is not predetermined then God cannot know my future choice perfectly.

2. If I can choose against the decree of God then He doesn’t actually know my future choice and thus has not decreed it.

3. If I can choose differently then God doesn’t know my future choice perfectly.

Monday, October 8, 2007

Eight Revealing Questions: Questions #5, #6 & #7: Installment #6

Question number five, what factors cause or determine our choices?

The answer to this question lies in the explanation given of the types of causes by which we are influenced, but the final answer to question number five is two-fold: our affections and God's decree; our affections are the factors that determine the choices we make, thus causing us to choose what we want, and God's decree causes or determines our choices. But these conclusions raise other questions.

We have seen that there are many influences to be considered as we ponder why we have made certain choices, but the immediate cause of our choice is ultimately our affections. Our affections may be altered by our surroundings and the influence that other creatures have over us. We also established that if I do not have the capacity to make a certain choice, I have ultimately not been coerced into choosing against my strongest desire because it is a choice that I am not capable of making, thus it cannot be the object of my strongest affection. We also saw that one of the causes of my choices (which remain free because I choose according to my desires and affections) is God's decree of that choice. Therefore we must ask the sixth and seventh questions: could we actually have chosen differently; can I chose against the decree of God?

The manner in which question #6 is asked makes it seem innocent and to answer in the negative would make it appear to be a violation of the creature's freedom, but a closer look at that particular phrasing should cause one to dive deeper into the question and re-ask it in a manner similar to question #7.

Question #6 is completely legitimate, could I actually have chosen differently? In answering this question it is helpful to consider once again, the causes of my choice. Let's return to the example where I was "forced" to turn left in my car. Would the material causes of my choice to turn left annihilate my ability to turn right? The existence of the road wouldn’t prohibit my turning right. The fact that I was in a car would not prohibit me from turning right if I had wanted to. My own existence would not preclude my turning right. So what about the efficient causes: my thought processes were some of the efficient causes for my turning left but they were not a cause to the exclusion of turning right. Even though the threat to my life caused me to turn left, I still could have turned right in the face of that risk, so from that stand point alone I could have chosen differently. By turning left, I might have still reached my destination even though I was forced to turn left when I would have considered a right turn the more efficient path to my destination. Even if turning left had been a dead-end, I could eventually have make a u-turn and finally arrived at my destination. The fact that I was at a “T” intersection when I turned left did not limit my choice to only turning left; I still could have turned right if I didn't allow the car-jacker to influence my decision. I even could have gone straight if I had been willing to run off the road. So we find that none of the material or efficient causes would have destroyed my ability to choose otherwise.

Next we explore the formal cause of my decision to turn left. Officially, the formal causes of my choice to turn left were the motivating factors of the situation: the gunman, and my desire to preserve my life, but neither of these destroyed my capacity to chose to turn right. So during the examination of all these different causes of my choice to turn left we find that, from the human, temporal perspective I could have turned right. But in hindsight we must also agree that my choice was fixed and because I did finally chose to turn left, we must deduce that I could not have chosen otherwise because of the final cause of my choice.

The final cause of my choice to turn left was not just my desire and affection to that direction and my desire to preserve my life, but ultimately, the answer to question #6 is no, and question #7 is that I could not have chosen otherwise because God decreed for it to happen. God knew it was going to happen, and if He knew I might turn left but I actually ended up turning right, then His knowledge of my choice would have been imperfect. Because God’s knowledge of the future is perfect I could not have chosen differently. So, can I choose against the decree of God? Well, if I have argued effectively in the last several sentences then we will see that the answer to this question is also no, and for the very same reasons. If we are able to choose contrary to the decree of God then He would no longer be God because He would be rendered impotent and without perfect knowledge.

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

Hyper-Evangelism

In this article I intend to propose a term for the practices that have long been (at least in this post-Finney period of redemptive history) regarded as normal evangelical efforts. Such practices and efforts Charles Finney called the "new measures". These new ordinances included the alter call, and the sinners prayer, and the method of their administration was not gospel proclamation but "preaching" the Law of God so as to insight fear in the heart and a desire to change one's own behavior. The term I propose for these practices which unfortunately remain a large part of 21st century evangelical heritage is, "hyper-evangelism".

