Romans 5:7-9

For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.

Thursday, December 13, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #12: The Types & Shadows of Christ: A discussion of Hebrews 7:13-24, & 28

The Types and Shadows of Christ

Hebrews 7 (continued)

13 For the one of whom these things are spoken belonged to another tribe, from which no one has ever served at the altar. 14 For it is evident that our Lord was descended from Judah, and in connection with that tribe Moses said nothing about priests. 15 This becomes even more evident when another priest arises in the likeness of Melchizedek, 16 who has become a priest, not on the basis of a legal requirement concerning bodily descent, but by the power of an indestructible life.

In this portion of the passage it is apparent that Christ is made our High Priest outside of the normal ordinance; He did not come from the regular line of earthly priests.

17 For it is witnessed of him, "You are a priest forever, after the order of Melchizedek." 18 On the one hand, a former commandment is set aside because of its weakness and uselessness 19 (for the law made nothing perfect); but on the other hand, a better hope is introduced, through which we draw near to God. 20 And it was not without an oath. For those who formerly became priests were made such without an oath, 21 but this one was made a priest with an oath by the one who said to him: "The Lord has sworn and will not change his mind, 'You are a priest forever.'" 22 This makes Jesus the guarantor of a better covenant. 23 The former priests were many in number, because they were prevented by death from continuing in office, 24 but he holds his priesthood permanently, because he continues forever.

The Oath

The “witness” mentioned in verse 17 is David, found in verse 4 of Psalm 110, and the oath mentioned in 21 we also find in a quote from that Psalm. This Psalm of David justifies the statement made later, in verse 28 that, “the word of the oath, which came later than the law”; the oath as stated in verse 21 came after the establishment of the ritual covenant stipulations of Moses, which pointed to Christ. The priests under the Old Covenant did not have an oath—in other words; they did not receive the promise to continue forever in their duties, not as individuals; neither did their office receive the promise of permanence.

The Former Commandment

The “former commandment” in verse 18 refers to the order of Levitical priesthood under the Mosaic Covenant. How is it set aside, well the preceding verses have quite clearly told us that when Christ came, this former commandment (because of its uselessness and weakness to accomplish the deeds of the Substance it symbolized) necessarily had to be trumped by the eventual establishment of the Permanent High Priest it shadowed—the “Better Hope” which was introduced to draw us near to God; though God’s wrath was stayed by those sacrifices, no one’s sins were propitiated by them, thus no one was drawn near to God by the rituals of the Old Covenant.

The Better Hope

The Levitical priesthood (in all its historical import and usefulness in pointing to the coming Messiah) was too weak to do what the real High Priest can do—mediate for us with clean hands, having no sin which needed covering; the High Priest makes us perfect but the Levitical priest only pointed out our imperfection, covering the people temporarily by their duties; the best they could do was to symbolize Christ in that office. On the other hand, the “Better Hope” was given an oath, a promise that He would one day become that High Priest forever.

Hebrews 7

28 For the law appoints men in their weakness as high priests, but the word of the oath, which came later than the law, appoints a Son who has been made perfect forever.

Calvin again, on verse 28:

"28. For the law, etc. From the defects of men he draws his conclusion as to the weakness of the priesthood, as though he had said, “Since the law makes no real priests, the defect must by some other means be remedied; and it is remedied by the word of the oath; for Christ was made a priest, being not of the common order of men, but the Son of God, subject to no defect, but adorned and endowed with the highest perfection.” He again reminds us, that the oath was posterior to the law, in order to show that God, being not satisfied with the priesthood of the law, designed to constitute a better priesthood; for in the institutions of God what succeeds advances the former to a better state, or it abolishes what was designed to exist only for a time."

Christ was made a high priest by the Father, and his position is forever. Do you think it is proper to interpret the bible, and to systematize the theology of a Mediator between us and God in such a way that there will one day be an earthly high priest (for whom the offering must also be made) in the position of making offerings for Israel while the real High Priest is on Earth in their presence? I think it does great damage to the meaningfulness of the shadow and substance relationship to have both in concurrent operation. Certainly Christ will not put a moratorium on His high priestly activities in any future era so that the old ways can be reinstated; if Christ ever suspended His high priestly activities we would all certainly perish. As we have seen, through the contextual interpretation of the Word, and as we must conclude, the Levitical priest who assumes the old, cultic rituals of the Old Covenant after Christ has come in the flesh to put those things away, his "worship" and "mediation" will be a foul stench in the nostrils of God.

In the passages above there is no indication of a restoration of the type or the shadow which will work as an ordained memorial. Again, I must ask, how would the supposed future, human high priest view these scriptures in a millennium wherein his duties contradict the very meaning of these passages in Hebrews? Meditate on the dispensationalists claim that there will be a "cooperation" of the high priest appointed by the Law and the perfect High Priest made with an oath, and I will discuss that topic later as I plow through Hebrews 8.

Tuesday, December 11, 2007

Bob Dylan Quote & My Comments

Below is a quote from a Bob Dylan song.

"Yes, 'n' how many times must the cannon balls fly
before they're forever banned?
The answer, my friend, is blowin' in the wind,
the answer is blowin' in the wind."

Normally, Dylan rejected any attachment to a particular social movement: the hippy movement, the folk movement in music, etc. On many occasions he even claimed that there was no real deep message invested in the lyrics of his songs, and that most of his audience takes them too seriously. Even though that claim itself is considered by his fans to be satirical, it was obvious that he did not intend for his lyrics to be co opted as a rally cry by any organization or organised movement.

All that being said, I do want to comment on the underlined portion of the lyrics I quoted above. It certainly is a noble desire to have wars and conflicts end, in fact it is one that I share. Dylan released this song on the 1963 album titled, "The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan", this was a tumultuous time in American history: the civil rights movement, the death of the President in November, and about one year earlier, several nations (the US included) signed an agreement to insure the neutrality of Laos, and the conflict in Vietnam had been escalating since 1959, so it is clear to see how his environment ( a nation being polarized by a clash in cultures and the threat war) might have fueled such lyrics. Unfortunately, though the sentiment is valid, the argument disguised in the question, "...how many times must the cannon balls fly before they're forever banned?" is utterly unrealistic. This lyric makes me ponder the reality of original sin, and the falleness that typifies the world in which we live. Imagine a world where the government was united under one state head; lead by one body of legislators to create laws, and one body to carry them out worldwide. Imagine that this world government does ban the "cannonball", the problem is that, the very governing body which bans them must exempt themselves so as to be invested with the power to weld cannonballs themselves to prevent anyone else from doing so...I'm thankful that, even in this fallen world, by the common grace of God, He granted the fathers of our country the wisdom to decide that each citizen (with some necessary exclusions) has the right to bear "cannonballs". Unfortunately, the world in which Dylan made his plea is not the one in which his dream could come true, in fact, the banning of cannonballs would inevitably lead to the tyrannizing of the entire world under the government of fallen men which make fallen laws.

Fortunately for those redeemed by Christ, they will live in a future world, redeemed even of the cannonball. If the answer is truly "blowing in the wind", as Dylan suggests, then that Wind must be the Holy Spirit.

Thursday, December 6, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #10: The Types & Shadows of Christ: A discussion of Hebrews 4

The Types and Shadows of Christ

Hebrews 4

8 For if Joshua had given them rest, God would not have spoken of another day later on. 9 So then, there remains a Sabbath rest for the people of God, 10 for whoever has entered God's rest has also rested from his works as God did from his.

We must first understand that the way that God has determined to relate to His creation and creatures through out all of redemptive history has been through covenant. These covenants are specifically noted in scripture by the nature of the language used to describe how God has determined to either, condition the distribution of His blessings or to grant these blessings out of His own beneficence and because of His own accomplished Holiness. The former (which would include the covenants He made with Adam and Moses) resembles the type of treaty that kings and rulers made with people how would benefit from their relationship only if they fulfilled whatever stipulations the king had set up. The covenant was “cut” by the blood sacrifice of an animal and the two parties would pass between the severed halves, in essence saying, that if we do not uphold our part in the covenant, this which has happened to these animals will happen to us, it was the same for the recipients and the king; if either party didn’t fulfill those obligation placed on them, a severe consequence, often referred to as a curse, would befall the offending party. The later (which would include the covenant made with Abraham, David, and the New Covenant) resembles the type of “royal grant” which a king or ruler would grant unilateral blessing because of his gracious character and never dependant on the obedience of its recipients. In these cases, a substitute sacrifice would be made to “cut” the covenant and represent the means by which any offence to the king by the recipients would be justly absolved. In this type of covenant the beneficiary alone places the warning of curse on himself. Imagine the first covenant is like the relationship between Americans and our government, as long as we keep the stipulations of the law then we benefit from the protection of the government. The later type of covenant is more like a convicted felon receiving a presidential pardon.

