“The second [I assume Phil. 3] simply warns believers against going back to symbols, on the ground that they have that which these symbols only typified. In the third [I assume Gal. 6], the expression, "Israel of God," is figuratively applied to those who for the time had taken Israel's place as the special object of God's favour; if, indeed, it is not confined to that "remnant according to the election of grace" — that small portion of the nation which believed in Jesus, while "the rest were blinded" (Rom. 11: 5-7).”
Romans 5:7-9
Monday, April 7, 2008
Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation # 26: T.B. Baines
Friday, April 4, 2008
Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation # 25: T.B. Baines
Moving on to another pertinent passage, Baines furthermore dismisses the evidence of the relationship of Christians to spiritual
7 Know then that it is those of faith who are the sons of Abraham. 8 And the Scripture, foreseeing that God would justify the Gentiles by faith, preached the gospel beforehand to Abraham, saying, "In you shall all the nations be blessed." 9 So then, those who are of faith are blessed along with Abraham, the man of faith. 10 For all who rely on works of the law are under a curse; for it is written, "Cursed be everyone who does not abide by all things written in the Book of the Law, and do them." 11 Now it is evident that no one is justified before God by the law, for "The righteous shall live by faith." 14 so that in Christ Jesus the blessing of Abraham might come to the Gentiles, so that we might receive the promised Spirit through faith. 15 To give a human example, brothers: even with a man-made covenant, no one annuls it or adds to it once it has been ratified. 16 Now the promises were made to Abraham and to his offspring. It does not say, "And to offsprings," referring to many, but referring to one, "And to your offspring," who is Christ. 17 This is what I mean: the law, which came 430 years afterward, does not annul a covenant previously ratified by God, so as to make the promise void. 18 For if the inheritance comes by the law, it no longer comes by promise; but God gave it to Abraham by a promise. 19 Why then the law? It was added because of transgressions, until the offspring should come to whom the promise had been made, and it was put in place through angels by an intermediary. 20 Now an intermediary implies more than one, but God is one. 21 Is the law then contrary to the promises of God? Certainly not! For if a law had been given that could give life, then righteousness would indeed be by the law. 22 But the Scripture imprisoned everything under sin, so that the promise by faith in Jesus Christ might be given to those who believe.
Here is how Baines quotes the passage,
“In Galatians 3: 7, we are told "that they which are of faith, the same are the children of Abraham." In ver. 27-29, we read, "As many of you as have been baptized unto Christ, have put on Christ. There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus. And if ye be Christ's, then are ye Abraham's seed and heirs according to the promise." Here the promise is the blessing of all nations in the seed, that is, in Christ. Of this promise believers are heirs as made one with Christ. The chapter does not name the promise given to the multitudinous seed, much less show the Church as taking this promise away from
The explanation itself is a bit confusing because, on the one hand he says that, If I understand him correctly, Baines has said that the “The chapter does not name the promise given to the multitudinous seed”, but just before that he makes this positive statement about the character of the promise, “Here the promise is the blessing of all nations in the seed”. So which is it, does the chapter not name the promise given or is the promise simply the promise that Abraham’s Seed, which is Christ, bless the whole world? I cannot just assume that the blessing gained by the promise (the blessing Baines would have in mind) is that gentiles will also be saved because their were proselytes to the Jewish cultic system who also were saved from the wrath of God in the same way as the Jew, by forward looking to the ultimate sacrifice of Christ, so what blessing could the Judaizers possibly had in mind that would have gotten them so riled up? Was it the fact that under the Old Covenant the proselyte had to be circumcised and now under the New Covenant Paul had said that no one had to be circumcised?