Contrary to all that, in the middle of the 1770's God blessed America and the world with what we call "The First Great Awakening". Men like Jonathan Edwards and George Whitefield were on fire with the gospel of God and they lowered their flames to catch fire to the souls of sinners who God had humbled by His grace. As mentioned before, in regards to the Finneite heresies, the second work that must be considered in the realm of Christian history is what is commonly referred to as "The Second Great Awakening" which took place about a half century later in the early 1800's, and from which the Christian Church is still recovering. In my opinion that second work was not an awakening at all, at least not an awakening to God and His gospel; it was more of a revival of externally moralism than anything else, and I would prefer to call the work God did through Edwards and Whitefield "The Great Awakening", and the events that occurred in America under the influence of Finney, a "Second Sinai" because of its emphasis on Law without gospel and the failure of its participants to see that the Law of God does not redeem it only condemns.

I justify the use of the labels hyper-evangelism and hyper-evangelistic based on the historical use of the terms: Calvinism, Hyper-Calvinism, evangelism and evangelistic. Calvinism is a term describing the biblical position which systematised five points of soteriological doctrine that resulted at the Synod of Dort from the discussions of Jacob Arminius' proposals against reformed thinking, but hyper-Calvinism rightly describes an unbiblical position loosely based on historical Calvinism but misapplied and drew unbiblical and illogical conclusions from the historic Calvinistic position. likewise, historically, evangelism is a term which describes the biblical methodology of spreading the kingdom through the means of gospel preaching, but the term I propose, hyper-evangelism, is a term I am using to describe an unbiblical method of evangelism which is loosely based on the historical, biblical method, but it either goes too far or not far enough.

Furthermore, Calvinism is the modern name that has been given (due to John Calvin’s debates with Jacob Arminius over the nature of election and saving grace) to this system which attempts to describe all the relevant biblical data concerning the sovereignty of God over all his creation and creatures, over all of history and his decree of those things. On the other hand, hyper-Calvinism is not so much a system, but rather a dogma which takes the Calvinistic understanding of election and predestination and, instead of building an understanding of all related doctrines systematically, it twists those doctrines to fit an illogical outworking of predestination and election while ignoring relevant passages stating the contrary, thus skewing one's evangelistic methods.

Likewise, evangelism is a word used to describe the act of bearing witness of the Christ of history, what he did in time and why. Historically speaking, the method of doing so is built on a systematic approach to all the biblical texts relevant to the nature of God, the nature of man, his relationship to man, the commands pertaining to said method, historical accounts of what God has done, and the weight of future events. On the other hand, hyper-evangelism also describes a method of bearing witness but it is not a method firmly tied to a systematic which considers all the relevant biblical texts but instead, it focuses exclusively on the "offer" of the gospel and the responsibility of all sinners to “accept Jesus Christ”. It does have a skeletal framework on which it bases its methods, that God is asking all men to embrace him, and that everyone God asks to come, has the natural ability to either accept or decline the invitation, and that if one experiences sufficient regret, then their prayer to God obligates Him to extend to them His grace.

The alter call, the “sinner’s prayer”, a fixation on “numbers”, “seeker sensitivity, a bare-bones presentation of the gospel (in fact the removal of God’s holiness and wrath from the gospel presentation all together), no or very little discipleship, no church discipline, a focus on false worship, a confusion of indicative and imperative passages and of law and gospel, a denial of perseverance (Christ’s lordship and the believer’s security), the promotion of the believer’s “temporal prosperity”, and in the most severe cases, a denial of original sin are either, symptoms of, or practices resulting from hyper-evangelism.

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Hence a Paradox

As we debate one another over various things, we engage in arguments in order to prove our position to be true, or to prove the position of our opponent to be false. Within this realm of discussion, discourse and dialogue we find what are called syllogisms. Syllogisms are defined by Princeton this way: "deductive reasoning in which a conclusion is derived from two premises." Although a syllogism may be formally valid and the two premises may not contradict one another, the conclusion of a formally valid syllogism may still be false because one or both of the premises is untrue. For instance:

God has created everything that exists; Christ exists, therefore God created Christ.

I believe we can all see how the syllogism "makes formal sense" if both the premises are assumed to be true, but the conclusion is false because the first premise is false; the first premise is this, God has created everything that exists, the second premise is, Christ exists. While the second premise is true, that Christ does exist, the first premise is false, God did not create everything that exists...God exists and He did not create Himself!

Another concept we encounter as we engage others in matters of debate is that of contradictions and paradox. These two concepts are easily confused; sometimes persons think an idea or two premises are contradictory when they are actually only a paradox.

First, let's examine the two terms:

1. Contradiction - This literaly is a combination of two words, contra (which means against), and diction (which comes from the Latin word - dictio - which means words, speech, or to speak), so the word contradiction means - to speak against. The law of non contradiction states that "A" cannot be "A" and non "A" at the same time and in the same relationship. Aristotle put it this way, "one cannot say of something that it is and that it is not in the same respect and at the same time".