Negative Polemic – What this passage doesn’t mean

I think the first thing to do as we discuss this passage is to define the “them” who are spoken of here. I believe that some have suggested that those spoken of here are the ethnic Jews with whom God will take up once again, the Mosaic economy some time in the future, thus fulfilling the land promises made to Abraham. Misunderstanding and confusing the two covenants, these men claim that what God promised to Abraham, He eventually started to fulfill in the covenant with Moses but upon Israel’s disobedience they were punished in exile and when Christ came as their Messiah to offer the kingdom to the nation of Israel they rejected Him so God brought salvation to the gentiles because of the disobedience of ethnic Israel and also to make them jealous. Though some of these views are true, it is nevertheless wrong to consider the “them” spoken of in verse 8 exclusively as ethnic Israelites. We have the full revelation of God from which to draw as we consider our interpretation of Old Testament passages and their reference in the New Testament. If we develop a comprehensive understanding of these covenants and their promises as we bring New Testament verses in to bear on their meaning we will come to the conclusion that the people being referred to by the author of Hebrews in this passage are the seed of Abraham, the true circumcision; this group spans all of redemptive history. That is why he can say that, “there remains a Sabbath rest for the people of God", and the Sabbath rest is that rest which is inaugurated in Christ’s first appearance and which will be consummated in His second coming.

Positive Polemic – What this passage does mean

I think that the actual point of Hebrews 4:8 is to say that Joshua did not give the people rest, at least not ultimate rest. Joshua in this verse (and as an historical person) represents the means by which God had Israel enter the physical land; the land is often referred to as a place where the people of God will find rest, but the physical land that was given by Joshua did not give the people rest upon their entry and it will not give a day of rest to anyone—in fact, once they entered the land they still had to keep the whole law in order to stay there—that is no rest at all. We find a striking similarity in the creation account where God establishes a pattern of six days of work and then rest. Take that rest for instance (a rest I believe to represent one of the blessings of the covenant between God and Adam), it was at the end of 6 days of work; God worked six days and then rested as if to say that, if Adam fulfilled the covenant obligations: don’t eat of this tree, then he would rest from his work at the end of the fulfillment of his obligations. The promise of rest is conditioned upon his obedience, an obedience for which God doesn’t say “I will fulfill the obligations of this covenant for you so that I may grant the covenantal promises to you.” This day of rest is not a future day when the nation of Israel will acquire rest in the physical land by having God fulfill the promises of the Abrahamic Covenant because of their obedience to the stipulations of the Mosaic Covenant. Actually, it is a future day of rest when God, because of Christ’s obedience to the stipulations of the Covenant of Life, fulfills the Abrahamic promises to his children in eternity.

Christ in all of creation

Even after the fall we get a vivid description of the covenant God made with Adam (the covenant of life) in creation—in the general revelation of God, there is no provision for the eternal salvation of the soul; no promise of resurrection; no grace for justification, in that revelation only law is presented which shows us that God exists and that His holiness condemns us—For this creation order, God instituted the seven day week, six days of work with the promise of rest on the seventh. In the Mosaic covenant, which was a reiteration of the covenant of life—not the covenant God made with Abraham. In the Mosaic Covenant, God instituted many Sabbaths, one of which was weekly—all of these Sabbaths ultimately point to the rest we find in Christ; they are types and shadows of Christ who is the archetype and substance. The fascinating thing is that point when the church, after the cross, changes the weekly day of worship to the first day of the week. So now we have a picture of a seven day week where the first day is a day of rest and then six days of work are to follow. I believe that this format pictures the conditionality of the Mosaic Covenant in which the first order of weekly Sabbath was set up—six days of work and then a day of rest; “Do all of these things and I will bless you”. But the opposite is true for the members of the New Covenant, the order of the weekly Sabbath was to begin with a day of rest and then go out to work the other six days, as if to say to the partakers of the New Covenant that, because you enjoy my spiritual rest you will indeed do good works as an identification of character. The circular nature of this cycle exposes the present need that all God’s children have to renew their faith in Christ every week, even daily in personal reading of the Word, but also in a special way once a week with the people of God where He meets us audibly in the proclamation of the Word and tacitly in the proclamation of His blood and body.

The Abrahamic Covenant

The Abrahamic Covenant was very much one sided, God cut the animals in two and passed through them, God granted the promises and blessings of the covenant to Abraham and his seed because God Himself, in Christ, would fulfill the stipulations of the covenant. Understand that there were stipulations in that covenant, good works are demanded to be sure, and repentance and belief are the full revelation of those stipulations, but it remains unconditional because Christ fulfilled all the righteous requirements of God and His righteousness was “counted to Abraham before he was circumcised”, and because of the gracious unconditional nature of the covenant, Abraham’s subsequent love of God and ultimate desire to please Him (however small) was guaranteed. So, instead of “do this and you will live…” we hear, “I will do this, and you will live”; in the Abrahamic covenant we hear about another day later on to which the author of Hebrews refers. So my conclusion is that the later day is the day of Christ’s appearing, a day which was inaugurated in His incarnation and will be consummated in His second coming, when “the people of God” will find their ultimate rest.

I think that dispensationalists would disagree that there is an overarching theological interpretation of the Bible which suggests that the Old Testament saints never fully understood the meaning of many of the prophecies. Yes, as the Dispensationalist would agree, there was an historical grammatical interpretation to be understood; the prophecies did mean something to the Old Testament saints, but they often misunderstood their true meaning because God didn’t fully reveal it to them—there was yet a future, spiritual meaning to many of those prophesies. So in hindsight, the prophesies made in the Old Testament have great meaning for all who read them because they are telling the story of redemption, they are not simply subject to the historical grammatical interpretation. The pattern we actually see regarding revelation and our understanding of it is this: prophesy then fulfillment, and then understanding. Because I can’t say it any better, I quote Sam Waldron below,

“It is also relevant to note that a comprehensive hermeneutic must take into account the necessity of a theological interpretation of the Bible. The Bible has both a divine and human authorship. Historical-grammatical interpretation goes no further than the human authorship. It asks only what the original human author might or could have meant by what he wrote. The Bible affirms for itself in addition divine authorship. While what the divine author meant in any given passage will not contradict what the human authors meant, it must be obvious that the intention of the divine author could go considerably beyond what the human author meant or could have meant."

This theological interpretation may be what is sometimes referred to as the “analogy of faith”—scripture is keen on its own interpretation and the later revelation in time is profitable in the interpretation of the former.

The Second London Baptist Confession of Faith, Chapter 1, Sections 9 & 10

“The infallible rule for the interpretation of Scripture is the Scripture itself, and therefore whenever there is a question about the true and full sense of any scripture (which is not manifold, but one), it must be searched by other passages which speak more clearly.
The supreme judge, by which all controversies of religion are to be determined, and by which must be examined all decrees of councils, opinions of ancient writers, and doctrines of men and private spirits can be no other than the Holy Scripture, delivered by the Spirit. And in the sentence of Scripture we are to rest, for it is in Scripture, delivered by the Spirit, that our faith is finally resolved.”

Wednesday, December 5, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #9: Who are the partakers of the New Covenant?: A discussion of Jeremiah 31

Who are the Partakers of the New Covenant?

Jeremiah 31


31 "Behold, the days are coming, declares the LORD, when I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and the house of Judah, 32 not like the covenant that I made with their fathers on the day when I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt, my covenant that they broke, though I was their husband, declares the LORD.33 But this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, declares the LORD: I will put my law within them, and I will write it on their hearts. And I will be their God, and they shall be my people. 34 And no longer shall each one teach his neighbor and each his brother, saying, 'Know the LORD,' for they shall all know me) from the least of them to the greatest, declares the LORD. For I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more."

This passage is pregnant with meaning. A couple things that are clear from a quick look are that: it is a prophecy of an event future to the writer, and it is a different covenant from the one God made with the people when He brought them out of Egypt (the Mosaic Covenant); it is “new” in reference to the covenant that I made with their fathers on the day when I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt.

Possibly the largest hurdle for a theologian steeped in Dispensational tradition to get over is the fact that the New Testament authors apply the term “Israel of God” to a group that includes ethnic Jews and Gentiles, and above is probably the prime Old Testament reference; located in verse 33 it is stated this way, But this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, declares the LORD. Prominent preacher and defender of the truth, John Macarthur said in his recent diatribe against Covenant Theology at large and Amillennialism specifically, that we can never understand references to the house of Israel or Judah as ever meaning anything but the physical form of those houses as being primarily represented by ethnic Jews. At this point, I would like to direct you to a work that has been done online: the chapter in Sam Waldron's book regarding John Macarthur's misrepresentation of Amillennialism called "The Israel of God" is helpful information here as well when he considers the New Testament understanding of the Church as the elect remnant. I don’t believe that I could answer Macarthur’s or any other form of dispensational objection to the covenantal use of the term in the New Testament any better that Dr. Waldron has already done.

