Romans 5:7-9

For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die—but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - VII

To continue with one of my observations of the theology and practice of the Plymouth Brethren, I do want to point out that their apparent disregard for historical theology (the thoughts and work that the Spirit had done through the comments of men who had gone before them) is, at least in part, due to the over-emphasis that they placed on the doctrine of the priesthood of the believer.  It seems to have led to the "no creed but the Bible" mentality that appears prominent in American Christianity today.  The idea that, if one were simply not to allow himself to be eschewed by the theologies of the past, then his interpretation is more likely to remain acute because he has not developed any presuppositions that he use to bend the meaning of the text to his desires.
I think that it is this sort of mindset that acts as a Pietre dish for heresies and cultism, feed by arrogance.  This to me seems naive for a number of reasons.  First, the person generally speaking, is not going to be reading the text in its original languages, so his interpretation will already be influenced "from the outside" by the editors of whatever English translation he is using.  Second, and now let's just take for granted that this man is reading his bible in the original languages, this idea has to assumes that the Spirit, if the would-be interpreter of the Word has no historical influences, would teach him every right thing that He had taught all other interpreters from the past.  Lastly, it would do us well to consider this: the primary means God uses today to physically heal our bodies is not having the infirm sit alone in prayer (though God can certainly heal this way if He pleased), our healing is more likely to come from God, through the means (means which He has ordained and of which He is in control) of medications and the common wisdom He has given to medical professionals.  Likewise, the primary means God uses today (and for the past 4-5 millennia) to heal our minds of sickly and deficient theologies is not having the infants or mature in the faith, sit alone in prayer with their bible (though God does teach us the right ways of scripture in our personal bible studies), our theological healing is much more likely to come from God, through the means (means which He has ordained and of which He is in control) of the preaching and teaching of the Word that we hear from live men, and the preaching/teaching and comments men of old, with which we have been blessed.  I don't mean to suggest that historical theology is authoritative, nor inerrant, just that (along with the preaching/teaching of men today, which by the way as soon as it has been spoken or published, it has become part of the total of historical theology) it is a.  I also don't mean to suggest that we should consume every word of our favorite theologian (live or dead) without question, as though it was mother's milk, but neither should we act as though we are lactose intolerant--Historical theology is a vital part of our rightly understanding the Word of God, and we balance that with the Berean principle.

I believe that we can observe one of the methodologies/practices that logical result from "anti-confessionalism" (a term which I believe also encompasses a disregard for historical theology) in the Brethren movement.  Their misinterpretation of and over-emphasis on the priesthood of the believer was not balanced by the teaching of scripture on the offices of local church leaders, and their God-given capacity to teach and shepherd the flock God has given them, thus the anti-clerical aspect of the movement.  This is the conclusion that must  fnally be drawn from a disregard of historical theology, and too high a regard for my ability to rightly interpret God's Word void of outside influences.

Just a word of personal application, I've learned lots of things in my personal bible study, while meditating on it in prayer, but some of it I later learned was heresy, and I allowed myself to be corrected by smarter men, and the interpretations granted them by the Spirit.  Take for instance, the formulation of the way we talk about the Triune nature of God.  As a young Christian, I easily could have come away from my preliminary readings of the New Testament as a convinced "modalist", but only when confronted by the historical theology of the Trinity, was my understanding set straight

I wonder if the aversion to historical theology, and its importance in the development of our understandings of scripture, is in some degree due to a Protestant reaction to the Magisterium (teaching authority) of Roman Catholic ecclesiology.  But as a survey of the history of the Reformation would quickly show, the doctrine of sola scriptura was never set in opposition to the importance of the guidance we are to receive from our pastors/elders/teachers, nor was it intended to excuse a disdain for the importance historical theology.  The formulation of the doctrine of sola scriptura was to define authority not importance or resourcefulness.  So, perhaps anti-confessionalism and anti-clericalism is an overreaction to the final authority that the Roman Catholic Pope and Bishops taunted over their parishioners.

It's a Boy! - Part 3

Below are some potential combinations of the names previously mentioned.  No particular order, just listed as "conceived".