2. Paradox - On the other hand, a paradox (a compound word combining the idea of coming beside and speaking well of) is the combination of two or more premises which appear to be contradictory on the surface, but with further clarification (perhaps with the introduction of another premise) investigation may result in the combination's exoneration of the charge of contradiction. For further definition, this word comes from the Greek word, paradoxos which means seemingly absurd or, contrary to expectation. Below, I will use the example of a particular car and its characteristics to demonstrate the difference between a contradiction and a paradox.

And now, imagine a car, half of which is red, half of which is blue.

Premises Developed About The Car

True premises:
  1. The car is blue

  2. The car is red.

  3. The car is blue and red.

False premises:

  1. The car is not blue.

  2. The car is not red.

  3. The car is not blue & red.

If this was my car and it was not in view, but I attempted to describe it to you, I could state any of the 3 true premises as fact. It would be a statement of truth if I told you that my car was red. It would also be a statement of truth if I told you that my car was blue. It would also be a true statement if I told you that, my car was red; my car was blue, hence the paradox: the car is red, and the car is blue, at the same time; both statements are true and do not contradict one another because the car is painted half red and half blue. A contradiction would occur if I told you that my car was red; my car was not red, at the same time and in the same relationship.

Monday, September 24, 2007

Eight Revealing Questions: Questions #3 & #4: Installment #5

Revealing Questions Concerning the Will of God Over His Creation:
Installment number five: Question #3

In the following discourse, I have also answered the next question in this discussion as well, question #4, Why do I choose what I choose? The answer to this is very simple as it was answered in installment #4 as we discussed question #2, I choose what I want to choose, well...because I want to; because that is my strongest desire.

The primary question to be answered in this installment is this: can I be forced to choose something I do not want? Ultimately I would say no, not if I have the capacity to do that which I desire. Following are three examples used to illustrate this point.

a. Perhaps one day I decide I would like to fly by my own power, no assistance, no wings, and no devises. Right up front we must acknowledge the fact that I do not have the capacity of unassisted flight and my shear willing it to happen is unrealistic and irrational. So if two choices are before me, under normal circumstances I will always choose that which I most strongly desire; that to which I am most strongly inclined. But this situation is abnormal. Nearly every kid has at one time or another wanted to simply jump into the air and fly. He may even have a very strong desire to fly. However, he may not legitimately choose that which only seems to be his strongest desire because he is not capable of choosing it. He may have a powerful inward desire to fly but he is incapable of inclining himself to fulfill it. This leads us to a consequent question, can one actually desire most strongly, that for which he has no natural capacity? I may have a strong inclination toward flying, but I have no empathetic understanding of its mechanics, thus I do not understand what it would really mean to fly; I am not actually aware of the work and effort that would be involved, therefore I do not actually desire to fly, but what I desire is my understanding of what flying is. I desire a caricature of flying, but not flying itself. So I conclude that one cannot most strongly desire that for which one has no natural capacity to do or to even understand. I call this the futile wish, and it is most probably relegated to the human race and a condition of the fall, as a consequence of our depravity, because we know that we will not be able to desire anything we cannot do or have in the eternal state with God. Perhaps Hell, at least in part, consists of eternally unfulfilled futile wishes and unsatisfied desires.

b. The second example is only slightly different. Imagine being tied to a chair by an abductor. This illustration tries to answer the question, what if I can’t do what I want. This example illustrates both a lack of capacity and a conflict between what I call contiguous desires, or desires that appear to be very close in intensity or strength, with a nearly inappreciable difference. In this situation, you would obviously have a very strong desire to be free. On the one hand, you may actually be able to free yourself from the chair when your abductor turns his back or leaves the room but the success of this venture may result in having to pull one of your wrists out of socket, or cut off your hand by vigorously rubbing it against the cords with which your hands are tied. So your choice now is between your desire to be free and your desire not to remove your hand. Even these choices lend themselves to a degree of capacity—can you actually pull your wrist out of socket, will the cord cut through your hand, or can you twist your arm enough to pull your hand off at the wrist. If you are able to do either of these things, would you desire strongly enough to do so, or would your desire to not pull your wrist out of socket, cut it or pull it off out weight your desire to be free? Even if you are able to free yourself in one of these ways, you must also consider what would happen next. Will you bleed to death from your wounds? Once you are free from the chair will you then be able to defend yourself with such a handicap? At this point (assuming you can break free by removing your wrist) and weighing all these nuances together, it becomes more a matter of discretion than capacity. Though you have a very strong desire to be free from the chair you choose not to remove or dislocate your hand because keeping your hand intact in the end was a stronger desire than your desire to free yourself in that way. Though you very much want to be free, your stronger desire is to leave your hand attached to your arm, so in the end you chose the strongest between several contiguous desires, thus the rule was not violated—you were not actually hindered from doing that which you desired most strongly, it only appears so because, of the choices you had, the two strongest desires were so close in strength, but in the final assesment you chose according to your strongest desire, thus you were not made to choose something you did not want to choose.