In Luke 22 Christ uses the cup of wine in the upper room as a picture of the cup of God’s wrath which He must drink on the cross—Christ drank it and we must partake of Christ, so as a sacred meal which signifies the body and blood of Christ, we do the same until His return to renew our faith in the invisible Word by the visible means of the covenant meal. We can appropriate this for us today because when Christ instituted the meal, He referenced Jeremiah 31 in the gospel account: Luke 22:20 And likewise the cup after they had eaten, saying, "This cup that is poured out for you is the new covenant in my blood. In his first letter to the Corinthians, Paul then interprets the gospel accounts of this event for us, 1 Corinthians 11:24 and when he had given thanks, he broke it, and said, "This is my body which is for you. Do this in remembrance of me." 25 In the same way also he took the cup, after supper, saying, "This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of me." 26 For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord's death until he comes. So Christ institutes the sacrament of communion for New Covenant members, then Paul places us into the group of New Covenant members by applying this institution to us.

In chapter 8, the writer of Hebrews quotes the entire passage from Jeremiah 31 regarding the New Covenant and names Christ as its mediator. So with Christ as it’s mediator, and with the way the New testament speaks of “the Israel of God’, the “true circumcision”, and Abraham’s offspring” as inclusive of all races, Christ’s declaration to His disciples that the New Covenant is in His blood, and with Paul’s application of communion to Christians today, we can safely say that the New Covenant (spoken of through the prophet Jeremiah) is a covenant God made with all believers. This covenant was confirmed on the cross; the cutting of that covenant spanned millennia and it most certainly does include all those who believe. Even though the prophet spoke of the house of Israel and the house of Judah, we must understand that the correct interpretation of those houses expands far beyond the historical/grammatical and goes (like all prophecy) into the redemptive historical “meta-narrative” and, in the broad sense, God would have us to understand through the Scriptures, that those houses included all those who believe and who are counted righteous in Christ.

Well, if you are a Dispensationalist you might want to call that Replacement Theology, and that term might be accurate if what was being said by Covenant theologians was that, the group (of which all believers in this post incarnation age are included) to whom this new covenant is made are getting the promises that were made to the people who God brought out of Egypt because they were unfaithful, and that God decided not to fulfill those promises He made through Moses to the nation of Israel, but instead He “replaced” them with another group, one which would certainly obey; if that was what Covenant theologians were saying, then the term "Replacement Theology" might stick. The fact remains that Covenant theologians have not, are not and will not say that. The unconditional promises made to Abraham will certainly be kept, and they will be kept with those to whom God always intended— Abraham’s seed, those in Christ; so God remains faithful. Those promises were not the same as the conditional promises which were made to Moses and the people who God brought out of Egypt—they broke the covenant and thus God did keep His promise to curse those in that covenant for corporate disobedience, the promises made to Abraham were never intended to be fulfilled through, and were not reiterated in the Mosaic Covenant, instead, the promises made to Abraham and his offspring (as stated very clearly in Romans 4) did not come through the law but through the righteousness of faith, so that the beneficiaries of those promises are all of those who have faith, either in the coming Messiah or the Messiah who came, thus God can say through Paul that His promises have not failed because not all who are descended from Israel belong to Israel, so there are Israelites who will not be saved, and an “Israel” who will.

As I have heard it described by Kim Riddlebarger, one of the hosts of “The White Horse Inn”, it may be helpful to think of it this way, there could have been an ethnic Jew under the Mosaic Covenant who was personally obedient to the law of Moses and who was enjoying the blessings that were afforded to that covenant (enjoying milk and honey in the promised physical land) but who, at the same time, was a child of God’s wrath because he was without faith. There also could have been an ethnic Jew whose family was killed in the Babylonian invasion and who was carried off into exile and captivity, and who was no longer able to keep the temple laws but who, at the same time, was a child of God who would eventually enjoy the rest of Christ in the promised spiritual land because of the real sacrifice of Christ and because of his faith in that future Messiah, thus in eternity he would worship by the real Temple which is Christ Himself.

Friday, November 30, 2007

Riddlebarger's Recent Blog Article

Below is Kim Riddlebarger's (one of the hosts of the White Horse Inn) recent blog article on Eric Clapton's autobiography.

Providential Perspectives

Regardless of God's revelation to us, our perception of God is bound up in time; the fact that our senses and perceptions are limited by our temporal existence is perhaps a reminder that men's descriptions of God are always abstractions of the reality of God’s being—we can’t help it. In the same way, a photograph—however realistic—is still an abstraction of the reality which it attempts to represent.

Below is a quote from Mike Horton's "God of Promise

"While much of the debate over God's sovereignty and human freedom turns on endless speculation about philosophical possibilities, the covenantal structure of God's relationship to creaturely reality is a much safer and profitable resource. The covenant is always the site where the Great King and his servants are recognized for what they are: unequal partners with their own way of existing, knowing, willing, and acting--one as Creator, the other as creature."

We must all be very careful when we meditate on the knowledge of God and how He has that knowledge. I am aware that we have Scriptural precedence to delve these depths somewhat, by those precedence are also boundaries.

On the Absence of Confession

It is one thing to say, as a Christian, that "I'm not confessional". A surface understanding of such a statement would have most of us take it to mean that the person does not hold strictly to one of the historic confessions, Heidelberg, Westminster, London Baptist, Savoy, New Hampshire, etc, but it is another thing all together to say that Christians need not confess their sins. Though the discussion of that type of confessionalism involves a great deal more, it is not what I ran into on the truthtalklive blog yesterday. No, over the past couple days I have been engaged in a discussion under the heading of, "How Do You Reach Your Jewish Friends for Christ?". My involvement began when I heard the host on Tuesday November 27, 2007 use the pejorative term, "replacement theology" and immediately following, the guest mention the atrocities (and they certain were that) welded by the hands of those who held to that theology in the past.

If you have spent any time reading this blog you would probably have noted that I am a covenant theologian who used to be a disepnsationalist. Now, the guest last Tuesday, a believer who is Jewish, does not refer to himself as a dispensationalist but the conversation that ensued on the blog under the same title as the radio show does have a participant who calls himself a "Classic Dispensationalist", after the tradition of Darby and Chafer.

The most shocking of the tenets to which he holds, born out of his system of Dispensationalism--which I 'm sure he would confess--was that, Christians don't need to ask forgiveness for their sins because that forgiveness has already been bought. You can look at the blog yourself to read the interaction. The Classic Dispensationalist referred everyone to two websites that represent his view, WithChrist.org and realanswers.net.

One thread of the discussion in particular involved 1 John 1:9, and in the link above, realanswers offers an explanation which you can read for yourself.

The last thing I want to do is call the salvation of these individuals into question, but I do believe that the system called Classic Dispensationalism has very little in the way of scriptural accuracy to offer the Church. I hope that you will take a look at their work on 1 John 1:9 and contrast it with the orthodox view below

Here is a reasonable exegesis of 1 John 1:9 offered by John Gill.

"Ver. 9. If we confess our sins,.... Not to one other; for though it is our duty to confess our faults to our fellow creatures and fellow Christians which are committed against them, yet are under no obligation to confess such as are more immediately against God, and which lie between him and ourselves; or at least it is sufficient to confess and acknowledge in general what sinful creatures we are, without entering into particulars; for confession of sin is to be made to God, against whom it is committed, and who only can pardon: and a man that truly confesses his sin is one that the Spirit of God has convinced of it, and has shown him its exceeding sinfulness, and filled him with a godly sorrow for it, and given him repentance unto salvation, that needeth not to be repented of; and who, under such a sight and sense of sin, and concern for it, comes and acknowledges it before the Lord, humbly imploring, for Christ's sake, his pardoning grace and mercy; and such obtain it: he is faithful and just to forgive us [our] sins: forgiveness of sin here intends not the act of forgiveness, as in God, proceeding upon the bloodshed and sacrifice of Christ, which is done at once, and includes all sin, past, present, and to come; but an application of pardoning grace to a poor sensible sinner, humbled under a sense of sin, and confessing it before the Lord; and confession of sin is not the cause or condition of pardon, nor of the manifestation of it, but is descriptive of the person, and points him out, to whom God will and does make known his forgiving love; for to whomsoever he grants repentance, he gives the remission of sin; in doing of which he is faithful to his word of promise; such as in Pr 28:13; "and just"; in being "true", as the Arabic version adds, to his word; and showing a proper regard to the blood and sacrifice of his Son; for his blood being shed, and hereby satisfaction made to the law and justice of God, it is a righteous thing in him to justify from sin, and forgive the sinner for whom Christ has shed his blood, and not impute it to him, or punish him for it; though the word here used may answer to the Hebrew word qydu, which sometimes carries in it the notion and idea of mercy and beneficence; hence mercy to the poor is sometimes expressed by righteousness; and the righteous acts of God intend his mercies and benefits unto men; see Da[n] 4:27; and so forgiveness of sin springs from the tender mercies of our God, and is both an act of justice and of mercy; of justice, with respect to the blood of Christ, and of pure grace and mercy to the pardoned sinner: the following clause, and to cleanse us, from all unrighteousness, is but the same thing expressed in different words; for all unrighteousness is sin, and to cleanse from sin is to remove the guilt of it, by an application of the blood of Christ for pardon. The antecedent to the relative "he" in the text, is either God, who is light, and with whom the saints have fellowship; or his Son Jesus Christ, who is the nearest antecedent, and who, being truly God, has a power to forgive sin."