Alastair Boone
Tanner Bryson
Carson Brach
Porter Knoll
Finnegan Anderson
Bryson Cooper
Broderick Cooper
Caedmon Sawyer
Anderson Boone
Finnegan Addison
Asher Brach
Lincoln Beckley
Cooper Knoll
Alastair Braighton
Bryson Carter

Monday, September 29, 2008

It's a Boy! - Part 2

Though our youngest son, Spencer has already decided that the baby boy we are expecting in February will be named "Frisbee", Melissa and I are thinking of some back-up names just in case that one doesn't work out.  Of course, Spencer does have good reason for his wanting to name the baby Frisbee.  He figures that if we name the baby Frisbee, then he will have someone to throw the frisbee with when the baby grows up.

All that being said, below are a list of names that we've come up with.  It will be interesting to see if we get any feedback.

Addison
Alastair
Anderson/Anders
Ashur
Beckley/Beck
Berkley/Berk
Boone
Brach
Braighton
Bretton
Broderick
Bryson
Caedmon
Camden
Carson
Carter
Cooper
Finnegan/Finn
Gibson
Gilmour
Harmon
Kamden
Knoll
Lincoln
Loche
Porter
Sawyer
Simon
Slate
Smith
Tanner
Townsend
Trevor

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - VI

Below are some supposed "quotes" that I came across, which were attributed to Chafer.  I am now trying to confirm there validity.  If anyone can help identify these, I would be very appreciative.
“With respect to regeneration, the Old testament saints were evidently renewed; but as there is no definite doctrinal teaching relative to the extent character of that renewal, no positive declaration can be made”—Chafer from ?????

“The silence of God must be respected relative to what constituted one a just man according to the Mosaic demands…The Old Testament will be searched in vain for a record of Jews passing from an unsaved state to a saved state, or for any declaration about the terms upon which such a change would be secured.  In other words, their national covenant standing was a tremendous spiritual advantage; but it cannot rightfully be compared with the estate of the believer today who is justified and perfected forever, having received the pleroma of the Godhead through vital union with Christ.”—Chafer from ???

Friday, September 26, 2008

(Revision Note) Further Questions for Dispensationalists - V a

I just adjusted a couple sentences in my previous post due to their confusing sentence structure.  Here are the two revised sentences.
"This, in part, may explain the reason for the vast majority of dispensationalists in our day who reject Calvinistic theology.  Perhaps that rejection is not an historical association alone, but I think it may be one of the fundamental causes for the development of Dispensationalism. "

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - V

In my recent project where I've been attempting to understand the birth of Dispensational Theology in the Brethren movement, I have seen more evidence that seems to connect it with a distinctly non-Calvinistic soteriology.  For a while now, I have been suspicious of the influence of Arminianism on that movement, and as I read through some of Darby's and Macintosh's writings posted on the "Stem Publishing" website, I have found that the way they speak about justification, sanctification, regeneration, propitiation, sin, etc, is symptomatic of that influence.  This, in part, may explain the reason for the vast majority of dispensationalists in our day who reject Calvinistic theology.  Perhaps that rejection is not an historical association alone, but I think it may be one of the fundamental causes for the development of Dispensationalism.  I also see a general disregard for historical theology and its categories, whether it be conscious or not, I don't know.  This too would contribute to the rejection of Calvinistic theology among the Brethren in Darby's day, and the overemphasis among Dispensationalists in our day, on the priesthood of the believer.  Which, coupled with a basic misunderstanding of the reasons why they are "Protestant",  has inevitably resulted in the disdain that many American Evangelicals have for creeds and confessions. 

So, I am wondering if anyone with more time invested in their writings would have some insight to share.

Friday, September 19, 2008

It's a Boy!

Well, it's official, we are having our 3rd boy! He should arrive sometime between February 4th and 10th, but with our history, he's likely to be a New Year's baby. Some of you who visit this blog from time to time,may be friends of ours in "the real world" (as opposed to this virtual one). You will know that we may have hoped for a little girl, but another boy is, without a doubt, no disappointment! As a man subject to our culture, and heir to the majority of cultures preceding ours, I am proud to pass on my name and the name of my physical forefathers. So in that respect, I would much rather be in the position of already having been blessed with male heirs and hoping for a girl, than already having been blessed with girls and hoping for a male heir to carry on my family name. Don't get me wrong, someday we would love a little girl with all our hearts, if God blessed us with one. Perhaps the means of that blessing would be through adoption...who knows what the Lord of Creation has in store?

Those of you who know us, probably know some of our family histories which have provided a great number of boys, on both mine and Melissa's side of the family. Melissa's dad, a Spencer, is the oldest of five boys, and I am the oldest of three. So whether or not those statistics factor into the Punit Square and make it more probable for us to have boys, I can't say with any scientific certainly. One thing is for sure, neither my wife nor our parents expected the baby to be girl.