In verses 1-6, Paul has chastised the Galatians for trying to uphold their position in Christ (one gained by faith and not by works) by Law keeping, and he does so by reminding them that they were first saved by a spiritual salvation and it is not by a fleshly ordinance that they will continue to be saved (namely circumcision because the battle Paul was fighting in this epistle was against those Judaizers who thought it a scandal for gentiles to be brought near to the promises of God without having to be circumcised) in Paul’s mind this is ridiculous and he sums it up with this statement, “27 For as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ. 28 There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. 29 And if you are Christ's, then you are Abraham's offspring, heirs according to promise.”—notice how the promise of land and rest were not explicitly excluded; believers across the ages are heirs according to promise, not heirs according to obedience.
Thursday, April 3, 2008
Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation # 24: T.B. Baines
Section 2 of: The Lord's
Baines’ misunderstanding or misrepresentation of the Amillennial view aside, here is his view on several passages that consider the Church/Israel distinction:
“Now that believers are the children of Abraham is not disputed. The question is, whether they drain into themselves, and divert from
He then cites Romans 4:
11 He received the sign of circumcision as a seal of the righteousness that he had by faith while he was still uncircumcised. The purpose was to make him the father of all who believe without being circumcised, so that righteousness would be counted to them as well, 12 and to make him the father of the circumcised who are not merely circumcised but who also walk in the footsteps of the faith that our father Abraham had before he was circumcised. 13 For the promise to Abraham and his offspring that he would be heir of the world did not come through the law but through the righteousness of faith. 14 For if it is the adherents of the law who are to be the heirs, faith is null and the promise is void. 15 For the law brings wrath, but where there is no law there is no transgression. 16 That is why it depends on faith, in order that the promise may rest on grace and be guaranteed to all his offspring—not only to the adherent of the law but also to the one who shares the faith of Abraham, who is the father of us all, 17 as it is written, "I have made you the father of many nations"—in the presence of the God in whom he believed, who gives life to the dead and calls into existence the things that do not exist.
Baines continues this way,
“But the promise here is not the promise of the land. It is a summary of God's promises announcing his purpose to make Abraham the root of blessing. Thus believers are morally Abraham's children, as the father of the faithful. This is all that the passage states as to relationship. They will inherit the world as joint-heirs with Christ, and the promises to Abraham are varied and extended in God's grace to include them. This is all that the passage says about the promises. The specific promise to the descendants of Abraham is not transferred to the Church, and is altogether inapplicable to it. And so far are the literal seed from being set aside by the spiritual seed, that the promise is expressly stated to belong to the seed "which is of the law," as well as to that "which is of the faith of Abraham."
Romans 4 would not be the only time a New Testament writer brackets off a portion of an Old Testament quote, for the purposes of the Holy Spirit, yet still having the whole of its Old Testament context in mind. In other words, Paul can say that, “13 For the promise to Abraham and his offspring that he would be heir of the world did not come through the law but through the righteousness of faith.” and still have the entirety of the Abrahamic covenant promises in view; he does not have to reiterate every aspect of the covenant rewards in order for them to be included in his citation. The interpretation that Baines makes of this passage would not have crossed the minds of the first century Jews hearing the letter read aloud, though it was not written to them specifically in history, saved Jews of that day and ours should adore this Scripture just as any other. Furthermore, if Paul knew that God had two peoples in one (the remnant of spiritual Jews and the Church contained in one elect body) in mind and that the promises distributed to each group were not all the same, then it is the belief of this theologian that here in Romans he would have made that patently clear, but he didn’t, in fact, the exact opposite is expressed by the consideration of the text in the context of the rest of the letter and the entire New Testament. So I feel that the burden of proof lies with those dispensationalists who insist that Paul has that in view here. Baines asserts that the promise of land is not in view here, but any mention of the inheritance of Abraham’s children would have conjured up thoughts of the land and the rest therein unless the promises of such things were explicitly excluded, but they are not. So I think Baines’ claim that the promise of land is not here and that Paul only had in mind the promise God made to Abraham that through him all the nations would be blessed is very bold at best. In this isolated reward the essential thing in mind is that salvation is of the Jews but for the gentiles as well. If it were true, that this was the only thing Paul had in mind, then he never would have used the phrase, “heir of the world” because of the great confusion it would have caused. So, Baines continues, because this is the only aspect of the Abrahamic promises that Paul had in mind, he concludes that believing gentiles are only Abraham’s children “morally” because he is the father of the “faithful”. What he appears to mean here is that Abraham is the father of those who keep the law. But this directly contradicts Paul’s entire line of argumentation. Paul is arguing that all believers are Abraham’s children BY FAITH, not that those who ARE FAITHFUL to keep the law are his children; else he wouldn’t have said that Abraham was counted righteous before he was circumcised. This is symptomatic of the perennial dispensational confusion of justification and sanctification.