Now I want to offer a few practical observations of my own.

If believers have no need of confession or "asking forgiveness", then in what way--if any--is God displeased with our sins as believers? If God has forgiven us by the cross of all the sins we will ever commit as Christians in such a way that no application of forgiveness is necessary when we sin, then the sins we commit as believers can not be displeasing to God at all, because He has already set His displeasure for those sins on Christ in the past, therefore God NEVER chastens His children because that chastening has already been accomplished in Christ.

As for Old testament believers, when God saved them, would the Classic Dispensationalist say the same thing about their life of sanctification, that they too had no need to ask forgiveness when they sinned as believers? If so, then why would Christ have told His disciples--being Old Testament saints--that they needed to ask their Father in heaven to forgive them?

Classic Dispensationalism confuses the aspects of personal atonement: regeneration, justification, and adoption. Regeneration has to do with being reborn and being made spiritually alive; justification has to do with being made right in light of God's Law, and adoption has to do with being brought close to the inheritance.

Classic Dispensationalists also tend to confuse our redemption accomplished and redemption applied. When God regenerates us he applies the righteousness of Christ to us by faith, but confession is the means of the application of Christ's work to us by faith, daily--in sanctification.

Thursday, November 29, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #8: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Romans 9

Who are the Children of Abraham?

At last, the final installment regarding the above question…

Romans 9

4 They are Israelites, and to them belong the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the giving of the law, the worship, and the promises. 5 To them belong the patriarchs, and from their race, according to the flesh, is the Christ who is God over all, blessed forever. Amen. 6 But it is not as though the word of God has failed. For not all who are descended from Israel belong to Israel, 7 and not all are children of Abraham because they are his offspring, but "Through Isaac shall your offspring be named." 8 This means that it is not the children of the flesh who are the children of God, but the children of the promise are counted as offspring. 9 For this is what the promise said: "About this time next year I will return and Sarah shall have a son."

Verses 4 and 5 set up the obvious Jewish question, “if the gentiles can be saved apart from being made a physical Jew (through the ritual of circumcision) and an observant of the ceremonies and Sabbaths, then what of the promises of God to the Jews (those who are observants)?” We see here in the question assumed and the answer given by Paul that, the Jews had believed that those to whom the promises of the Mosaic Covenant were made were the Children of Abraham, thus they receive those promised blessings. That is why they asked if the promises of God had failed, because Paul was telling them that just because they were born into the Mosaic Covenant they were not necessarily going to receive the promises of God for eternal life—rest in the land. Paul’s answer is this, God has not failed because the promises made to Abraham were never made only to the ethnic Jew but have always been for the spiritual offspring of Abraham not his physical offspring.

Paul is speaking specifically of his kinsmen according to the flesh. He reminds all the members of his audience that the adoption, covenants, the giving of the law, the worship, and the promises belong to his kinsmen (the Jews) but the belonging mentioned here is not the belonging of exclusive possession, the idea he is pursuing here is that all of those things had been disclosed in history through their culture and practices. The Jews no more owned those things as their exclusive possessions than they owned Jesus Himself, but there obviously is a sense in which all those things did belong to the Israelites (because it is in the text and the NASB translates it the same). It is in fact the same sense in which Christ belongs to the Jews. So the dispensationalist might argue from verses 4 and 5 that the fulfillment of the entire collection of covenant promises that God made belong exclusively to the Jews; the physical nation of Israel, but we can see that this argument would be invalid because of the nature of Paul's use of this statement and further reasons we will now explore. Another fact to be seen here is that the “belongings” Paul mentions in verse 4 are all parts of the Old Covenant that God made with Moses on Mount Sinai. The promises that Covenant Theology says are attributed to all believers are the ones made to Abraham in that unconditional covenant.

In what I believe was a moment of clarity, one day I read through this passage again, and having the debate over dispensational and covenant theology loosely fit in my mind, I read verse 6 and heard Paul say that, though all the things mentioned in the few preceding verses belonged to the Israelites, and understanding that not all of the Israelites were “in Christ” and that they remained under the thumb of the Roman empire even after their Messiah had come, God’s word had not failed! For Paul to make such a statement we must assume that is what many mistaken Jews were thinking and even expressing in their frustration. As I read this statement for myself once again, I was struck by the absence of the obvious dispensational explanation Paul should have given at this point. Shouldn’t Paul have inserted his thoughts in Romans 11 at this point; had the manuscripts been mixed up? Certainly not! I think that if Paul had believed that God’s “primary” plan has always been with ethnic Israel and His plan with the church was just a parenthesis within this plan, then he would have finished verse 6 this way: “It is not as though God’s word has failed—He has not put away His people forever. Because you did not receive Him as your king, He has sent your Messiah to save the gentiles as well, but He has not forsaken His chosen people, He has only postponed His dealing with you and He will resume it when He is finished dealing with the church”. But Paul doesn’t do that, instead of proving God’s faithfulness by reassuring the ethnic Jews of God’s future dealing with them, he proves God’s faithfulness by telling them their physical ancestry is not the issue, it is their spiritual ancestry; not all who are physically descended from Israel are spiritually descended from Israel; not all who are physically descended from Abraham are spiritually descended from Abraham…it is not the physical nation of Israel who are the children of God, but it is the spiritual nation of Israel who are His children.

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Sanctification by Faith Alone

Sanctification is the fruit of justification; it is the byproduct, not the end.

I think it was Warfield who said that the only victorious Christian life that has ever been lived was that of the Lord Jesus Christ. I agree with that assessment, and with that in mind, why do we still have a great majority of the visible church fighting in an intramural wrestling match, if you will, to gain various crowns which represent the fulfillment of promises that God has actually made to ALL believers; to every member of His elect body?

Many (at least American believers) have been sold a poor bill of goods which includes the idea that once we are saved we must then maintain God's favor toward us by obedience to His commands. This flies right in the face of grace and works itself out in at least two ways:
  1. When we sin we lose our justification and we must repent and be saved once again.
  2. We remain saved when we sin but our disobedience is actually punished in eternity by loss of possible "rewards" .

The first option, in my estimation, is barely Christian at all. I do insist though that there are Christians who hold this view and defend it theologically (not just traditionally) but it is also important to recognise the far reaching implications of such a theology. It goes back to one's understanding of what happens at regeneration/conversion/the new birth; the reformed view states that at that event, an individual is "counted righteous"--he is justified in the eyes of God because of Christ's accomplishments. If this view is correct, then how strange it would seem to have God justify an individual on account of what God did on the cross only to have that individual later "unjustify" himself by breaking God's Law?

The second opinion, although much more palatable to the Christian tongue, is strangely misguided about the faithfulness of God to keep His promises to His people and about just what promises were fulfilled in the cross; further, this opinion accentuates the desire for eternal rewards besides God Himself--I believe that when the desire for these rewards outweigh our desire for God Himself, it is idolatry.

Conclusions:

At the moment of our justification we are counted righteous before God. Beside our sanctification, also procured by faith, what more could one really want? It is God's faithful distribution of His benefits to us that fuels our sanctification even after He has graciously justified us. It is not the fear of the potential loss of our crowns or of our salvation that should drive us to obedience but rather, it is the reiteration of the gospel that should drive us to delight in Christ; Christ raised for us, our newness in Him; sin no longer has dominion over you, therefore your obedience only makes sense. The gospel creates faith, and the sacraments of communion and baptism present the gospel tactily for the strengthening of our faith--the faith through which we were once justified and through which we are continually being sanctified.

The Law could never save us, and obedience to the Law is also never the road to sanctification, but the destination...the road of sanctification is also the gospel road.

The Law could not justify me and it also cannot sanctify me.

Sunday, November 25, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #7: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Ephesians 2: Part Two

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Part 2 of the discussion of Ephesians 2

I submit that, if at any time in the future a physical temple is set up and sacrificial worship (as either an honorarium or memorial) is reinstituted, then that building and those sacrifices will be a blasphemy to Christ. If dispensationalism is correct in claiming that the ceremonial laws, rights and rituals of the Mosaic Covenant (the Old Covenant) will be reinstituted, then shouldn’t the sign of circumcision as a sign of corporate covenant obedience also be reinstated? And if so, then this teaching flies in the face of the Word of God that the Holy Spirit delivered through Paul, to the Galatians.

Galatians 1

6 I am astonished that you are so quickly deserting him who called you in the grace of Christ and are turning to a different gospel— 7 not that there is another one, but there are some who trouble you and want to distort the gospel of Christ.

Galatians 2

3 But even Titus, who was with me, was not forced to be circumcised, though he was a Greek. 4 Yet because of false brothers secretly brought in—who slipped in to spy out our freedom that we have in Christ Jesus, so that they might bring us into slavery— 5 to them we did not yield in submission even for a moment, so that the truth of the gospel might be preserved for you.