We are now in the process of choosing a name. At least we only have to make one list, boy names. I may post some of our ideas in later articles; with our first two, we tried to choose names that would be significant. Our first, was named after a friend of mine from college who died about eight years ago. His mother is, of course, the adopted grandmother of all our children and we greatly appreciate her generous spirit. We gave our second, Melissa's maiden name, my middle name (which, by the way was my father's and his father's middle name) and Levi for purely aesthetic reasons. At the time of his birth,we thought he would be our last for sure, so we tried to get all the names in we could.

Prayers are always appreciated, and especially during our pregnancies. They always seem to be particularly difficult on her physically, but I won't go into detail about that...some of you already know . And after the baby is born, we will renew our concern for raising all our children in covenant with God. Fully aware of how imperfectly we do it, we are very grateful for the great influences God had in place for us just before our oldest was born (now 6); and for all the subsequent help provided to us from our parents and families; the encouragement provided by our friends; and most of all, God's gracious mercy to show us our sin through the Law, and to make us His sons and daughters by faith, through the power of Christ's Spirit in the proclamation of the gospel. May Melissa and I correct our children (and ourselves) with the Law of God and quickly proclaim the gospel of God's grace to them, for His glory and for our joy, Amen!

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Regarding the Continuity of the Role of the Holy Spirit in All Ages

One of the first passages mentioned in this discussion is Acts 2 and its reference to Joel 2.  The first thing I would say is that the purpose of the Pentecost event recorded in Acts 2 was to show the Jews that the Holy Spirit was going to be poured out on all nations, not just the Jewish nation.  It was a scandal to the Jews in Peter's day to think that someone could receive covenant blessings without first becoming a Jew, being circumcised.  The category they had for Holy Spirit indwelling had nothing to do with persons outside of the covenant.  So when they saw that individuals on the day of Pentecost were being filled with the Spirit, Peter had to explain that this day was prophesied by Joel; Peter told them the meaning of Joel chapter 2, and that (at least in part) it was fulfilled on that day when God poured out His Spirit, not just on believing Jews, but even on  uncircumcised believers from other nations.  The role of the Spirit in the New Covenant is primarily different in His scope, and only secondarily in extent.  In other words, the difference is primarily one of  a quantity of participants and secondarily one of a quality of experience.

Covenant Theology does affirm a measure of discontinuity between the role of the Holy Spirit in the Old and New Testaments.  Read this quote from D.A. Carson below,

"...the pulsating New Testament stance, especially strong in Paul, that sees the Holy Spirit in the life of the Christian and the church as the decisive evidence that the new age has dawned and the messianic reign has begun. The structure of New Testament eschatology is jeopardized by the failure to discern such distinctions."

But, Covenant Theology also submits that unless one has been translated from death to life by the Holy Spirit's work, he is not saved, regenerated, made right before God. 

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - III

Two posts ago I included a quote from Charles Ryrie in which he uses Acts 13:39 as an example of a major shift in the responsibility of man, and this indicates a change in administration, a change from one dispensation to another.

The false assumption that he seems to be making, one that is likely enforced by his hermeneutic, is that this statement in the book of Acts indicates that the saints in "The Age of Law" were required to obey the covenant law of Moses in order to be justified. In the very verse itself is the idea that this was never the case...it never was possible that the Law of Moses could justify. Covenant Theology would submit that the practice of those Old Covenant rituals were a part of the sanctification of the saints under that covenant, but never their justification.

Another, and related, outworking of the Dispensational hermenetical structure is that major shifts in what God has revealed to mankind are emphasized and are either caused by or the effect of the change from one dispensation to another. On the other hand, Covenant Theology places emphasis on the subtle shift of what God has reveled to mankind, not as indicators of a change in administration or dispensation, but rather, these shifts show that God cumulatively reveals knowledge about His relation to His creation and creatures.

Further Questions for Dispensationalists - II

There seems to be an historic Protestant way in which we have referred to the theological concept of justification. And if anyone reading this article can correct or expand my understanding here, particularly with a written source specifically on this subject, please do.

The ground of justification is the Passion of Christ; His life for our righteousness imputed, and His death for our sins atoned. The instrument of justification is faith.. The means of justification is the proclamation of the gospel and the Holy Spirit applying it.