c. Here is the third example which describes how we all choose accoding to our strongest desire and we are never compelled to choose something outside of our nature, thus we remain volitional creatures as God has created us:

Imagine I am driving down the road with every intention of taking a right at the next stop light however, as I sit in line waiting for the light to turn green a man jumps in the back of my car and while holding a gun to my head he demands that I turn left at the light and insists that he will kill me if I don’t do as he says. I now have an added element in the choice I would make. Had the man never jumped in my car I would have turned right because that is the direction I most strongly desired to go. But now, because of the threat to my life (which will end up being a determining cause in my choice) I choose to turn left. Does this mean that I have done something that I did not want to do? While I would have had the desire and the capacity to turn right at the light, my stronger desire was to save my life by turning left. Because of the introduction of another efficient cause (the threat to my life) the formal cause (my motivation) was altered, thus the conflict was no longer simply between turning left or right. The conflict would then have been between turning right (as I initially intended) and turning left in order to preserve my life. Because I more strongly desired to preserve my life than to turn right, I fulfilled my stronger affection toward one of two contiguous desires by turning left. So again, I surmise that I cannot ultimately be forced to do something that I don’t want to, and I cannot actually desire that which I have no capacity to do.

For a little background, a philosopher named Aristotle lived in the 4th century BC and was the teacher of Alexander the Great, and the student of another prominent philosopher named Plato. It was in that environment where he developed the "four causes of nature" as an answer to the question: why does anything exist rather than nothing? I used these ideas to help answer the question in the previous paragraph. The four causes are these: material, efficient, formal, and final.

1. The material causes of my choice to turn left were the things that had to exist for my choice:
my existence, the road, the intersection, etc.

2. Some of the efficient causes for my turning left were:
the threat to my life, the place I want to go, etc.

3. Some of the formal causes were:
all the motivating causes like, the gunman and my desire to preserve my life,

4. The final causes for my choice to turn left:
my stronger desire to turn left over my weaker desire to turn right, and ultimately, and at the same time, God's decree for me to turn left.

Thursday, September 20, 2007

The Seed of Substitutionary Atonement is Sown in the Soil of Covenant Theology

Preface

The truth of the substitutionary atonement is at the very heart of the gospel, and this truth cannot exist consistently except in some degree of the acceptance of federal theology; a theology that affirms Adam's failed representation of the entire human race in the covenant of works as our federal head, and Christ's successful representation of the elect as a fulfillment of the covenant of works, also as our federal head.

From the beginning (Genesis 3:15) redemptive history has foretold the coming of The Seed of Abraham, Jeshua ha Messiah, God among us, The Anointed One, The Holy One of God, the Christ through the prophetic Word of God and that history has also shown all of us pictures of this Coming One through: the types and shadows of Old Covenant symbols. So even Adam and his immediate posterity had, through God’s curse of the Serpent, the gospel, a promise of good news and ever since then, God by His merciful grace has progressively revealed to the world this Jesus through His special revelatory work.

Perhaps most eloquently summed up in the words of Paul to the Corinthians, substitutionary atonement is described this way: “For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.” (2 Corinthians 5:21). So the idea invested in the term substitution is that Christ did not merely do this thing for us—so as to only set an example, or to us—so as only to provide the foundation for a righteousness which in us would inhere. Certainly He did do it for us and eventually by His Spirit, to us, but not only that, He has done this thing in our place so we would not have to, and because we could not do it, even in the slightest. Substitution is that doctrine which teaches that, because of our deadness to spiritual things, Christ obeyed the commands of God’s Law perfectly—for us and in our place; He fulfilled the Law in every respect, and He endured all the wrath of God that would be due every elect individual had God not predestined them to good works and glory.

Covenant Theology

Christ came as the second, or last Adam (1 Corinthians 15:44-46); in that passage, Paul shows us the progression of the “two Adams” from the natural to the Spiritual. Christ fulfilled the covenant of works on our behalf—in our place. That which Adam failed to do in the covenant God made with Him, Christ succeeded in doing by His life of perfect obedience and His death of satisfaction which in turn displayed the intentions set forth in the covenant between The Father and Son and Holy Spirit for redemption. In the quote below, John Owen speaks of this eternal covenant:

“The will of the Father appointing and designing the Son to be the head, husband, deliverer, and redeemer of his elect, his church, his people, whom he did foreknow, with the will of the Son voluntarily, freely undertaking that work and all that was required thereunto, is that compact (for in that form it is proposed in the Scripture) that we treat of.”