The larger Pauline purpose here (and I dare say that it is the purpose of the Spirit as well) is to solidify the idea that all believers in every age are the children of Abraham, and if his children, then joint heirs with Christ—receiving, as do all of Abraham’s descendants—all of the promises afforded thereunto. The real problem is that Baines has a view of the promises of God that is constricted by what I have referred to as the tenacist view. This view regards the historical grammatical interpretation of the Old Testament prophesies as their only interpretation. On the other hand, the covenant theologian (and the Amillennialists in particular regarding the fulfillment of the promises of God to Abraham) is concerned with the historical grammatical interpretation and believe that it is important to ascertain how the audience contemporary to the prophesy (prophet included) would probably have understood it, but he also affords a spiritual, divine, fuller and greater interpretation and fulfillment of many Old Testament prophecies to the degree that the New Testament or the metanarrative of the canonical context expands that interpretation. I suggest that the neglect of this method of interpretation has created more than one pitfall in the landscape of Christian theology and its application over the last 160 years.
Wednesday, April 2, 2008
Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation # 23: T.B. Baines
More from Baines,
“1 Thessalonians 4:13-5:11, may be examined by means of the discussion of five exegetical issues. The first of these issues may be called the problem of the Thessalonians. The theme of this passage in general is clearly to comfort and encourage the Thessalonian believers concerning believing loved ones who had died. This is the theme with which it begins and with which it concludes (
“When a dignitary paid an official visit or parousia to a city in Hellenistic times, the action of the leading citizens in going out to meet him and escorting him on the final stage of his journey was called the apantesis…”
“This connotation points toward our rising to meet Christ in order to escort Him immediately back to earth."12 This meaning of meeting (apantesis) is confirmed by its two other uses in the New Testament. Matt. 25:6 speaks of the ten virgins who were waiting to go out and meet the bridegroom and then return with him to the wedding feast. Even more clearly Acts 28:15 speaks of how the brethren came out to meet Paul and accompanied him on the final leg of his journey to
Monday, March 31, 2008
Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation # 22: T.B. Baines
On the surface it appears as though Baines would have his readers believe that a compelling argument for the secret rapture is the fact that, other than in the passages addressed immediately above, Christ never tried to give His disciples hope of His return as being eminent, and because it is spoken of here in eminency then here Christ cannot be speaking of the end of the world because prior to that event we know other things must happen, thus Christ must here be speaking of a different return; Baines would he would assert that return to be the secret rapture. Of course, we have already addressed the fact that even to the disciples, the secret rapture could not have happened at ANY time because Peter had to die before its occurrence. Baines really just tries to gloss over this fact and in my opinion just because he exempts Peter from having the same hope of an eminent return does not mean that the return is necessarily eminent, thus separating it from the return in power and glory. Baines continues.
“But though our Lord's own language seems sufficiently plain, it may be asked, whether it is in agreement with other portions of God's Word? Christ's teaching [teaching of the secret rapture], as we have said, only slightly touched this special subject of His separate advent for His saints; and He left its full significance to be brought to the hearts of His disciples by that Spirit of Truth, who was to teach them all things, and bring all things to their remembrance whatsoever He had said unto them. What, then, does this Holy Spirit teach us concerning the wondrous theme we are here considering?”