Covenant Theology affirms that the entire formula above applies to justification in all ages. I believe that all types of Dispensationalism, generally speaking, would affirm this formula for what they call the "Age of Grace", or the "Church Age", and they too would affirm that the ground and instrument are the same in every age. The disagreement I believe would arise when we talk about the means in every age. It is here that I believe we get the reason for the oft heard claim that Dispensationalism teaches two "ways" of salvation. Though it seems to be clear that Darby, Scofield, Chafer and Ryrie would all deny this claim but, even if they would say that the means of justification in the "Age of Law" was the proclamation of the gospel, would they agree that the content of the gospel was the same? I think the answer is no. This begs the question, what is the content of the gospel?

According to Covenant Theology, the content of the gospel is always at least this, that God will (or already did depending on the perspective) provide the ultimate sacrifice to satisfy the demands of His Holiness. It is in the distinct expression of this promise that we find a difference as revelation progresses, but the shifts in the knowledge of the content of this promise are most often gradual: from the proto-evangel in the garden, to the salvation of Noah's family in the ark, to the substitute ram provided in the place of Isaac on Mount Moria, to the Suffering Servant desribed by Isaiah, on up to the culmination of all of those shadows in the revelation of Jesus on the cross.

On the other hand, Dispensationalism says (at least according to Ryrie, and this is where I need more information about other forms of Dispensationalism) that the content of that promise prior to the Church Age was not that specific, and that Old Testament saints did not necessarily have to see a coming Messiah/Redeemer in the shadows of the Old Covenant sacrifices, or that Abraham really only believed that God would bless him with many decendants and a physical land. Granted, these promises to Abraham, in their limited historical expression were very great promises which challenged the faith of Abraham, but to limit the content of his faith to just those things ignores the revelation previously provided for us. Though Abraham did not have a written copy of the pentetuch as the Jews later did, he would have had the stories of the garden and Noah to consider, and those types of Christ that would expand the content of his faith past what I believe Dispensationalism generally allows.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Further Questions for Dispensationalists

Another question for my dispensational friends is regarding Ryrie's distinction between the object of faith and the content of faith. In my assessment, this distinction is novel yet demanded as a consequence of a focus on the discontinuity between the Old and New Covenants (between the dispensations as they would say), but I would like to hear your thoughts on this. Below are two quotes from Charles Ryrie concerning this issue,

‘Through Him everyone who believes is freed [justified] from all things, from which you could not be freed [justified] through the Law of Moses’ (Acts 13:39). Here is unquestionably a distinguishable and different way of running the affairs of the world regarding man's responsibility in relation to the most important area of justification. Whatever his responsibility was under the Mosaic Law may be left unspecified at present (see chapter 6), but with the coming of Christ the requirement for justification became faith in Him. This, too, is obviously a distinctive stage in the progress of revelation. Therefore, we conclude that a new dispensation was inaugurated, since the economy and responsibility changed and the new revelation was given.”- Dispensationalism Today

"The basis of salvation in every age is the death of Christ; the requirement for salvation in every age is faith; the object of faith in every age is God; the content of faith changes in the various dispensations. It is this last point, of course, that distinguishes dispensationalism from covenant theology, but it is not a point to which the charge of teaching two ways of salvation can be attached. It simply recognizes the obvious fact of progressive revelation." - Dispensationalism Today

I now am wondering if this is consistent with the current form of argumentation regarding the "way" saints from previous ages were saved.

Friday, August 29, 2008

Addendum to Last Post

In my last post I called for the recommendations from Dispensationalists for sources citing the definition and defense of any form of that position. I mentioned in that post, several representatives of the faceted position, but I did fail to mention the proponents of what is called, "Progressive Dispensationalism". Craig Blaising and Darrell Bock are two of the major proponents, as well as Robert Saucey. After some prompting, I felt compeled to mention their names.

Monday, August 25, 2008

Calling All Dispensationalists, of Whatever Stripe or Shade

I am in the process of composing an essay on the differing hermeneutical assumptions of the Dispensational and Covenantal systems of theology, and their consequences on bible interpretation. In this process I have already consulted several sources on both sides of the issue. Of course I am writing from the side of Covenantal Theology, and in the progress of the essay I will argue that position. Even though I grew up in and was somewhat nurtured into Dispensational Theology, I still would like those who still hold that view to aid in my choices of sources for representation of that position, and its historical survey.