The Covenant of Works

The covenant of works, or the covenant of life some have called it, is that covenant made with Adam and through which God offered life to Adam on the basis of Adam’s obedience to the law which God had revealed to him. The conditional nature of this covenant can be summed up in the formula, “Do this and you shall live”. Much like the covenant God made with Israel’s representative head Moses on Mt. Sinai, God promised Adam life if he obeyed, if he would not eat of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil; conversely, God promised to curse Adam and his posterity if he did not live up to the stipulations of that covenant. Before Adam had fallen, as he had been created by God, he had the ability to sin and the ability to not sin. Augustine of Hippo termed his state in Latin as, posse peccare, posse non peccare. We know Adam had the ability to sin because he did sin. We know that Adam had the ability to not sin because God created man and said His creation was very good; God created Adam and Eve holy and happy as the catechism says. We know that Adam failed to uphold the stipulations of this covenant but that Christ fulfilled them.

The Covenant of Grace

God made another covenant with man, this time with the man Abraham specifically and the promises of this covenant are to all his seed in Christ. We call this covenant the covenant of grace, and this covenant is unconditional. We know by the comments God made to Abraham in Genesis, and the nature of the cutting of the covenant itself that, God intended to fulfill the stipulations of this covenant on our behalf. As a luminous picture of this trans-historical covenant, God commanded Abraham to take his only son Isaac, his heir, heir of the promise to the top of Mount Moriah to sacrifice him on an alter for worship. Unknown to Abraham, God had prepared a substitute for Isaac. So after that day, Abraham and all subsequent generations of redeemed individuals are called to look upon this picture and see, first: that God the Father sacrificed God the Son on the cross, and that the knife blade that was raised to cut us off was stayed, we were loosed and taken down off the alter and Christ was bound, beaten, and cut off in our place.

The Grand Inconsistency

When those who have no idea what covenant theology is or those who berate covenant theologians co-opt the concept of substitutionary atonement, they do so at the expense of inconsistency in their own systems (or lack thereof). The inconsistency is this, that many who have rejected the covenantal view of redemptive history: that Christ merited the grounds of our justification by being the substitute Law-abider; He did this by meeting the stipulations of the covenant of works, the same covenant Adam failed to fulfill thus plunging his posterity into death, consequently will normally support a "Dispensational" system: that God relates to men in different economies of time by giving them specific revelation, conditions which they (even though by God's grace) are required to meet in order to please God and thus the end of such an economy usually occurs near the time when God determines that the stipulations of His special revelation of law has been adequately violated and/or disregarded, yet dispensational theologians still embrace the doctrine of substitution even though they largely reject the idea that a particular covenant and the trans-economical continuity thereof, was made with Adam (wherein he represented the entire human race) which he disobeyed as our representative, and that Christ (being the "Second Adam") obeyed all the stipulations of that covenant as our representative and effected redemption for His people. So you see that the idea of substitution grows out of the covenantal concept—Christ obeyed for us the covenant that Adam disobeyed for us. On the contrary, historic dispensational theology obviously does not sow in the soil of federal theology, nor do they have the grounds to systematically affirm Christ’s work as our substitute in covenant with God. I suppose in one sense this inconsistency is good, I'd rather see many redeemed and inconsistent evangelical dispensationalists who dislike "Covenant Theology" proper (for whatever reason) but who love the reformed doctrine of substitution than to see many consistent evangelical dispensationalists who reject, in hatred, the idea of substitution.

Saturday, September 15, 2007

On the Taxonomy of Terms in Historical Theology:

The definitions of a few fallacies :

A common example of a straw man fallacy is one used by Arminians and anti-Calvinists alike, frequently charging Calvinist with the teaching that God drags the elect kicking and screaming to their predestined position in Christ; because we say man is dead in trespasses and sins and does not seek after God and that the redemptive grace of God cannot ultimately be resisted, then therefore, God drags those He had elected into the Kingdom against their will. Likewise (as the straw man goes) we teach that there will be persons in Hell who desired God and obeyed Him but God didn't save them because they were not numbered among the elect. Nothing could be further from the truth ans no Calvinist would say (or even draw the conclusion systematically) that God drags persons into the Kingdom kicking and screaming—so the anti-Calvinist builds up a “straw man” (the conclusions with which straw men are made, even their Calvinistic opponents would disagree) which can be knocked down with ease, QED, the Calvinistic position is wrong...so goes the straw man argument.