“Now no time is here mentioned, and if the passage stood by itself it might be supposed to refer to the end of the world. But, comparing it with other passages, this interpretation becomes impossible. For, in the first place, His coming again was to be "in like manner" with His ascension, and nothing can be conceived more unlike to this event than the appearance of the Judge upon the great white throne. Secondly, when the Judge then appears, He does not come to the world, for "the earth and the heaven flee away." It is the dead who are summoned before the Judge, not the Judge who comes to them. (Rev. 20: 11-15.) But thirdly, our Lord had Himself constantly spoken of His coming, and had only recently named its effect upon the disciples as a special ground of consolation and hope, as the one precious comfort to stay their hearts during His absence.”
Saturday, March 29, 2008
Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation # 21: T.B. Baines
The following section deals primarily with, “Section 1 of: The Lord's
“Everybody is aware of the difference prevailing among the Lord's people as to the interpretation of those passages of Scripture which foretell the future in reserve for the Church and the world. The ordinary interpretation is, that the promises contained in the Psalms and Old Testament prophecies refer to the Church, which, as the spiritual
It is interesting how much difference 150 years makes—at the time of Baines’ writing, the Amillennial view was the popular, ordinary view, and now his view is popular and considered ordinary. There are two misstatements in the paragraph above regarding the Amillennial view (if that in fact is the view he inteded to critique), one, that we believe that the Church as the Spiritual Israel has “taken the place” of national
“Indeed, the very thought that the constant references to the future scattered through the sacred writings are not meant to be understood, carries its own refutation.”
“But in the epistles there appears another fact, a "mystery" hidden from the Old Testament prophets, and only hinted at by Jesus himself. This is that the Lord's coming is divided into two different acts.”
“That these words disclose a new prospect, not the spirit's presence with Jesus after death, is clear from the closing verses of this gospel. There our Lord first foretells Peter's death; then, being asked what should become of John, replies — "If I will that he tarry till I come, what is that to thee?" (John 21: 22). Now this could not mean that John might live till the end of the world. But neither could it mean that John might go to be with Jesus at his death. In this case, how would he have differed from Peter or any of the other disciples? Moreover, such an interpretation would rob the words of all meaning, making them equivalent to this — "If I will that he lives till he dies, what is that to thee?" The coming referred to, therefore, is neither the departure to be with Jesus at death, nor His appearing at the end of the world.”
While it is as clear to the Amillennialist as it is to the dispensationalist that when the Lord returns, the saints of God will be translated and they will not die a physical death. Without any preconceived notion of a secret rapture prior to Christ’s coming in power and glory, one should never derive such a belief from the reading of the passages Baines and others use to promote it. His argument for such a secret rapture seems to rely largely on his assumption that the disciples could not have been comforted by the desciption of Christ’s return “at the end of the world”. I am not certain, but it almost appears that Baines, either believes for himself, or believes that those who oppose the secret rapture claim that all persons living at the second coming of Christ in triumph will necessarily die a physical death, therefore it cannot be comforting to Christ’s disciples.
This next discussion is clearly an aside, but I do find the following statement (which is in order with the statements as made in Baines’ material) to be very curious due to the popular emphasis today on “the eminent return of Christ” as being a doctrine of proper Biblical interpretation.
“The time of the Lord's coming is studiously kept out of sight. The only event that must necessarily happen, according to these scriptures, before the promised return of Jesus for his disciples, was the martyrdom of Peter, a thing which, in an age of persecution, might have occurred at almost any hour. When that had taken place, there was no reason to be deduced from these passages why the return of Jesus should not be momentarily expected.”
In the quote above, the part that I have underlined is the classic and popular, modern argument against the eminence of Christ’s return that covenant theologians would level against present day Ryrie style dispensationalists; because Christ told of His certain return, and Peter expected His return to Earth as a certainty (though he must have know he would die before it) they knew that there was at the very least, one event that would have to happen before it…namely, Peter’s martyrdom.