I believe that the advocate of a future temple Judaism must endorse a sort of digressive revelation because the whole of the New Testament is just that, a new testament, or a new covenant, and the old has passed away. Is it suggested that in this future epoch the words written to the Romans, the Galatians, in the book of Hebrews and elsewhere are voided? No, I’m certain no self respecting dispensationalist would say so, but how else is such a view of the temple supposed to be interpreted? Paul was obviously chastening the Galatian church because they had been fooled by false brothers that obedience to Old Covenant rituals was part of sanctification, and in the worst cases, part of justification—Paul called this another gospel; he didn’t say it was another preference, he didn’t say that they were simply imprudent, he called the Galatians fools! The new covenant plainly brings the Jewish man and the gentile man together in one group, not separated by ceremonies, ritual sacrifices, moons and Sabbaths, but identified together with Christ, and this is accomplished in a better covenant. Are we to believe that in God’s plan for redemptive history, He made a covenant with Abraham (which he planned to fulfill in Christ) then He had the old covenant set up to picture the coming Messiah, which would be put aside for the better, new covenant which was in Christ’s blood (which would eventually begin to see fulfillment in Christ) only for the new and better covenant to later, also be put aside so He could finish what He had only begun with ethnic Israel in the old covenant? I know that to say that the reinstitution of circumcision, ritual sacrifices and the temple will be for a memorial appears to be a clean and sharp answer that dispensationalism gives when it attempts to answer the critique of future animal sacrifices after Christ has been sacrificed himself, (once and for all, as put in the book of Hebrews), but it is neither clean nor right; you don’t have to have a memorial for a person who is not dead, and especial not for a person who is alive and who is in your presence.

The ordinance of communion is what Christ told us to practice until He returns, and what of the Jew in that dispensational future who reads the Word and hears Col. 2:16 Therefore let no one pass judgment on you in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath. 17 These are a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ, or the words of Romans 4, Galatians 3, Hebrews 8, etc? The Jew in any future age will been given no authority subsequent to the writings of the New Testament to make him believe that those words will not also apply to him, but only to those who had passed in the age before. I know that we, present, new testament saints look at the commands of the Mosaic ceremonial and civil law and say, “…that is not for us…”, though Paul and others must look at it the same way we do, unless we are to believe that God will reveal more words in later years.

You might say that those Jews have precedence for rebuilding the temple and reinstating temple sacrifices because of the words of Ezekiel and other texts tell them to do this in the future, but this denies the New Testament interpretation of Ezekiel in specific and the Old Testament as a whole. The problem for dispensationalism remains, that revelation is progressive and there are many New Testament texts that explain how we should understand Old testament texts—even if that understanding is that they are not to be taken "literally"—as dispensationalists count things literal.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #6: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Ephesians 2: Part One

Who are the Children of Abraham?

In this article I continue my attempt to answer the question once again posted above.

Part 1 of the discussion of Ephesians 2

11 Therefore remember that at one time you Gentiles in the flesh, called "the uncircumcision" by what is called the circumcision, which is made in the flesh by hands—12 remember that you were at that time separated from Christ, alienated from the commonwealth of Israel and strangers to the covenants of promise, having no hope and without God in the world. 13 But now in Christ Jesus you who once were far off have been brought near by the blood of Christ. 14 For he himself is our peace, who has made us both one and has broken down in his flesh the dividing wall of hostility 15 by abolishing the law of commandments and ordinances, that he might create in himself one new man in place of the two, so making peace, 16 and might reconcile us both to God in one body through the cross, thereby killing the hostility. 17 And he came and preached peace to you who were far off and peace to those who were near. 18 For through him we both have access in one Spirit to the Father. 19 So then you are no longer strangers and aliens, but you are fellow citizens with the saints and members of the household of God,

Paul tells the Gentiles in the flesh (that is us) that we were at one time far off, but we have now by Christ, been brought near to the commonwealth of Israel, no longer strangers to the covenants of promise, and now having hope. The dividing wall in the temple which separated gentiles from Jews, even circumcised Gentiles from Jews, was broken down by Christ on the cross. It was a wall of hostility; a wall of violence which cause division and animosity between the Jews and the Gentiles; a wall which caused the Pharisees to hate the Samaritans. Paul tells us that this wall has been broken down because Christ abolished the law of commandments and ordinances, and He did this by fulfilling all righteousness and making the debt payment for sin which is death; Christ has fulfilled the consequences God demanded of us because of Adam’s failure in the covenant God made with that first man (not that in His victory Christ destroyed the immutable commandments of God) but rather, He destroyed the ordinances of that Old Covenant and thus God fashions the individual recipients of the New Covenant as new men—not like the old man in the Old Covenant, and not like the old man who was far off from the Old Covenant, but a new man who receives the benefits of the covenant God made with Adam and which He reiterated in the covenant He made with Abraham and which He now, finally and forever, has fulfilled by Christ in the New Covenant, in order to bring together in one new group, all of the saints through all time: those who before were strangers to and those who were familiar with the covenants of promise.

In light of the declarations in this passage, it is backwards to take the prophesy of Ezekiel’s temple and an interpretation of Romans 11 (which affirms some sort of future for ethnic Israel) to mean that, at some time in the future God will measure the obedience of the nation of Israel by their faithfulness to rebuild a physical temple, and sacrifice bulls and goats. Even if the purpose of this practice in a future age were only for memorial, the advocate must maintain that Christ is present and ruling on an Earth while the “people of God” are not focused on the substance to which those sacrifices pointed but rather, they would center their worship around the shadows and the types while the substance of the shadows and the archetype is there—it’s scandalous! Can you imagine trying to honor your brother in eulogy while he is still alive, and even in the same room? This is paramount to going to the beach and instead of gazing out into the vastness of the ocean to marvel at its size, you stand on the sandy shore, turn your back away from the ocean, pick up a seashell and put it up to your ear—proclaiming the greatness of the sounds of the ocean; smelling the shell and delighting in how much like the beach it smells; touching your tongue to the inside of the shell and likening its flavor to the salty taste of ocean water, when all the while the object to which the shell is only a sign, is right there before you. The pre-incarnation Saints only had the shell to lift to their ear to hear the echo of the waves; to lift the shell to their nose to see how the sea smelled; to taste what the salty sea was like by touching their tongue to the shell. Those of us after the birth of Christ can bask in the glory of the presence of the Sea itself and can stand before it and smell His misty waves as they crash on the shore, and we have the privilege of tasting the salty flavor of His waters in the flesh, and this is done in communion; not now nor at any time in the future will we trade that covenant feast for a lesser sign of physical sacrifice, but we will one day trade it for the physical presence of our Lord Himself.

Friday, November 16, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #5: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Galatians 4:22-26

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Galatians 4

22 For it is written that Abraham had two sons, one by a slave woman and one by a free woman. 23 But the son of the slave was born according to the flesh, while the son of the free woman was born through promise. 24 Now this may be interpreted allegorically: these women are two covenants. One is from Mount Sinai, bearing children for slavery; she is Hagar. 25 Now Hagar is Mount Sinai in Arabia; she corresponds to the present Jerusalem, for she is in slavery with her children. 26 But the Jerusalem above is free, and she is our mother.

Here Paul formally states what he said in the previous chapter of Galatians, that there are two covenants in mind: the one of promise and the one of flesh. Interestingly enough Paul uses an Old Testament text and allegorizes it to illuminate his audience to the fuller meaning of the text. Paul and his readers certainly believe that the two literal women existed in history and that the literal account of their lives was written down in scripture, but God had a bigger, fuller purpose with those women, and the events spoken of here are meant to do more than merely establish ancestral integrity or historical validity. So we have a contrast of two covenants, a tale of two cities, if you will:

Hagar ------- Sarah
Moses ------- Abraham
Sinai/Jerusalem ------- Heavenly Jerusalem (the Jerusalem above)
Slavery and law ------- Promise of Freedom
Flesh ------- Spirit
Sons of flesh ------- Sons of promise

There are two items in the study of this text that I believe argue against dispensationalism, and they are:

  1. Paul contrasts the blessings of the Abrahamic and Mosaic Covenants.
  2. Paul allegorizes the historical/grammatical interpretation of an Old Testament event.

It is my understanding that both of these items above are contrary to rudimentary dispensational hermeneutics, which states that the meaning of the Old Testament text to its then, contemporary audience is the only meaning of that text, thus rendering it the so called “literal” interpretation. Also (according to dispensational theology), the promises God made to Abraham (land and many seed) were reiterated and expanded in the Mosaic Covenant and given even more strenuous stipulations; and even today they have not been realized, thus they cannot be arrogated by the gentile/Jewish “Church” because God never made those promises to that group and He still plans to fulfill those promises of physical seed and land to a group strictly made up of believing Jews in the future in a literally physical way.

As I close this post, take a look at another statement that clearly associates Old and New Testament believers in the same covenant.