A red herring fallacy is where someone side-steps the real issue. For instance, I can discuss the points of historic Calvinism with my non-Calvinist friend and, inevitably he will bring up the “fact” that Calvin had persons burned at the stake for not believing as he did, thus everything Calvin taught is invalid. All historical absurdity and misrepresentation aside, we need not conclude that Calvinism is formally invalid because of this objection—in fact, my friend’s argument is formally invalid because he has not dealt with the issues Calvinism raises biblically, nor has he accurately represented the history of Calvinism or John Calvin himself but instead, he has introduced information that has no relevance to the validity of Calvinistic doctrine.

The fallacy of equivocation is where one changes the definition of terms mid argument, and it might look like this, I say to my dispensational friend that, because we are made the children of Abraham at our rebirth, the Church is the Israel of God and he replies by asserting that, because we do not become ethnic Jews at our spiritual rebirth, the church is not the Israel of God. We can see that the term being equivocated is the "Israel of God". I have made no indication in my statement that I am talking about the physical, ethnic nation of Israel, in fact I have qualified my use of the term in question by stating that we are Abraham's children but my friend redefines the term thus rejecting my premise due to his faulty argumentation.

Another, perhaps clearer example of equivocation is this: non-Calvinists agree that the bible calls the unbeliever dead in his trespasses and sins, but they also say that the unbeliever is not so dead as to be rendered incapable of seeking God. In this example, the equivocation occurred in the word "dead". It is one thing to say that the unbeliever is dead in his trespasses and sin, we all agree on that, but to assert that the same dead man is capable of seeking and even choosing God in his state of deadness is to redefine the meaning of dead as contextually defined in the first premise and thus formally invalidates the non-Calvinist's position on the deadness of the unbeliever.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

On the Taxonomy of Terms in Historical Theology

I have recently had some time to consider the fact that the historical definitions of the theological terms within a debate are not necessarily paramount on the mind of its participants. I don't mean to say that I have never been guilty of this negligence, but I would like to believe that in the past five years or so, as I have studied and strongly debated amongst friends the issue of Calvinism (more specifically—monergism versus synergism) I have developed a greater sensitivity to the importance of historical definitions in the taxonomy of theological distinctions. In his book, Getting the Gospel Right, R.C. Sproul has this to say, “Words are the key to knowledge. They are a form of the science of taxonomy or classification…The simple process of such classification, which is the root of all knowledge, is the process of noting similarities and differences.”

Taxonomy is contextually defined in the Sproul quote as the study of similarities and differences, and that is the differences between two or more words, and for our purpose it is the similarities and differences between two or more words/terms which symbolize (or describe) theological dogmas or concepts.

Words are like symbols, and on a “molecular” level they are in fact made up of the combination of smaller symbols—letters. Can you imagine a world of debate, instruction, or apologetic endeavors where the participants of that debate or the author of that polemic decided that the historical use of the symbols (or the letters) of the language in which he was writing were not so important, or worse—irrelevant? No one would understand what he trying to say; he would have to define (or redefine) every combination of symbols—terms—that he was trying to use to prove a point. That sounds absurd I know, but it is very much the same as what takes place when someone engages in a theological debate and is either ignorant of the historical theology that surrounds the issues or worse, he decides to disregard the proper historical use of those terms and import his own meaning, and this may be done for various reasons. One instance of this is provided in a book written by Norman Geisler called, Chosen But Free, wherein he labeled historic Calvinistic belief as “extreme” or “hyper” Calvinism, and took the classic five points of Calvinism and so redefined them as to appropriate their revised meanings and then he referred to himself as a “moderate Calvinist”. But in his fallacious process of equivocation, Geisler only co-opted the names of the five points to describe the same old, popular non-Calvinism in a different way; in an attempt to avoid what he referred to as “extreme” Calvinism and “extreme” Arminianism, he instead adopted another extremity—extremely fallacious argumentation.

I realize the example above is extreme in degree, but in the present American theological climate it is wide spread in its sort. In Geisler’s case, he was not only partly ignorant of the way Calvinism had been historically defined (or simply incapable of understanding how it had been described in the sources he chose to research) he also rejected that definition to serve whatever his motivations were. The point I am trying to make is that when one neglects or refuses to understand the historical categories and terms that surround a presently debated theological topic, or they do understand the historical theological issues but decide to ignore them, then they will inevitably commit the “straw man”, “red herring”, “equivocation”, and “false dilemma” fallacies, thus rendering their own arguments invalid.