For instance, from the Brethren camp I have read and/or cited J.N. Darby, C.H. Mackintosh, and T.B. Baines. From the Fundamentalist Baptist camp, C.I. Scofield, L.S. Chafer, J. D. Pentecost, John Walvoord, and the more contemporary, Charles Ryrie. From the more progressive camp (and perhaps Calvinistic Dispensationalists) Michael Vlach, John MacArthur, Barry Horner, and Dennis Swanson.

I am making a call now to any dispensationalist reading this blog, to help me to quote the best sources in the areas of: scholastic/academic Dispensationalism, and surveys of that theology's occurrence in history made by trustworthy Dispensational sources.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

The Not-So Surprising Parallel Between the Hippie Movement and the Jesus People Movement

I've been listening to an interview with Stephen Nichols on the White Horse Inn. He has written a book recently called, "Jesus, Made in America".

Part of the discussion included a brief mention of the "Jesus People Movement" of the 70's. In this, Nichols described how many of those who gathered to talk about Jesus without conforming to the popularly established forms of clothing and music associated with going to church, had later in life finally traded in their long hair and headbands for a feathers cut and necktie, and started to sell insurance.

A similar thing happened with the individuals from the Hippie movement. The same ones who gathered to talk about world peace and social injustices without conforming to the popularly established forms of clothing and ethical standards, had later in life finally traded in their peace sign and tabs of acid for dollar signs and a half glass of Pinot Noir.

I find this parallel fascinating and I think it only makes sense when we consider that there is a strong historical argument suggesting that, in large measure, those individuals in Jesus People Movement came out of the Hippie Movement.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

What Does It Mean to Pray?

Whether one hales from a Calvinistic theology of God's providence or not, prayer really is a difficult thing for us finite creatures to wrap our minds around. As a matter of fact, we can't wrap our minds around this idea, and I don't think god intends for us to. All He would have us know about prayer in this age He has revealed in His Word and we can ascertain through our collaborative review of the historical, biblical and systematic theologies of prayer.

Prayer can be illustrated in this way. When I pray it is a bit like me throwing my self with my earnest desires against the immutable Rock of God's will and he chips away at my desires so as to make me look more like His Son the Christ, in Who's Image I have been re-created.

In obedience to His command for His children to come to Him in prayer, I humbly submit my requests, mediated by the righteousness of Christ before His throne, expecting him to do all His holy will, and wait for Him to work all things together for good, for those who love Him.

Friday, August 15, 2008

Communicating the Doctrine of the Trinity Through Analogy

Whenever different theologians have tried in the past to devise various illustrations to better explain the Trinity on human terms, they have often gotten into trouble; some for trying to work the analogous picture too far, and others who simply have used the description in a limited sense but their audience misunderstood them to be saying that "God is only like this...".

So, naturally, I'll have to tread these dangerous waters.  But one caveat before I do, I want to it absolutely clear that I don't think that this illustration is by any means complete, thorough or perfect as a depiction of the mystery of the Triune God or His work in creation.  Note that a portion of this illustration has shamelessly been adapted from an analogy (I assume) that was invented by Kim Riddlebarger to describe the process of progressive revelation.  With that, here goes.

Imagine that you are in a darkened room.  No lights; it's as pitch as the darkest, starless, moonless rural night.  Imagine God as a man who stands outside the room and speaks to you.  You can only hear Him and the only things you know about Him are the things He has spoken to you through the door.  Even the things you know about the darkened room in which you sit are limited to your vain sensual perception and what He has told you about the room.  Imagine that one day, God opens the door just slightly and reaches His arm in and turns on the light in the room.  You are absolutely amazed by what you see.  The elements and character of the room are exactly as God had described them.  You call out to God, and because all you see is the arm, and ask, "God, is that You?".  God replies "yes, it is Me."

Obviously, God turning the light on represents what happened when He came in Christ to proclaim the Kingdom and explained the purposes of the Old Covenant cultic rituals.  But when you ask, "God is that You?" and He answers yes, even though all you saw of Him was a hand, we know that God is more than just a hand, but just as if I was to quietly sneak around a corner of my house into a room occupied by my sons, and if they saw part of my body and cried out, "Dad, is that you?".  even though the portion of my body they saw is only part of me, I can still say, and would say, yes, it is me.  Likewise, Jesus IS God, but He is not all that God is.  God is Father Son and Holy Spirit.