Philippians 3:3 For we are the real circumcision, who worship by the Spirit of God and glory in Christ Jesus and put no confidence in the flesh—

In Paul’s mind there were two circumcisions, one made with hands and one made by the Spirit (the real one). Obvious from more passages than can be listed, Abraham was of the real circumcision, and according to Galatians 3:29 we are Abraham’s spiritual children, but what makes us so? It certainly isn’t our physical Jewish heritage because in Christ there is neither Jew nor Greek. We are grafted into the Abrahamic Covenant and made fellow recipients of the promises thereof, because it is an overarching covenant, one which is ultimately fulfilled in the New Covenant and which affords gracious provisions for all of God’s children throughout the entirety of redemptive history.

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #4: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Galatians 3:7-29

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Galatians 3

I realize this is a very lengthy passage, but please bear with me—it is after all, Scripture.

7 Know then that it is those of faith who are the sons of Abraham. 8 And the Scripture, foreseeing that God would justify the Gentiles by faith, preached the gospel beforehand to Abraham, saying, "In you shall all the nations be blessed." 9 So then, those who are of faith are blessed along with Abraham, the man of faith. 10 For all who rely on works of the law are under a curse; for it is written, "Cursed be everyone who does not abide by all things written in the Book of the Law, and do them." 11 Now it is evident that no one is justified before God by the law, for "The righteous shall live by faith." 14 so that in Christ Jesus the blessing of Abraham might come to the Gentiles, so that we might receive the promised Spirit through faith. 15 To give a human example, brothers: even with a man-made covenant, no one annuls it or adds to it once it has been ratified. 16 Now the promises were made to Abraham and to his offspring. It does not say, "And to offsprings," referring to many, but referring to one, "And to your offspring," who is Christ. 17 This is what I mean: the law, which came 430 years afterward, does not annul a covenant previously ratified by God, so as to make the promise void. 18 For if the inheritance comes by the law, it no longer comes by promise; but God gave it to Abraham by a promise. 19 Why then the law? It was added because of transgressions, until the offspring should come to whom the promise had been made, and it was put in place through angels by an intermediary. 20 Now an intermediary implies more than one, but God is one. 21 Is the law then contrary to the promises of God? Certainly not! For if a law had been given that could give life, then righteousness would indeed be by the law. 22 But the Scripture imprisoned everything under sin, so that the promise by faith in Jesus Christ might be given to those who believe.

27 For as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ. 28 There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. 29 And if you are Christ's, then you are Abraham's offspring, heirs according to promise.


In this passage Paul refers to us, those of faith, as the Abraham’s offspring (v 29) because of our relationship with Christ—being in Christ; Abraham is the man of faith, and we are those who are of faith, and if Abraham’s offspring and heirs according to promise (v 29) then we are obviously part of the same spiritual family—now and in Heaven, in eternity because he is not referring to us as the physical descendants of Abraham, and if we are the offspring of Abraham, heirs according to the promise, then we are also sons of Abraham. If so, then by what line of reasoning can we conclude that we will be of a different group or family or kingdom in eternity? For further support that we are in the same group as Abraham consider that the blessing which comes to all the nations through Abraham was the same good news (gospel in v 8) that was preached to Abraham by the scriptures, which foretold of the gentiles being justified by faith and they are in the company of Abraham because he is the man of faith, not the man of law and not the man of circumcision. We are blessed along with Abraham, and this cannot merely be the blessing of physical land because that was the blessing of the Mosaic covenant. We know that our blessing is not limited to that of a physical place in an unredeemed earth, but our blessing, our inheritance is the redeemed Heaven’s and Earth, as Christ said, “the meek shall inherit the Earth”, so too must Abraham’s ultimate blessing be spiritual because, according to this passage we are blessed together with him.

Verse 16 tells us that Christ is The Seed of whom God was speaking to Abraham; the promise is to Christ, and those counted in Christ are joint heirs, thus receiving the inheritance promised to Abraham’s seed. But the question might be posed, “but the Law of Moses came after the covenant with Abraham so it must fulfill it or cancel it out, right?” But Paul answers this question by telling us that the Law, though it did come 430 years after Abraham does not annul a covenant previously ratified by God. These two covenants are separate and the promises of the covenant God made with Abraham are not appropriated when the stipulations of the covenant made on Mount Sinai are fulfilled or Paul would not have to answer the question about the law, and the question would not have been pressing in the minds of his contemporaries if they had not confused the two covenants. Paul does go on to explain that the Law is not therefore useless, but that it was put in place because of sin, and elsewhere, Paul tells us that the law points out the exceeding sinfulness of sin. Perhaps the phrase that best explains the existence of the law though the promises were received by faith is in verse 22, “But the Scripture imprisoned everything under sin”; that is what the Law did, it imprisoned all our works under sin so that it would be very clear that even our “good works” would not purchase the promises of the Abrahamic covenant for us.

Paul says that if the inheritance came through Law, then it can’t also come through a promise. In other words, if the covenant of Moses came to hold out the same promises as the covenant with Abraham, then its blessings and benefits are no longer by the promise, but by Law, and Paul maintains that this is not the case. So one of the conclusions we must make regarding verses 16-19 is that the promises made to Abraham were neither fulfilled or annulled in the covenant with Moses, but that the previous covenant continues and the Mosaic Covenant, though it was good to point out sin, was the parenthesis inside the timeline of the promise and fulfillment aspects of the Abrahamic covenant. Paul further explains the differences of the Mosaic and Abrahamic Covenants by contrasting one as law and the other as promise, not that they are fighting against each other, but that the Mosaic Covenant was never put in place to accomplish the same thing. The Mosaic Covenant was only ever typical of the Abrahamic Covenant. Though there may have been a temporal aspect to the promises made to Abraham, the greater fulfillment of them would be spiritual and granted unconditionally, and the blessings of the Mosaic covenant were strictly temporal and conditioned upon the corporate or federal obedience of the nation “…all this we will do.” (like the covenant God made with Adam, who was the representative of all). If the law (which was never given to provide life) had not imprisoned us in sin then life could not be given by faith alone in Jesus Christ. A few verses later Paul concludes the section by telling his listeners that there is no difference between Jew and Greek regarding the promise and blessing to Abraham because if you are in Christ then you are Abraham’s offspring because it is by promise, not by ethnicity or law or circumcision.

Monday, November 12, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #3: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Romans 4:9-12

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Romans 4


9 Is this blessing then only for the circumcised, or also for the uncircumcised? We say that faith was counted to Abraham as righteousness. 10 How then was it counted to him? Was it before or after he had been circumcised? It was not after, but before he was circumcised. 11 He received the sign of circumcision as a seal of the righteousness that he had by faith while he was still uncircumcised. The purpose was to make him the father of all who believe without being circumcised, so that righteousness would be counted to them as well, 12 and to make him the father of the circumcised who are not merely circumcised but who also walk in the footsteps of the faith that our father Abraham had before he was circumcised.

In all of Romans 4 Paul is talking about how Abraham’s faith was given to him before he obeyed any stipulations that God had set up in a covenant; faith even then was the instrument God used to rescue individuals from the wrath to come, not the individual’s personal piety or obedience to the “rule of life” for that particular dispensation—salvation has never been granted any other way by grace alone, through faith alone, in The Christ (future or come) alone.

Covenantal obedience in Romans 4 is specifically characterized by the act of circumcision. In the Apostolic age the gentile Christians might have questioned their legitimate claim on a Jewish Messiah, but in Paul’s letter to a gentile city and church, he writes about how faith is given apart from or before the obedience to a peculiar Jewish custom—which in this case was circumcision.

The peculiar act of circumcision pictured the curse by which God Himself would be defecated if He did not uphold the unconditional promises He made to Abraham in that covenant. It was a sign of the animals cut in two when God “cut” that covenant with Abraham, and a seal to all the children of Abraham afterward that God would remain faithful, not that all those who were circumcised were the spiritual children of Abraham, but that it pictured the promises God made to him and his offspring, thus the removal of his foreskin is typical. On the cross, Christ was “cut off” in the place of Abraham and all his spiritual children. He was the cut off foreskin in the place of those who couldn’t fulfill the law for righteousness. It was a strange ritual, but it makes sense when you consider the nature of the promise, that it would come through Abraham’s Seed (Christ), to Abraham’s offspring (those counted “in Christ”). The misunderstanding of many, because it was formerly a mystery, was that the spiritual blessing that came to Abraham and will come to his offspring through Christ is not only for those who were circumcised in the flesh, but for those who were circumcised in their heart; those who were and are spiritually circumcised, and Paul establishes his claim by telling us that Abraham was counted righteous before he was circumcised, not after, and the purpose of God doing it in that order was so God could count both the physically circumcised and the physically uncircumcised righteous—by faith alone, not by faith plus circumcision. Just consider the harsh words Paul had for the Galatians.

Furthermore, if Abraham is the Father of all those who have faith and are counted righteous, then he is obviously in the same redeemed group as all of those who are counted righteous; all those who are counted as his children. He cannot be “the father of all who believe without being circumcised” and at the same time, the member of a completely different group in eternity. Paul places Abraham in the same group as all who believe (circumcised or not); who “walk in the footsteps of the faith that Abraham had before he was circumcised”.