Now to continue with the discussion of the secret rapture and the prophetic discussion of Peter’s death and John’s possible tarrying.
“Let us look at the position of the early disciples, remembering that this was almost all the light they yet had on the subject. Of the two whose future career had been spoken of, one had been told that he must suffer death, the other that he might tarry till Jesus came. Would it not be a perfectly natural and lawful thing for John to be living in anticipation of the Lord's coming? Yes, Amillennialists would agree because Christ’s words tell all of us to do so. Would it not, indeed, have shown sad unbelief if he had not looked for translation, but had looked for death instead of translation? Christ doesn’t predict John’s life like He does Peter’s death, and Baines’ working assumption seems to be that future events will transpire in this way: secret rapture, The Great Tribulation, Christ’s return, and then a millennial reign. Would it not also have been lawful for the other disciples, Peter excepted, to anticipate that the Lord might come in their lifetime, and to have constantly before their souls the refreshing hope that the One whom they loved, and who had departed from them would soon return to take them to Himself? Again, Amillennialists would say yes, as long as all the expected events happened first. I think Baines’ dispensational assumptions upon the character of the rapture, tribulation, and second coming blinded him to passages that firmly evidence an eschatology that opposes his own. It is important to ascertain the legitimate effect which these words of our Lord would have on the minds of the disciples, because they were the only clear light on this subject which they yet possessed. It is true there were other prophecies as to His coming uttered by Himself, but these were intentionally obscure as to the great point here brought out namely, the coming of the Lord for His saints apart from and before His coming in power and glory.
The intent of Jesus telling Peter of the possible tarrying of John until His return was simply to make a point to Peter, that if it was the will of the Father, John would live until Christ’s return, or that Christ would return prior to John’s death. Jesus assures him that John’s future was lastly any of Peter’s concern. Christ was not here in this statement proclaiming some great treatise of the division of His return into two parts: secret and triumphant. Certainly, all who lived after Christ’s ascension were to look for His return, but the simple fact that John was encouraged to do so even though Christ also told Peter that it might happen prior to John’s death could never mean that Christ must return in “secret” in order for His words to be accurate prophesy, and for them to ring true in their hearts as an encouragement to hope. Just because this admonition of Christ here for His disciples to look for His return was more detailed than His description of events that would be preliminary to it, in no way gives the theologian license to separate these out into two particular returns; in fact, I believe that, unless you assume a secret rapture, it would be impossible to draw that conclusion from this text. The discussion Christ has with Peter regarding John’s life would not necessarily preclude his expectation of possible death.
Friday, March 28, 2008
Responding to Dispensationalism, Installation # 20: T.B. Baines
Section Three:
Responding to the Arguments of Particular Dispensational Authors
T. B. Baines
“To speak of the Church replacing
Thursday, March 27, 2008
Mysterious China: entry #13 The 36 hour Day
I'm finally sitting here in the Beijing international airport waiting on my flight to board. We won't start boarding for another 25 minutes, and then we don't depart for another 30-40 minutes after that. No trouble getting here--the taxi driver was very nice and helpful. In the meantime, I need some coffee...
Sunday, February 24: 5:00 pm e.s.t.
I haven't really felt like writing in a while. Amazingly, it has been more than 28 hours since I woke to begin the trip home. It's really strange when you travel like this, you basically end up living a 36 hour day (with a nap or 2 of course). I talked to you, Melissa, about 2 1/2 hoursr ago; I bought some Day Quill and it has suppressed my cough a bit, but I think it's going to wear off soon. I bought another dose in case that happened. I suppose I would have read or written more on the flight from Tokyo to Detroit if the buttons on my arm console had worked. I couldn't turn on my light, call the attendant, or change the channel or volume, so the entertainment portion of my flight had apparently been canceled. I told the flight attendant, but he didn't seem to share my concern. Just another example of airline service not being held to the same standards as restaurant customer service, "I'm sorry you didn't enjoy your meal sir, here's a free dessert." You don't hear that on an airplane.