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Covenantal Hermeneutical Presuppositions and Their Logical Sequence

Below I have Included a revised edition of the covenantal hermeneutics I listed in a post a week ago or so. I have attempted to place the items in this list in a logical order, one that follows another in their function.
 
I.                    Let easily interpreted passages guide our interpretation of difficult passages. 
a.        
                                           i.      Let the interpretation of the fulfillment of Old Testament prophesies/promises found in the New Testament amplify/expand the grammatical/historical understanding of a particular prophesy when it was given.
                                             ii.      When a promise is made, the object of promise is always, to some degree, a shadow or type of the object of fulfillment; so if the fulfillment of a promise is limited to its "literal" or grammatical/historical manifestation, then it isn't as illustrative of God's goodness. But if the quality of the object of fulfillment is to be accurately represented by the object of promise, it cannot always be limited to its grammatical/historical manifestation.
1.      Christ is the ultimate fulfillment of the types and shadows pictured in the Old Testament, so in that way, all the Old Testament points forward to Christ and not to a future manifestation of ethnic Israel, but Christ is the true Israel and those found “in Him” are true Israelites.
b.       
                                               i.      Let our understanding of the immediate context of a passage be interpreted under the larger umbrella of the entire context of Revelation; the "meta-narrative" or "big picture" perspective of redemptive history should be used to tailor our understanding of the immediate contexts of passages, such as the context provided by their human authorship, chronology in respect to other writings of Revelation, and literary genre.
                               ii.      Let the literary genre of a passage guide our understanding of symbols, types/shadows, parables, numbers, and prophesies (either their giving or fulfillment) i.e., historical narratives such as the gospel accounts of resurrection should be taken at face value, but apocalyptic literature when it presents visions such as dragons, lamp stands, 24 elders, etc, they may be symbols which represent something greater. The objects they represent either, could not have been understood if their future manifestation had been presented, or God has decided that the objects being represented are meant to be kept a mystery in part, until such a time when He sees fit to reveal their identity. Note that the object being symbolized is normally a literal and real object.

Monday, August 11, 2008

What Does It Mean to be The Church?

George Barna and Fred Viola have collaborated in a book called, "Pagan Christianity", and Barna in other sources has stated similar opinions regarding the impractical nature of the local church as its practice has been since the Reformation, and as I see it, the way it was established in the first century.

With the differences over several forms of polity aside (Episcopal, Presbyterian, and Congregational) the way in which a local church is to function is never to be established by what we believe "works". Granted, no individual local church or denominational polity is enacted perfectly, no matter how closely it operates to the biblical mandate of its existence, it remains the community of creatures yet to be glorified.


Though Mike Horton in an article at the White Horse Inn has already accurately critiqued Barna's position, I too will take a stab.


I think that it is clear that Horton isn’t suggesting that the layperson neglect personal Bible study just that, contrary to Barna’s heterodox conclusions, shepherds are not trying to work themselves out of a job as it were As Horton points out, “The church’s min-istry is exercised faithfully when the people are fed, not when the sheep are expected to become their own shepherds.”

Here are a few disturbing quotes from Barna:

“Ours is not the business of organized religion, corporate worship, or Bible teaching. If we dedicate ourselves to such a business we will be left by the wayside as the culture moves forward. Those are fragments of a larger purpose to which we have been called by God’s Word. We are in the business of life transformation.”–George Barna, The Second Coming of the Church (Nashville: Word, 1998), 96.

“Believers need not find a good church, but they should “get a good coach.”–Barna, The Second Coming of the Church, 68, 138-40.

Once the PRIMARY reasons we gather together at a local church become something other than to worship God by “hearing the gospel preached”, and to participate in the sacraments rightly administered, and to submit ourselves to the discipline of the elders, then we are skewing the purpose of God in the local body. When Christ told Peter to feed His sheep, it wasn’t the pragmatic feeding of the food of self help or “moralistic therapy” or the fickle “felt needs” of each individual layperson, it was the food of the gospel that Christ was commanding Peter (and all elders following)to feed His sheep.

There certainly are SECONDARY and even byproduct reasons for gathering: worship through fellowship, catechizes, and other implements of sanctification, but these can never be elevated to the preaching and hearing of the gospel and the viewing of it in the sacraments of baptism and the Supper.

Somehow, I think that when we have a hermeneutic that doesn’t lead us to Christ and His gospel as we interpret all of the OT and NT, the result is that a vacuum is created that we try to fill with our “felt” needs.