In Galatians 3:29 Paul calls all of those in Christ Abraham’s seed or offspring. We can logically and biblically equate the term “Abraham’s offspring” with the term, “children of Abraham”. Every redeemed person is counted in Christ instead of being counted in Adam, and if counted in Christ, then counted as the seed or offspring or children of Abraham. How then can anyone say that Abraham is the father of all of those in Christ, and yet he is not part of that same eternal group? We cannot!

Thursday, November 8, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #2: Who are the Children of Abraham?: A discussion of Romans 2:26-29

Who are the Children of Abraham?

Romans 2

26 So, if a man who is uncircumcised keeps the precepts of the law, will not his uncircumcision be regarded as circumcision? 27 Then he who is physically uncircumcised but keeps the law will condemn you who have the written code and circumcision but break the law. 28 For no one is a Jew who is merely one outwardly, nor is circumcision outward and physical. 29 But a Jew is one inwardly, and circumcision is a matter of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the letter. His praise is not from man but from God.

Three statements must first be made: the Jews in Paul’s day considered themselves the children of Abraham by virtue of their covenant relationship through Moses and Sinai; for Paul, “keep[ing] the precepts of the law” is the same as one having been regenerated, which is the same as one having had the law of God written on his heart; and last, those “who have the written code and circumcision” are those to whom Moses gave the Decalogue; the members of the Old Covenant; those who in Paul’s day, considered themselves Jews exclusively.

Paul clarifies here what God has been doing throughout history: that which was once veiled as a mystery but is now revealed more clearly after Christ (the Lamb of God, the Seed of Abraham) has come, that the ethnic Jew (the Jew by sole virtue of his family heritage) is not necessarily the one blessed to receive the promises of God even if, along with that heritage, he obeyed the stipulations of the Mosaic covenant and received some of the physical promises of God with the covenant community as a whole but rather, the true Jew is the one who is circumcised of heart, not just circumcised of flesh; the one who has the precepts of the moral law written on his heart by God’s elective work, not the one who only obeys the precepts of the civil and ceremonial law of Moses as a member of the Old Covenant community.

When Paul mentions circumcision here he is referencing the outward obedience to the Mosaic Law, which is why he draws the contrast between the one who is merely circumcised and the one who has the law inwardly; the one who has had the law written on his heart; that one is the one who is regarded as actually having been circumcised.

Having the law written on the heart of an individual, as is mentioned in Jeremiah 31, is not the futuristic portion of that prophesy, the future aspect of it was that one day, all those in the covenant God has made will have the law written on their hearts. There were many under the Old Covenant who were members of that community but who had not had the law written on their hearts, likewise there were individuals in the Old Covenant who did have that law written on their hearts—they were saved, they were born again—but the law had not been written on the hearts of the community at large. One day in that New Covenant, all its members will have that blessing; all of those covenant members will be the spiritual children of Abraham. We will discuss this a bit more when we deal with the Jeremiah passage in particular, as we attempt to answer the question: who are the partakers of the New Covenant?

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation #1: Introduction

I am beginning a series on my thus far accumulated thoughts on the dispensational system and why I think the bible teaches otherwise. I am dreadfully aware of the controversy that might result from the title alone, but to call this series by any other name would be to betray the very nature of its content.

There will be four major sections in the series:

1. Who are the Children of Abraham?
2. Who are the partakers of the New Covenant?
3. The types and shadows of Christ
4. A few exposing questions for dispensationalists

I look forward to any discussion which may result from this series and I pray that my rhetoric is not hurtful and in no way misrepresents those from the dispensational camp.

Discussion on this topic has been all the rage this year and I believe it was kicked off by John MacArthur’s polemic against Amillennialism at this year’s Shepherd’s Conference. Many blogs are still periodically posting articles relating to the topic, even though the frequency has diminished. I do see much of what has transpired in the last 7 months or so as useful (excepting the harshness of some of the discussions) and I agree with John Piper when he says in his book, Contending for Our All, that, “The witness of church history is that seasons of controversy have often been seasons of great growth and strength.”, and as he wrote concerning Athanasius’ stand for the deity of Christ that, “Without controversy there would have been no gospel, and therefore no church.” J. Gresham Machen also spoke wisely about the controversies of his day, “Every true revival is born in controversy, and leads to more controversy. That has been true ever since our Lord said that he came not to bring peace upon the earth but a sword.”

So with that introduction behind us, let’s delve into the realm of controversy and pray that a revival might break out locally and abroad.

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

An Illustration of the Concurrence of Our Plans and God's Plans

This morning I considered an illustration of the way our wills and choices coincide with God's will and eternal decrees.

I work in the design field where I am drawing on a daily basis. We often find ourselves tracing over the lines of an existing drawing using tracing paper (a translucent paper). With that in mind, imagine that the lines of the existing drawing are the lines of God's decree; the lines of God's eternal plan. Now imagine that the tracing paper represents the Word of God, so we are suppose to interpret God's plan through the tracing paper (the Word of God). As we trace the lines on the existing drawing, because we are imperfect and affected by the curse, we don't see through the tracing paper as we ought, so we sometimes misinterpret the lines on the existing drawing underneath, thus we often do not trace over the lines properly. The less understanding we have of the scriptures, the thicker the tracing paper seems to be and in that case it is more difficult for us to see the lines of the existing drawing through the tracing paper.

So it also is with the concurrence of our plans and God's plans. Often, we lay out our plans on the tracing paper without tracing over the lines of God's plans because we do not see them clearly, but God's plans exist objectively and they do not change. Other times we do see the line of God's plans clearly through the tracing paper of scripture and we line the drawing of our own plans up with the lines of God's plan; God's glory is magnified and our joy results. Still other times we do see the lines of God's plan clearly and yet we rebel against those clearly draw lines and we scribble off in another direction, noticing that our scribbling has not changed the lines on the existing drawing underneath but instead, we find that our scribbling has driven us to joyless despair and fear, and as God's children we eventually and enevitably repent of our sinful misdirection, and by God's grace, once again we trace the existing lines of the plan God has drawn.

Monday, November 5, 2007

The Mighty Savior of All Creation

Holiness be to the Lord our God;
The Mighty Savior of all creation!

He resists the pride of haughty men,
but He comforts the weak and afflicted.

Oh, how we praise His name;
how we lift it up before the lords of earth.
Hallelujah He will save us!
Hallelujah praise His name!

The name of the All Mighty we will proclaim;
sovereign over all His creation!

He is good and wise and powerful,
yet He stooped down to share our distress.

Oh, how we praise His name;
how we lift it up before the lords of earth.
Hallelujah He will save us!
Hallelujah praise His name!

He came and died and He rose again;
all creation must worship The Anointed!

He was seen by many in resurrection body,
then to His Father’s right side He ascended!

Oh, how we praise His name;
how we lift it up before the lords of earth.
Hallelujah He will save us!
Hallelujah praise His name!

Friday, November 2, 2007

Another Example of Equivocation

I heard an interesting example of equivocation this morning:

The host of a Christian radio show introduced their topic while he was interviewing the speaker. The topic was, "myths about evangelism", and the host labeled the first one, "people do not want to hear about Jesus." The speaker then began to elaborate on the myth by stating its converse, "people are open to the gospel".

All other errors aside, it is one thing to suggest that people do want to hear about Jesus; this statement could be considered true if one qualified it by saying that a person wanting to hear about Jesus is not the same as a person seeking after God, which Paul in his letter to the Romans explicitly states as not being the case, but to liken the idea that, "people want to hear about Jesus" with the idea that "people are open to the gospel", is to equivocate a potentially true statement with an out-right error.

The context on the program was this: we as Christians tell ourselves lies (myths) about unbelievers and about the nature of evangelism so that we might not feel so guilty about not proclaiming the gospel. But in that context, we can never say that persons (ones we should be evangelising) are open to the good news, which is that Christ has born the penalty of our sins, and raised from the dead to placate the wrath of the Father. If anyone believes that then they do not need to be evangelised...they need to be discipled.

As a result of, what I believe is a disregard for what have historically been considered biblical categories: evangelism, seeker, and the gospel, and for what has been the historical understanding of the human condition, i.e., depraved, persons often think that unbelievers are open to the gospel, or that they are even seeking it or seeking Jesus for salvation prior to being regenerated, when we know from scripture that all of us who once were, and all present unbelievers not only are not seeking the gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ, but in their hearts we hated Him; those considered "seekers" by many evangelicals may very well want to know more about Jesus the person who existed in history, they may even want to know more about the historical truth claims of Christianity, but unless they are called by The Spirit of God, they are never open to the gospel...at least not until one is regenerated is he open to the gospel.

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Memorable Quote

"Once you assume the gospel, you're already in danger of losing it."