Melissa, I'm sorry I haven't been able to shop for anyone on this trip, i'm afraid I didn't have any time to do so. I did get the boys a little something in the airport in Tokyo, but nothing caught my eye there for you.
Tuesday, March 25, 2008
Mysterious China: entry #12
I'm now on an airplane on my way back to Beijing. Tomorrow morning I must leave the hotel for my flight home, which leaves at 9:00. As much fun as I have had, and as much as I have enjoyed my stay here, I am definately ready to leave. I have a little cough. I'm not sure that it isn't the result of being around so much cigarette smoke. On several occasions I might as well have smoked myself. Melissa, I can't wait to tell you and the boys all about my trip.
8:00 am e.s.t.
Wow! that is the first thing I must say about the room I'm in tonight at the KunLun Hotel. I will definitely take some photos. When we checked in, for some reason, they upgraded my room. When you walk in you enter a study with a desk, the main room with a bed on the left, the widow straight ahead, and the entertainment center on the right. A door on the right, near the study, reveals the bathroom (or should I say rooms), and it really is quite a room--it is what makes this hotel room incredible itself: with the toilet room, main room, closets, tub (you know, the one with the TV) and the shower. I couldn't believe their was no TV in the shower--I think I'll complain. (photos to come...)
Wednesday, March 19, 2008
Mysterious China: entry #11 Passport, what Pasport!?!
Another interesting thing is that the family style restaurants are as big as hotels, 5-10 stories. They are the kind of restaurant where you go it and see all the food you want and pick it all out, and the fish you choose to eat are alive and swimming until the decide to cook it for you. Inside, it looks like a hotel as well, and they take you to your room where you and your guests have their own restroom...simply amazing!
Monday, March 17, 2008
Mysterious China: entry #10 Beauty in the Eye of the Consumer
It is very interesting hearing about the way commercialism has suddenly taken China by storm. Mark (the president of our client, Glen Arbor Home Furnishings) said that 6-7 years ago there was no "commercial" TV. There were only two channels: a government run, political channel and a current weather and Chinese news channel, which by the way rarely broad casted programing. At the time there really wasn't a large enough class of people to consume commercial products; there wasn't a demographic large enough to support the product sales that TV programming as we know it needs to support itself--thus there were no TV shows. But now all that has changed as a result of the rising middle class who are consuming, who are buying commercial products that have purchased air time from the TV stations, thus enabling the stations to develop and distribute popular programming.
All that in order to discuss the image of beauty as beheld by the average Chinese person, or so interpreted for us by the Chinese broadcasters. For a few days now I have walked around and wondered who Chinese people consider beautiful and who they don't; what facial structures, skin tone, hair shape and color, body build qualifies as beautiful in Chinese culture? I could certainly walk around and make that judgment for myself..."her face is pretty", "I'll bet women find him attractive..." and so on. But would the average Chinese person agree with me? I often found myself, after looking back at the situation, considering those whose faces resembled Westerners most, to be the most beautiful...those who looked most like me, or my "kind". One humorous incident involved me finding out that they think that my nose is very sharp and long (a bit exaggerated in proportion) and that characteristic is considered to be very "Western". Mark on the other hand, does not have what the Chinese would consider a "Western" nose because his is flatter, closer to his face like a Chinese person, thus more attractive and desirable.
I hope this post was interesting to someone other than myself, I had great fun writing it while I was in China. By the way, the top photo is from a lunch I had, very delicious! The photo at the bottom is from my first experience at a "family" style seafood restaurant, where you pick your food out live, then they cook it and bring it to your "room", where you have a table and your own bathroom. More about all that later!Friday, March 14, 2008
Mysterious China: entry #9 A Theology of Inprecision?