In conclusion, it's hard not to question Barna's adherance to the doctrine of sola scriptura when he is so zealous to take a pragmatic approach to, not just the re-structuring of local church government, but really his willingness to promote its total dismantling.

Thursday, August 7, 2008

Clearing Up Confusion Over Distinctions #19

Below are more of Zaspel's words on Rev. 20.

“Reigning


Then there is the matter of "reigning" and the consideration that this period has a specific time of duration -- one thousand years. Premillennialists assert that the "reigning" of those of the first resurrection is one that involves rule over the lost. It is an authority exercised over rebellious men. This fits well with Rev.2:25-27, where a "rod of iron" is promised to the faithful when Christ returns (cf. 19:15). An iron rod is necessary only in a world of sin. For the amillennialist, on the other hand, the reigning is a spiritual one only, in either of two senses: 1) in the sense of a heavenly vindication of some kind in the intermediate state, or 2) in the sense of the believer's spiritual reigning "in Christ." Neither idea, however, is allowed by the text. 1) The term translated "they came to life" ( ezesan) is nowhere in the NT used to describe the continued life of the soul in heaven after the death of the body. Never. It speaks of life after death only in resurrection. It indicates the final state, not the intermediate. Furthermore, the picture presented in Rev.6:9-11 of the saints in heaven during the intermediate state is far from that of "reigning": they are crying out to the Lord for vengeance to be executed upon their oppressors still on earth. In response they are told to "rest" and be patient until the number of martyrs is complete. The situation in chapter 20, however, is the answer to this: when Christ comes in His kingdom, only then will they be raised to reign with Him. Finally, now, their time of vindication has come. And 2) while the term is used outside of the book of Revelation in a spiritual sense (e.g., Jn.5:25), we must ask, In what sense can spiritual reigning be said to last only a thousand years? Will that kind of reign not continue forever? And is it not so that we should expect suffering today and reigning only tomorrow (2Tim.2:12)? Again, the amillennialist suggestion seems neither to rise from nor fit the demands of the passage.”


Zaspel’s assumptions here are clear, that the terms “reigning” and “rod of iron” logically indicate the perfect obedience of those being reigned, that those who reign cannot be “crying out to the Lord for vindication”; the two ideas are antithetical, that Amillennialists DON’T consider the millennium to be a “specific time of duration”, that those reigning are saints who have been resurrected into glorified bodies and those who are reigned are unbelievers (those unbelievers over whom they reign are yet in their physical bodies—such an interpretation should raise several questions). As for the nature of spiritual reigning, there is certainly no warrant by biblical or systematic theology to suggest that it must be exactly the same in this age and the age to come. Also, the dichotomy between the “reigning” in Rev. 20 and suffering is falsely imposed.


And in the following section from "John's Use of the OT", he quotes hymnodist and Greek scholar Henry Alfred.


“The famous admonition of Henry Alford concerning arbitrary interpretation in Rev.20 merits repeating here:


‘As regards the text itself, no legitimate treatments of it will extort what is known as the spiritual interpretation now in fashion. If, in a passage where two resurrections are mentioned, where certain psychai ezesan ["souls came to life"] at the first, and the rest of the nekroi ezesan ["dead came to life"] only at the end of a specified period after the first, -- if in such a passage the first resurrection may be understood to mean spiritual rising with Christ, while the second means literal rising from the grave; -- then there is an end of all significance in language, and Scripture is wiped out as a definite testimony to anything.’


Alford's criticism is a valid one. It is demonstrably evident that the interpreter who admits no inter-regnum period prior to the eternal state in Rev.20 approaches the passage with preconceived notions and leaves with the same; he gains from the text "neither the exact sense nor the value."”


I can't help but think that if Alfred's line of reasoning was consistently applied to all the New Testament, then he and Zaspel both would not end up as Calvinists, at least not the variety that espouses particular redemption. Because, at least as one makes a surface reading of certain texts such as 2 Peter 3:9, 1 John 2:2, and others, one could conclude that God intends to save every living soul, but when one begins to place these texts in the greater context of all of revelation, one will soon see that not all persons are saved and he becomes an advocate of a preveinient sort of redemptive grace for "all" or "the whole world", but hopefully, soon after that, when one continues to contextualize the atonement through the testaments, one becomes an advocate of particular redemption, but not through what Alfred would call a "legitimate treatment". Again, we see that our interpretations come directly from our operating assumptions; how we reason through scripture texts. And at least at the point of Rev. 20, both Alfred and Zaspel refuse to admit that their interpretation is tied to any assumption about how to come to a conclusion regarding scripture.