D.A. Carson during an interview with Mike Horton of The White Horse Inn - October 2007

Tuesday, October 30, 2007

The Gospel As Law

In the theological circles in which I travel, most are aware of the recent discussion of Joel Osteen on The White Horse Inn. On the right side of this blog under "Places I Go" I have a link to their site. I am certain that it is not the intention of the White Horse Inn hosts, nor is it my intention to simply criticize and bash another man who at least calls himself a Christian. The intention is to protect the children of God from those things that are very dangerous. Though he smiles a great deal, though he communicates friendliness and concern through his soothing tone and his passive body language, his message, I'm afraid, is ultimately one that brings death.

Instead of the Law of a holy God: do all this and you shall live, he presents moralistic advise: just try a little harder and you'll get it right. Instead of the gospel of a merciful and just God: Christ has done for sinners all that God has commanded in His Law, he attempts to absolve his listeners of their guilt by advising them to obey God's commands and God will be obliged to make them happy. In the end, that presentation is just another form of law; there is no mention of Christ's work on our behalf: even on our behalf to give us joy, which it most certainly does. Though Osteen may mention Christ's death in some of his preaching, he does not attach it to the holy justice of God and His wrath against unbelievers, so the Osteen "gospel" becomes law. Instead of presenting the Law and commands of God: your sins have set you against God and His wrath is upon you, Osteen says, even if you don't think that you measure up, it's OK because God loves you anyway. Instead of presenting the good news: believe and repent of your sins, Osteen says: obey God's commands and He will lead you on the path of happiness and self-fulfillment.

While Joel Osteen's message is mingled with truth: God does love humanity, excessive self abasement is harmful (particularly if it does not drive one to the gospel), his presentation of "good news" is not all that good. Are you really telling us Pastor Joel, that the way we earn God's favor is by obeying His Law; the way we insure our "best life now" is to line ourselves up more strictly with a form of biblical moralism?

A few scripture come to my mind in this case:

Jude

3 Beloved, although I was very eager to write to you about our common salvation, I found it necessary to write appealing to you to contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints. 4 For certain people have crept in unnoticed who long ago were designated for this condemnation, ungodly people, who pervert the grace of our God into sensuality and deny our only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ.

2 Peter 2

1 But false prophets also arose among the people, just as there will be false teachers among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies, even denying the Master who bought them, bringing upon themselves swift destruction. 2 And many will follow their sensuality, and because of them the way of truth will be blasphemed. 3 And in their greed they will exploit you with false words. Their condemnation from long ago is not idle, and their destruction is not asleep.

I know some of my words seem harsh, but they are not nearly as destructive as the ignorance of the gospel which Olsteen's words promote.

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

Eight Revealing Questions: Question #8 & Conclusions: Installment #7

And finally, the last question to be asked (at least in this series) is:

Was my choice determined?

If I have answered the previous questions correctly and with biblical accuracy, then:

1. God does know my future choices; God knows all the future perfectly.

2. I do choose freely.

3. I cannot be forced to choose something that I do not want.

4. I make the choices I make based on my affections and my strongest desires.

5. My affections and God's decree are causes of the choices I make.

As we consider the choices I have already made:

6. I could never have chosen differently.

7. I cannot choose against the eternal decree of God.

Then the answer to question #8, was my choice determined is, yes. And it must be if God knows what He knows perfectly and those things He knows includes my choices, then my choice is necessarily predetermined. God has determined my future choice by His infallible decrees which are their primary cause, but He has also determined that I will make the choices I make based on my affections/desires/inclinations, which are the secondary causes of my choices. They are the means by which God will accomplish His ends through my free choices; and He has ordained both the means and the ends. Take once again the instance where I chose to turn left instead of right: if God knew I was going to turn left, even though there were various causes (secondary to His knowledge of my future choice and His decree of it) for my decision, and I ended up turning right--contrary to His knowledge--then we must either change our definition of the word know or God didn't actually know that I was going to decide to turn left.

After ruminating over these questions, I think it is clear how one ends up with an "open" view of God if one has rejected the orthodox view of providence, compatibilism and God's decrees and replaced it with an unorthodox view of libertarian free will (the view that claims that in order for the creature to make really free choices, in hindsight it must have had the ability to have chosen otherwise and cannot have been constrained by any determining cause...even its own desires and affections) the next "logical" step in such a system, in order to maintain one's consistency, is to say that God does not actually know my future choices, and if He did and if I couldn't have chosen otherwise, then my choices are never really free because they are constrained by God's knowledge of them and my affection toward, them based on my strongest desire.

What is further is that God's knowledge of future events, creatures and their choices is not subject to His observation of a future that exists outside of His decree. The set of events which we (bound in time) look forward to as future, and which we look back at and call history does not exist as an arbitrary object which God had to discover and about which He now submits His knowledge. NO, the reality is that time and history are subject to Him because He has ordained all their means and ends.

There are two sets of implications that can be drawn from this information:

Those conclusions which are subject to biblical evidence lead to the Reformed view of God's providence:

1. God knows my future choice perfectly, therefore my choice is predestined.

2. Because God has perfect knowledge of future events and choices, He necessarily must have decreed their occurrence.

3. God knows my future choice perfectly, therefore I can’t choose against His decree.

4. God knows my future choice perfectly, therefore I can’t choose differently; I cannot make a choice which is contrary to His decree.

Those conclusions about God's providence which are based solely in human sophistry lead to a non-Christian view of God.

1. If my choice is not predetermined then God cannot know my future choice perfectly.

2. If I can choose against the decree of God then He doesn’t actually know my future choice and thus has not decreed it.

3. If I can choose differently then God doesn’t know my future choice perfectly.

Monday, October 8, 2007

Eight Revealing Questions: Questions #5, #6 & #7: Installment #6

Question number five, what factors cause or determine our choices?

The answer to this question lies in the explanation given of the types of causes by which we are influenced, but the final answer to question number five is two-fold: our affections and God's decree; our affections are the factors that determine the choices we make, thus causing us to choose what we want, and God's decree causes or determines our choices. But these conclusions raise other questions.

We have seen that there are many influences to be considered as we ponder why we have made certain choices, but the immediate cause of our choice is ultimately our affections. Our affections may be altered by our surroundings and the influence that other creatures have over us. We also established that if I do not have the capacity to make a certain choice, I have ultimately not been coerced into choosing against my strongest desire because it is a choice that I am not capable of making, thus it cannot be the object of my strongest affection. We also saw that one of the causes of my choices (which remain free because I choose according to my desires and affections) is God's decree of that choice. Therefore we must ask the sixth and seventh questions: could we actually have chosen differently; can I chose against the decree of God?

The manner in which question #6 is asked makes it seem innocent and to answer in the negative would make it appear to be a violation of the creature's freedom, but a closer look at that particular phrasing should cause one to dive deeper into the question and re-ask it in a manner similar to question #7.

Question #6 is completely legitimate, could I actually have chosen differently? In answering this question it is helpful to consider once again, the causes of my choice. Let's return to the example where I was "forced" to turn left in my car. Would the material causes of my choice to turn left annihilate my ability to turn right? The existence of the road wouldn’t prohibit my turning right. The fact that I was in a car would not prohibit me from turning right if I had wanted to. My own existence would not preclude my turning right. So what about the efficient causes: my thought processes were some of the efficient causes for my turning left but they were not a cause to the exclusion of turning right. Even though the threat to my life caused me to turn left, I still could have turned right in the face of that risk, so from that stand point alone I could have chosen differently. By turning left, I might have still reached my destination even though I was forced to turn left when I would have considered a right turn the more efficient path to my destination. Even if turning left had been a dead-end, I could eventually have make a u-turn and finally arrived at my destination. The fact that I was at a “T” intersection when I turned left did not limit my choice to only turning left; I still could have turned right if I didn't allow the car-jacker to influence my decision. I even could have gone straight if I had been willing to run off the road. So we find that none of the material or efficient causes would have destroyed my ability to choose otherwise.

Next we explore the formal cause of my decision to turn left. Officially, the formal causes of my choice to turn left were the motivating factors of the situation: the gunman, and my desire to preserve my life, but neither of these destroyed my capacity to chose to turn right. So during the examination of all these different causes of my choice to turn left we find that, from the human, temporal perspective I could have turned right. But in hindsight we must also agree that my choice was fixed and because I did finally chose to turn left, we must deduce that I could not have chosen otherwise because of the final cause of my choice.

The final cause of my choice to turn left was not just my desire and affection to that direction and my desire to preserve my life, but ultimately, the answer to question #6 is no, and question #7 is that I could not have chosen otherwise because God decreed for it to happen. God knew it was going to happen, and if He knew I might turn left but I actually ended up turning right, then His knowledge of my choice would have been imperfect. Because God’s knowledge of the future is perfect I could not have chosen differently. So, can I choose against the decree of God? Well, if I have argued effectively in the last several sentences then we will see that the answer to this question is also no, and for the very same reasons. If we are able to choose contrary to the decree of God then He would no longer be God because He would be rendered impotent and without perfect knowledge.