Now as for the application to the arena of theology, those principle thoughts that I presented in the last post: China has been the place of a growing and flourishing underground Christian church for even the past 25 years or so, even though the Aristotelian line of thinking has not penetrated the culture or been cultivated as the way one should view reality. The differences that Chinese Christians, who obviously have been made so by the gracious power of the Holy Spirit, will face in the area of theological challenges will be more along the lines of the errors of imprecision in their theological constructs. While the Western church does have its share of that, we struggle to find unity within the invisible Church among opposing theological nuances. I'm certain a degree of this will also plague the Chinese Church, I think its greater challenge will result from the gradation tendencies that underlie the very earth in China.
Thursday, March 13, 2008
Mysterious China: entry #9 East Meets West
Like most westerners, I find the culture here very different; it's not just the language, the food, and the relationships, but those things are different ("eastern") as a function of some more foundational difference. The fundamental difference truly is the difference we see as West meets East. The same sort of difference that separated Aristotle from Confucius, the Jews from the Greeks, the Greek Orthodox Church from the Roman Church and now, the difference between East and the West as far as I can tell, is the difference between gradated and binary. Don't get me wrong, I've only been in China for five days, and though I have dealt with Chinese and other Eastern Asia folk for 10-12 years now, I would never make the mistake of assuming that I know everything about it or even a great deal about it--but I have, like thinking persons before me, made my own humble observations. Where we Americans and Western Europeans tend to see the world in more binary terms, with fewer degrees of difference; black and white; yes and no, consistent and inconsistent and yes, even right and wrong. This can lead to extremisms and we do bend our thought that way. While on the other hand, Chinese and Eastern cultures tend to view the world in gradation, more graduated terms, many degrees of difference on the spectrum; many shades of gray--from nearly black to almost white; from yes to maybe yes to maybe no to no. As a result, consistency is separated by the different segments of life; where intra-segmental consistency would be expected, inter-segmental consistency is not. The idea of consistency in one segment may not line up with the idea of consistency in another segment, so what might be "right" or acceptable at work or in business may not be "right" or acceptable at home or in familial relationships. There really is no place for the test of the consistent application of moras from one segment to another. This also can result in a tenancy toward imprecision. This different approach goes deeper than the ethos of a culture, even deeper than epistemology--it actually informs the way Easterners develop ethics and the way they determine what is true, just like our rudiments have practical functions.
We consider ourselves on a line, they consider themselves on a circle. This Eastern conclusion or assumption affects their language also--no gender or tense; no verb conjugation; it affects their relationships-- "X is always wrong unless of course, condition Y is met". It also affects their driving--the boundaries made by lines are always being crossed; signs are important suggestions; you should always stop at a red light, unless you are in a big hurry; stop signs are like yield signs, and yield signs mean, "try not to run into anyone as you pull out and merge into oncoming traffic". It also affects their art: visual and culinary. Take tea for instance, the leaves are floating in it whereas, we would strain them. If things are to be mixed, they are not necessarily mixed well, as a solution would be. And finally, the problem of furniture production--in which I am fully engaged on this trip. I believe that the reason American furniture executives and creative persons may so often be frustrated with the sampling and production of furniture by Chinese factories is because the Chinese often see the specifications on a construction drawing the same way they see a stop sign or light.
On another point, yes, Chinese factory owners do think that it is wrong to copy a company's hardware design unless of course it will sell more furniture for the importer; yes it is wrong to copy another company's furniture design unless of course it will prove more profitable to the furthered existance of the factory than not copying it would. I have to wonder that, if those who began importing products from China so many years ago had really considered the sociological and philosophical constrants that maybe the rampant copyright violations in today's environment could have been averted. Then again, maybe all those Westerners involved did make the same observations I have, but they chose to ignore them and then again, perhaps the distinctions I have made between East and West are not nearly so sharp.