As we employ the historical understandings of current theological debates (because we know that, even if one generation rejects heresy it does not mean that it will not be recycled by the next—though not all debates are between heresy and orthodoxy, sometimes there are intra-orthodox debates) we must be careful not to argue fallaciously ourselves; we must not make an “appeal to history” as a sole proof of orthodoxy because we know that the Word of God is our only authority in doctrine and practice, nor should we ignore the evolution of definitions, understanding that over time the meanings of words do have a tendency to change; we must differentiate between classical and current definitions of a word. But this evolution happens quite slowly and gradually, and one’s awareness of historical theology is not an option—it is imperative! Even so, there will always be those who, for whatever poorly examined reasons, wrongly reject history (particularly in the forms of creeds and confessions) in the defense of sola scriptura, and who opt for a “macro-evolutionary” or “inter-special” approach to the definition of terms over time.

Tuesday, September 11, 2007

Eight Revealing Questions: Question #2: Installment #4

Revealing Questions Concerning the Will of God Over His Creation:
Installment number four: Question #2

If the answer to the first question, “does God know our future choices” is yes, then the second question is begged, were our choices really free? To adequately answer this question we must define what is meant by “choices” and by “free”. Briefly, our choices encompass all the decisions we make, whether as individuals or part of a larger cooperation; the actions we determine to take and all our preceding ruminations regarding the action—action being defined as some sort of speech or movement. The word free may herein be defined as the ability and necessity of making a choice based on our desires and affections. Thus we are free to choose according to our desires, so it could be said that we always choose freely, according to our greatest desire, and our desires are necessarily limited by our capabilities, whether mental or physical. Consequently, the puritan Jonathan Edwards wrote broadly on this very topic in his work, “The Freedom of The Will.

Over against the Reformed/historical (and I think biblical) view of God’s providence, we sometimes hear explanations like this, “Well, we know that God could have created a world in which He retained His sovereign control over the will of man but we know that He decided to withhold His sovereign reign over the will of man and His choices in order to establish human culpability and to protect Himself from being charged with evil. The evidence for this is the fact that evil exists at all.”

So the answer to question two is yes, God can and does know what I will choose and the choices I make are also free, because my freedom is established (not denied) by the fact that I choose according to my strongest desire; my choices are governed by my affections. As a mater of fact, I always choose based on my strongest inclination. My will not only influences my decisions, it (in the immediate sense) determines them. The fact that I always do what I want also establishes the compatibility between God’s ordination and knowledge of my future choice and the freedom of my choice. Remember Genesis 50:20:
As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good, to bring it about that many people should be kept alive, as they are today.

In that verse we see how Joseph’s brothers did as they pleased, they desired to sell Joseph into slavery; they were not forced to do so. At the same time, God had ordained all those events and meant them for good; so we can see that the same event can be purposed for wickedness by evil men, and purposed for good but a holy God. So God has done as He pleased and accomplished what He had determined from before the foundation of the world, not acting in response to what Joseph’s brothers had done, and Joseph’s brothers freely chose to act upon the evil intentions of their hearts, thus human freedom (the ability to choose according to our desires) and God’s sovereign ordination are compatible.

Wednesday, September 5, 2007

The Fama Dei of Politicology

In academic or scholastic theological circles, we speak of the “three legs of the theological stool”: historical theology, biblical theology, and systematic theology. I am suggesting another category, which may or may not fit under or along side one of the three legs as a category or sub-category. I must also note that I have not fully researched and studied the distinctions I just mentioned, so if there is a name which exists to describe the following, then I am not aware of it and I ask your forgiveness because I may be repeating the work of previous generations.

First things first, what in the world does “fama Dei” mean? Fama is a Latin word which means public opinion, talk, report, rumor or tradition. According to the definition given by the Online English to Latin dictionary sponsored by the University of Notre Dame, the Latin word fama means, “fama -ae f. [talk , report, rumor, tradition]; 'fama est', [there is a rumor]; [public opinion; standing in public opinion, repute], good or bad.” Dei of course is a derivative of the Latin word for God, so the term fama Dei literally means talk, rumor or public opinion about God. I will use the term to more specifically describe what may have been previously studied as “popular theology”, and I may use the two terms interchangeably; so the term in this context can be taken to mean, the widely accepted and public opinion about theological issues.

Another and more specific way to put it is this—the popular, “Christian” opinion of a particular doctrine (including the biblical interpretation from which the doctrine is derived and its application in practical life). What I mean in the previous definition by “Christian” is—all those who call themselves Christians; and are those who have likely been counted in a “Barna Poll”. An example of an American (and perhaps wider) fama Dei of end times would be that, because ethnic Israel is a political state God is preparing the world for its end. Another simple example would be the current, popular theology of alcohol which is, that Christians don’t drink it. In other words, one could often say that fama Dei, or popular theology refers to what the World thinks “Christians” think about topic “x”; so it is different than orthodoxy—which largely reflects the consensus of what actual Christians actually believe about a particular doctrine in a particular generation—in that it is instead, a consensus of ideas about a doctrine held by believers and unbelievers that may or may not be true, and may or may not be held by actual believers.