At this point I plan to pause in my critique of Zaspel's essay and discuss in more depth, the hermeneutical assumptions of Premillenialist and Covenant Theologians.


Thus it can be said of Zaspel’s conclusions in general (as laid out in his essay, “The Kingdom The Millennium, and The Eschaton”, that he does just what he has repeatedly accused the Amillennialist of, reading the text in light of assumptions, but his own Premillennial grid of assumptions causes interpretations which have their own difficulties to which he is blinded because he appears unwilling to admit to the existence of and examine those hermeneutical operating assumptions from which his interpretations flow.

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Clearing Up Confusion Over Distinctions #18

After a short hiatus from blogging, here is the next installment of my critique of Zaspel's essay.

“It is equated with the resurrection of "the rest of the dead" (v.5), which all sides admit is physical. There is exactly no evidence within the text itself which would indicate a change in the meaning of words, no hint at all that the two resurrections spoken of are of a different nature. Much to the contrary, to shift in mid-stream without express warrant from the text is exegetical chaos. Further, the term ezesan (v.4, "they lived, they came to life," ingressive aorist) elsewhere in the book of Revelation refers only to bodily resurrection (2:8; 13:14), and never is it used in a spiritualized sense. Moreover, the resurrection of these in verse 4 is said to follow, not precede, their faithfulness -- a consideration which allows only a physical resurrection. Once again, the amillennial interpretation, here, rests on presuppositions imported to the passage and that against the most natural reading of the text; it is not grounded in exegesis. And again, if it is wrong at this point, we are left with premillennialism.”


The first thing that should be said is that, it is right to look at the content of the text at hand and its immediate context when we begin to interpret a text. Soon after that, even if he has already come to some conclusions, the reader should look at the concentric contexts in which the passage finds itself: the context of the book or letter and its author, where in the progress of revelation was it given, and finally, the context of the entirety of revelation and the context of redemptive history. It seems to me that many times the dispensational Pre-millennialist in particular (and we all are guilty of this at times) tries to interpret the text in its immediate context alone, often ignoring the type of literature it is (the context of the book itself, and the purpose of the human author), and its place in redemptive history. So in a certain limited sense, this interpreter can claim that he is viewing the passage “in context”. But because of his operating assumptions (probably the exclusively grammatical/historical fulfillment of prophecy, or what is often referred to the “literal” interpretation of ALL prophecy, and that of the sharp distinction of spiritual Israel and the Church) he will not allow for the analogy of faith (to allow the principle of the right interpretation of simpler passages to interpret the more difficult to trump immediate context), or for the context of literary genre, or for the over-arching purposes of God in redemptive history to be his boundaries when interpreting prophesy. I think it is these things, perhaps among others, that help lead Zaspel to his interpretation of Revelation 20, and thus guide his understanding of resurrections in this chapter. This is why he can make a statement like, “There is exactly no evidence within the text itself which would indicate a change in the meaning of words, no hint at all that the two resurrections spoken of are of a different nature.”


He goes on to say this, “Much to the contrary, to shift in mid-stream without express warrant from the text is exegetical chaos.” Zaspel is looking for “express warrant” “from the text” alone to allow for the two resurrections spoken of to be different but in symphony. He has decided that it is chaotic to allow any other interpretive help outside the exegesis of this text alone to define the vocabulary of this text; in his mind, the immediate context alone has the authority to give definition to the words.


Lastly, Zaspel accuses Amillennialists of impressing their presuppositions on the text of Rev. 20 in order to spin out their notion of two types of resurrections there, the one being the resurrection of regeneration in this age, and the other being the resurrection of the physically dead to physical life. At the same time, he claims that he has no external hermeneutical principle that colors his view of the resurrections in the passage, that the plain reading of the text alone is enough to come to the conclusion he has. But I say that, when one assumes the premillennial position (especially if he does not think that it too derives from a set of hermeneutical assumptions) and refuses to have the immediate context of a particular passage checked by the greater context of redemptive history or to have his understanding of it filtered through the more easily understandable texts in the rest of scripture, then his interpretation in my opinion, can end up being isolated and individualistic instead of communal and confessional.