Perhaps a more complex example is the fama Dei of political “involvement”; the research and study of political positions and ones implementation of the resultant views into life and practice—and for this complicated concept I may use the term, politicology. So, politicology would refer to political science, and its application; the study of: government, political affairs, and affairs of state, governmental policy, political beliefs, opinions, principles and views and also the necessary, subsequent adaptation of those issues into ones psyche which, consciously or not, one uses to filter information and opine about every topic encountered.

While not being healthy in the body of Christ, it is quite popular these days, at least on American soil, for one to falsely equate the political movement called Conservativism (or even Republicanism) with Christianity, denying the possibility of a Christian Democrat or a Christian who does not fit easily into the mold of popular Conservativism—many would say that the two are quite contrary, thus they must be contradictory. While it is true that some doctrines widely held by the Democratic Party so alienate them from Christian theology that it makes the promoters of such dogmas not Christians, or at best very immature Christians. Of course I am speaking, in one case, of the policy of “choice”; the woman’s right to kill the baby with which she is pregnant, this teaching is contrary to Christianity all together and it must be said of one who holds that abortion is not a sin is thus not a clear thinker; they either are not thinking clearly about Christ, therefore they are not Christians in the first place, or they are not thinking clearly about abortion, therefore they hold to a contradiction in their view of reality. That aside, the fama Dei of politicology (specifically the American type) is: pro war, pro family, and pro death penalty, pro free firearms distribution, pro Israel/ anti Palestine, and anti abortion, etc. It must be said that some of these planks are right and are Christian and some of them must be held by the one who aims to please Christ, but my point is that the fama Dei of politicology is that Christians are by definition, well-to-do American Republicans.

It is not uncommon today to see a Baptist, or a “fundamentalist” Christian pastor, or in some cases even a Presbyterian man in the political spotlight today. The popular theology of politicology has escaped the bounds of simple interest in the lives of many Christians today. One would find it difficult to turn on the TV or radio and discover a Christian program that wasn’t focused in some way on the political application of our inheritance with Christ. In some small way I place the blame on our dispensational brothers, who have so emphasized the earthly aspects of the inheritance of those in Christ, or have confused the promises of the Mosaic covenant with the promises of the New covenant, that the Kingdom of God is the Kingdom of man on God’s behalf, that their focus has unfortunately been relieved of Christ’s Kingdom by the kingdom of the perishing; the kingdom of this world.

The right and true ordinances given to us by the Lord Jesus Christ Himself were Baptism and the Lord’s Table, both physical pictures of the spiritual reality of our citizenship in the everlasting Kingdom of heaven. While many ecclesiastical leaders today would (not formally of course) have us to ultimately become, citizens of the Kingdom of American, or democratic freedom, worshiping the idol of capitalism through the sacraments of:

  1. Voting (like baptism it is an identification with the “right” party) and
  2. Boycotts, with which one practices communion with the greater good of Conservativism; it is an expression of being together with a group; fellowship in the rejection of the same things; “...we are all together against the same worldly evils...”, and so on.

It is easy to see that this view of Baptist and communion are not born out of the covenantal understanding of the ministries ordained by God but their understanding arises from a false interpretation of symbol, one which sees baptism as little more than an outward and visible expression of a prayer which was recited some time before, and one which sees communion as a simple rejection of perceived “sins”, but not real sins, just the rejection of conventional taboos—whatever they may be; a rejection of the common, subjective moralistic code instead of adherence to the objective Law of God. In the absence of true Law, some ruling force must come into power to frighten the people, and we must set aside a time to commemorate our agreement upon these surrogate rules by our consumption of the tactile symbols of Christ’s work, we somehow mysteriously acknowledge that we are capable of living up to them, but we haven’t, and that is why we should repent. (There is heavy sarcasm here if you didn’t notice).

In the end, in order to counteract the fama Dei of politicology, I think we need a new fundamentalist. Not like the first, like Machen, who countered the liberals who were his contemporaries, but one like Jesus, who countered the pharisaical hypocrites. What we need is a “neo-fundamentalist movement” which will counter the “religious right” and the so called, “conservative Christian” with the objective Law of God, which will also counter the moralistic, conservative, republicans in Christian clothing with the gospel of Jesus Christ, and may the Lord either soften their hearts with salvation or so harden them so that we may easily tell the difference. It is the meek who inherit the Earth, not those who possess political savoir-faire.